An Ahp Framework of Supplier Evaluation with Reference to High Value and Critical Items: a Case Study

In: Business and Management

Submitted By deborpita
Words 7789
Pages 32
Int. J. Services and Operations Management, Vol. 7, No. 4, 2010


An AHP framework of supplier evaluation with reference to high-value and critical items: a case study Debadyuti Das*
Faculty of Management Studies University of Delhi 110 007 Delhi, India E-mail: *Corresponding author

Deepak Barman
Faculty of Management Studies Banaras Hindu University 221 005 Varanasi, India E-mail:
Abstract: This study developed a simple two-stage decision framework for evaluating suppliers of high-value and critical items with reference to a heavy engineering organisation by employing the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). The first stage involved examining the qualifying criteria of the items on quality, while the second stage was concerned with identifying all other relevant attributes, including quality concerning high-value and critical items applicable to the organisation under study, and with finding out the relative importance of the same. The attributes were organised in a two-tier hierarchy showing four major criteria in the first tier and 17 subcriteria in the second tier. This enabled us to employ AHP to find out the relative importance of each individual subcriterion through pair-wise comparison between all major criteria and subcriteria by eliciting opinions from three experts. The findings indicated the quality/reliability of the items to be the most important criterion, followed by price and then technological capability of the suppliers. A group of five suppliers was evaluated on all 17 subcriteria with regard to their performance and the overall performance of the suppliers was compared on the factor scores obtained by each supplier. Keywords: supplier evaluation; analytic hierarchy process; AHP; high-value and critical items. Reference to this paper should be made as follows: Das, D. and Barman, D.…...

Similar Documents

Case Studies in Finance - Managing for Corporate Value Creation,

...MBA Program Course: Financial Analysis and Decision Making MBA730 Instructor: Marlena L. Akhbari Wright State University Finance and Financial Services McGraw-Hill/Irwin =>? McGraw−Hill Primis ISBN: 0−390−42334−3 Text: Case Studies in Finance: Managing for Corporate Value Creation, 4/e Bruner This book was printed on recycled paper. MBA Program Copyright ©2003 by The McGraw−Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. Except as permitted under the United States Copyright Act of 1976, no part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in a database or retrieval system, without prior written permission of the publisher. This McGraw−Hill Primis text may include materials submitted to McGraw−Hill for publication by the instructor of this course. The instructor is solely responsible for the editorial content of such materials. 111 MBAP ISBN: 0−390−42334−3 MBA Program Contents Bruner • Case Studies in Finance: Managing for Corporate Value Creation, 4/e II. Financial Analysis and Forecasting 1 1 6 16 16 39 52 52 60 66 66 84 100 100 6. The Financial Detective, 1996 11. ServerVault: ‘‘Reliable, Secure, and Wicked Fast’’ III. Estimating the Cost of Capital 12. ‘‘Best Practices’’ in Estimating the Cost of Capital: Survey and Synthesis 15. Teletech Corporation, 1996 IV. Capital Budgeting and Resource Allocation 19.......

Words: 54708 - Pages: 219

R&D Project Selection Using the Ahp

...factors complicating this task is the need to make the decision within the framework of an enterprise’s strategic objectives and organizational structure while considering and integrating financial and strategic benefits of each project. The paper discusses the use of the ANP, a general form of Saaty’s analytic hierarchy process, as a model to evaluate the value of competing R&D project proposals. A generic ANP model developed by the authors, which includes in its decision levels the actors involved in the decision, the stages of research, categories of metrics, and individual metrics, is presented. The paper concludes with a case study describing the implementation of this model at a small high-tech company, including data based on the actual use of the decision making model. Index Terms—Analytic hierarchy process, analytic network process, multicriteria decision making, project selection, R&D management, R&D projects. I. INTRODUCTION OR MANY firms, especially those that depend on innovation to stay in business, the key to continued competitiveness lies in their ability to develop and implement new products and processes. For these organizations, research and development (R&D) is an integral function within the strategic management framework. Even firms with excellent technical skills must work within the limits of available funding and resources. R&D project selection and funding decisions, then, are critical if the organization is to stay in business. While there are......

Words: 6750 - Pages: 27

Jefferson High School Case Study

...Follow-Up # 4 Jefferson High Case Study ED. 673 – Spring, 2013 Section: C.400.13SP Professor: Mary Bea Preston April 25, 2013 Part A: Issues related to teaching and learning and the larger context As we have studied this semester and prior to, teaching and learning is the foundation of school improvement. In the Jefferson High School case study, it is evident that a focus on the instructional design and development of teachers is essential to the reestablishment of its success. It is important for the leader to recognize and consider the larger context and the effect of the issues related to teaching and learning in order to build a positive and sustainable culture Jefferson High School has had tremendous shifting for approximately seven years, which has affected the school culture and is subsequently shown according to the state assessment data. There are several examples of teaching dysfunctions including (i) low expectations with students being viewed as problems rather than valued learners (ii) professional development and collaboration is nonexistent where teachers and administrators have been slow to change to meet the educational needs of the current students and (iii) new ideas, approaches or suggestions for improvement bring complaints, criticism and distrust. As a result, functions of learning have been affected including (i) low interest in post-secondary education (ii) poor academic performance on all measures and (iii) deteriorated morale...

Words: 3411 - Pages: 14

Critical Thinking Case Study

...Critical Thinking Case Study GEN/480 University of Phoenix Lisa Stansfield To the CEO of AcuScan: Here is a last report that I have devised for you which explains the up-to-date circumstances at AcuScan and a few suggestions and actions that ought to be taken and the reason. Chris Martinas, VP of Product Development and Pat Lambert, the new Director of Marketing have been collaborating on a new product that has to be initiated by the final part of the year. The new product happens to be the iScanner, which they have previously promoted except it will have new features, which makes it new and more advanced. The two of them have been figuring out a way to lower the budget by 15% and try not to not dismiss current employees. They have the funds of 400 K to use and have to convene with the right departments to launch the project. There was a problem through the emails among Pat Lambert and Kelly Thomas, Chief Engineer of Product Software. Kelly designed the original iScanner that was the groundbreaker in the developing retinal scanning security business. After discussing with you about the making of the product and not going outside 400K, Chris emailed Pat and Kelly on the way to do that and the way they could reach the deadline in August. The initial reply to that email was from Pat Lambert, the email was very optimistic and stated how Lambert did not think that it was going to be an issue to generate. The email after that was from Kelly saying that the team was placing...

Words: 1321 - Pages: 6

Competing Values Case Study

...Case Study - Toyota Motors / (The Competing Organizational Values Framework) In 1937, Kiichiro Toyoda founded the Toyota Motor Company in Japan as a spin-off from Toyoda Automatic Loom Works to manufacture cars roughly based on the designs of Chrysler and Chevrolet. Toyota emerged from the rubble of war in the late 1950s to become Asia’s premiere manufacturing company and swiftly moved from a regional to a global brand. Gaining a foothold in the United States during the oil embargo of the 1970s, Toyota systematically extended its product array from compact cars, like the Corolla, to mid-size sedans. In the late 1980s, Toyota accomplished the previously unimaginable by successfully introducing, Lexus, a luxury car line to compete with European blue bloods BMW and Mercedes. In fact, the newly introduced Lexus established previously unimaginable initial quality records, and may be said to have been the car that most sparked the quality revolution in the North American auto industry. Today, Toyota is Japan’s biggest carmaker with over $120 billion in annual sales. Toyota is one the few companies that has demonstrated an ability to pursue several directions simultaneously. The traditional organizational identity at Toyota was highly focused and internally directed. Perfecting “lean production” and “just in time” manufacturing techniques, Toyota became symbolized by quality and efficiency which made it a benchmark for automobile manufacturing worldwide. Engineering,......

Words: 1127 - Pages: 5

Critical Thinking Case Study

...Critical Thinking Case Study GEN/480 Interdisciplinary Capstone Course March 3, 2011 Norton Brainard III Case Study Part I: Analysis 1. Describe all assumptions seen in any of documents provided in the case study . a. Kelly: Had the assumption that with a project like this it was putting the company on the line. Furthermore the quality of service with little staff may prove impossible. Kelly also assumed that the company was only interested in putting the product out and they were not concern about Quality Control (QC). Another assumption that was pointed out is what exactly the company wanted done could not be considering the workload that they were given two years ago proved to be a challenger and the had more workers it is nearly possible now with the shortage of employees. b. Pat: Is insisted on the only way to bring the company back to where it was ten years ago is to expand and do it quickly because other are doing the same with their companies. Although he had an confidential source he think that the company Secu-A-Corp will be bring out a similar product within in months therefore he wants to move quickly. The anticipated cost he assumed was based on the initial analysis , he also added a significant amount for staffing time in order to reach a product launch goal, not taking in consideration of the changes within the staff and the fact that the company has begun to lose revenue and had to make cut back. He assumes the return on......

Words: 2189 - Pages: 9

Critical Analysis Self Evaluation (Case)

...A critical analysis of your leadership competence In this assessment, you are required to undertake a critical analysis of your personal competence in leadership. You will do this by working through the four elements of this unit set out below. 1. Communicate organisational mission and goals 2. Influence groups and individuals 3. Build and support teams 4. Demonstrate personal and professional competence Your analysis needs to consider the range of theories and practices of leadership explored during the subject (ideally using a minimum of two theories and four chapters). Your work must strongly reflect the material covered in this subject - but our focus is on your view of its practical application. You may analyse leadership in your current or previous workplace, an experience of leadership you may have had in an organisation or, if this is not possible, your thoughts on effective organisational leadership. You need to ensure your analysis is critical: that is that it looks both at the strengths and weaknesses of leadership strategies and that evaluates the effectiveness of your own or other’s leadership approaches. Analysing organisational leadership Introduction In this task, we look at how we interpret and analyse organisational leadership. The task is specifically designed to help you in the development of your final assessment for Providing Leadership Across the Organisation. Before looking at some of the forms of analysis we might use,......

Words: 1264 - Pages: 6

Ahp and Other

...Venkata Decision making in the manufacturing environment : using graph theory and fuzzy multiple attribute decision making methods. - (Springer series in advanced manufacturing) 1. Production management - Decision making 2. Graph theory 3. Fuzzy decision making 4. Multiple criteria decision making I. Title 658.5’036 ISBN-13: 9781846288180 Library of Congress Control Number: 2007926809 Springer Series in Advanced Manufacturing ISSN 1860-5168 ISBN 978-1-84628-818-0 e-ISBN 978-1-84628-819-7 Printed on acid-free paper © Springer-Verlag London Limited 2007 Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers. The use of registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher makes no representation, express or implied, with regard to the accuracy of the information contained in this book and cannot accept any legal responsibility or liability......

Words: 75183 - Pages: 301

Critical Care Case Study

...Critical Care Case Study Crystal Meyer Mohave Community College Nursing 222 Mrs. Michelle Christensen April 1, 2014 Critical Care Case Study ADMISSION TC is a 61-year-old English speaking Caucasian female born on April 29, 1952. She weighs 99.7 Kg and is 5 feet, 5 inches in height with a BMI of 35.84. On March 5, 2014, TC was brought into the emergency department after her daughter-in-law called 911 when she found TC unresponsive at home in her bathroom. When paramedics arrived, she was found to be cool, pale, and diaphoretic with oxygen saturations in the high 70’s. Emergency responders placed a non-rebreather high flow oxygen mask and her oxygenation began to improve with saturations in the low 90’s. Upon arrival to the emergency department, TC’s vital signs were as follows: T 97.4; P 97; BP 120/95 mm Hg; RR 15 per minute; and O2 sats of 98% via NRB oxygen mask on 8L. A chest x-ray (CXR) revealed no abnormality and lungs were determined to be grossly clear. However, TC was checked for a pulmonary embolism via a pulmonary artery angiogram with IV contrast and found to have a large clot burden with a small saddle embolism. TC also complained of right ankle pain. An X-ray of her right ankle revealed a distal tib/fib fracture, which was presumed to be related to her fall during her hypoxic episode. With these findings, TC was admitted to the Intensive Care Unit of Kingman Regional Medical Center and placed on an NPO diet in preparation for placement of an inferior......

Words: 4071 - Pages: 17

Case: Reducing Supplier Evaluation Cycle Time

...results of a study that showed concept-to-customer new product development cycle times were getting shorter by 50 percent every five years. While in some industries this rate of change was less severe, in other industries the rate of change was even more rapid for example refer table below. History of Automotive industry to reduce time to design and produce new car: Year when occur the strategy to reduce time | Time cycle to design and produce new car | 1990 | 48 months= 4yrs | Mid 1990 | 36 months=3 yrs | Late 1990 | 24 months=2 yrs | mid1980s to 2003 | 18 months= 1.5yrs | As Emily thought about what she had heard, she came to two conclusions. First, the food products industry was beginning to see the same kinds of market pressures that rapidly changing industries, such as automobiles and electronics, have experienced for many years. For example, she knew that the life cycles of her company’s products were getting shorter and shorter. Second, Emily knew very well that while not all supplier evaluation and selection decisions originated during the development of new products, many of the critical selection decisions were the result of new product needs. Other point that Emily was very interesting is analyze to reduce the time it takes to evaluate and select suppliers by 30 percent, 40 percent, or even 50 percent. Questions: 1. Why should companies commit time and resources to evaluate and select suppliers? The evaluation and selection of supplier is......

Words: 676 - Pages: 3


...Educational, Economic and Management Engineering Vol:7, No:10, 2013 Supplier Selection Criteria and Methods in Supply Chains: A Review Om Pal, Amit Kumar Gupta, R. K. Garg International Science Index Vol:7, No:10, 2013 Abstract—An effective supplier selection process is very important to the success of any manufacturing organization. The main objective of supplier selection process is to reduce purchase risk, maximize overall value to the purchaser, and develop closeness and long-term relationships between buyers and suppliers in today’s competitive industrial scenario. The literature on supplier selection criteria and methods is full of various analytical and heuristic approaches. Some researchers have developed hybrid models by combining more than one type of selection methods. It is felt that supplier selection criteria and method is still a critical issue for the manufacturing industries therefore in the present paper the literature has been thoroughly reviewed and critically analyzed to address the issue. Keywords—Supplier selection, Mathematical Programming. AHP, ANP, TOPSIS, I. INTRODUCTION I N most industries, the cost of raw materials and component parts represents the largest percentage of the total product cost. For instance, in high technology firms, purchased materials and services account for up to 80% of the total product cost. Therefore, selecting the right suppliers is the key to procurement process and represents a major......

Words: 6221 - Pages: 25

Ahp Site Selection Study

...Project Selection: A MCDM approach Site Selection for Hydro Power Plant using Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) Outline: NHPC Limited (Formerly known as National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd.), A Govt. of India Enterprise was established with the objective to plan, promote and organize an integrated and efficient development of hydroelectric power in all aspects. Since its inception in 1975, NHPC has grown to become one of the largest organizations in the field of hydropower development in the country. With its present capabilities, NHPC can undertake all activities from concept to commissioning of Hydroelectric Projects. The Case describes an AHP based approach to evaluate the sites among those identified to potentially set up hydroelectric power plants beyond the XI Plan. Introduction NHPC Limited (Formerly known as National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd.), A Govt. of India Enterprise, was incorporated in the year 1975 with an authorized capital of Rs. 2000 million and with an objective to plan, promote and organize an integrated and efficient development of hydroelectric power in all aspects.   Later on NHPC expanded its objects to include development of power in all its aspects through conventional and non-conventional sources in India and abroad. At present, NHPC is a Mini Ratna Category-I Enterprise of the Govt. of India with an authorized share capital of Rs. 1,50,000 Million. With an investment base of over Rs.3,17,000 Million Approx. ,......

Words: 3056 - Pages: 13

Critical Thinking Case Study

...Critical Thinking Case Study This case study is written from a critical thinking case study provided by the University Of Phoenix. This case study involves Faith Community Hospital a not for profit hospital that has many problems. The major problem described in this paper will be about the need for policies and procedures and there implementation. This hospital seems to have poor procedural discipline or no procedures at all to follow. The Problem or Problems The problems as they are described in the case study appear to be procedural and leadership issues but mostly there appears to be a financial problem. The cause of the financial problem has many reasons. The problem that I can extract from the text is that costs are higher and patient numbers are down. This hospitals management needs to develop a better management strategy and lead their employees. Faith Hospital has a mission statement that provides some corporate direction. The Mission statement is currently contradicting the management's current strategy. Faiths mission statement is as follows (Unknown) "With the foundation and commitment of our spiritual heritage And values, our mission is to promote the health and well-being of the people in the communities we serve through a comprehensive continuum of services provided in collaboration with the partners who share the same vision and values  This mission statement provides some direction from management for the hospital but it is not being followed by the......

Words: 394 - Pages: 2

Sole Remaining Supplier Case Study

...“The Case of the Sole Remaining Supplier” demonstrates one of the many instances where individuals must contemplate their moral standards in reflective issues. In the situation disclosed in the case, readers are presented with a layout of facts where they are on the board of directors for a company that makes transistors and supplies them to other companies, one of which includes a business where the transistors are used to make pacemakers. Your company has now become the only remaining supplier of transistors since other companies would not sell to them. Because a company that sells malfunctioning products are held accountable for consequences caused by defects, risk is at hand. Ethical affairs, less clearcut than business issues, consist of the concerns of your contractee. If your company halts supply of transistors to the Pacemaker company, they will have no other source of transistor inventory. Given these details, moral issues arise with your company being the origin of the involuntary shutdown of pacemaker manufacturing, depriving heart patients of their sole option of heart rate normalcy. Essentially, if you terminate your contract with the Pacemaker company, heart patients in need of the pacemaker will die. While business interests simply commend individuals to think economically efficient, morality often comes into play under circumstances as such, validating the disparities between a company’s principles as an object and staff virtues as human beings. With the......

Words: 1306 - Pages: 6

Case Study Value Alignment

...Coca-Cola Company we strive to refresh the world, inspire moments of optimism and happiness, create value and make a difference.” The company has many successes to learn and be inspired from (History of Coca-Cola). Excellent background – focus on creating a strong thesis statement that identifies your paper’s objective. Origin and Subsequent Evolution of Values The personal and workplace values of our team are much the same including core values like integrity, teamwork, performance, and learning. Acting ethical and developing trust and respect in the workplace is important. Integrity to me means honesty, trustworthiness, and respect. Teamwork involves sharing an open communication with other employees. Performance is based on the determination to strive for flawless performance in the workplace. Our team view of learning consists of possessing the necessary skills and training needed to perform a given duty. Our team’s individual values are based on doing the right thing and treating all people equally and with respect. In the workplace, individuals must act ethically and treat everyone with respect. What is the origin of values? Where do they originate? Values that drive actions and behaviors In our personal and professional life, values are beliefs we strongly adhere to daily. The observing of our family, religious leaders, educators, or employers our individual values can emerge. Measures taken to accomplish an objective are actions. Actions happen......

Words: 1327 - Pages: 6