“Analysis on Main Advantages and Disadvantages of Devolution and Fiscal Federalism: Is a Hybrid Solution the Cure?”

In: Business and Management

Submitted By minigp
Words 1232
Pages 5
“Analysis on main advantages and disadvantages of devolution and fiscal federalism: is a hybrid solution the cure?”

All countries in the world, regardless their degree of development, size, complexity or their form of government, must tackle an important choice when it comes to decide how the power is distributed between the central government and the sub-national entities who exercise governmental functions at local level. The two possibilities at the end of the spectrum, i.e.: complete decentralization of powers to local bodies on the one hand and total centralization of administrative and fiscal powers in the central government on the other hand, are often not feasible since both entail downsides that could hinder the sound functioning of the country.

The federal system has been applied extensively throughout history, even though with certain modifications and adaptations, in several countries, such as the US, Canada, Germany and Switzerland. It is based on the existence of a principal-agent relationship between central government and a network of decentralized sub-national entities. The latter act as agents on behalf of the central government and they are responsible of carrying out governmental tasks and responsibilities at a local level.
In particular, federalism can be extended and applied to fiscal powers, allowing local governmental authorities to retain part of the revenues stemming from tax collection instead of just collecting for the central government, which eventually will transfer back the revenues to the local authorities to meet their expenditures.
Fiscal devolution and the possibility for local governments to decide how to use tax revenues (i.e.: regional spending power) could reduce principal-agent issues and pose a wide array of benefits for sub-national governments. In fact, the latter are now incentivized to collect taxes since the…...

Similar Documents

Advantage & Disadvantages of Minimum Wage

...Introduction Minimum wage refers to the lowest hourly, daily or monthly wage an employee is legally entitled to when working. Minimum wage is in effect in a range of different jurisdictions with differences in the views on the advantages and disadvantages being disputed by people. Supporters claim minimum wage increases the standard of living for workers whilst reducing poverty. Opposite views are that if it is high enough to be effective then it increases unemployment, particularly among workers who are inexperienced or handicap, thus harming the lesser skilled workers to benefit the better skilled workers The effect on employment rates due to minimum wage rates is a highly contested policy within economics. The introduction of minimum wage into the market can lead to competitive employers cutting employment; this depends on the rate of the wage rises require to comply with the current minimum wage according to the “standard textbook model”. Other models have also been suggested in which a decline in the employment rate may not occur and in fact employment may increase. During my research I found a wide range of literature on minimum wages, particularly on the effects of a minimum wage policy in place. Though a lot of informative research was concluding I also found the argument between weather the effects and positive of negative on employment, both sides of the disagreement present a large amount of information supporting the theories. Research before the 1990’s......

Words: 2611 - Pages: 11

Devolution vs Federalism

...Devolution vs federalism The definition of devolution: it does mean the process of a higher level of government granting a lower level of government the right to exercise some of its powers, but ultimately remaining superior to the lower level of government. In practice it is much the same as federalism, the main difference is that devolution allows varying levels of autonomy for the different areas (units) within the nation-state, whereas federalism usually requires each unit to have the same powers. It's not right to think that devolved states (such as the UK) are highly centralised, it was actually brought in specifically to decentralise the UK and Spain, turning them from highly unitary states to what have been dubbed 'quasi-federations'. Devolution is increasingly viewed as a modern type of federalism that allows flexibility, as opposed to the more rigid "traditional" federalism. Only 2 countries really use devolution (UK and Spain), with most federal systems using traditional federalism in one of two forms: federation (strong federal government), or confederacy (weak federal government). It is also wrong to think that devolution means the upper/central government can abolish the lower levels or force them to comply: In the UK all political parties recognise the democratic legitimacy of the devolved institutions and their right to govern within their spheres of responsibility. Each was established after the people voted in referenda to create them, and no british......

Words: 1027 - Pages: 5

Advantage and Disadvantages

...National Curriculum Statement (NCS) Curriculum and Assessment Policy Statement LIFE SCIENCES Further Education and Training Phase Grades 10-12 basic education Department: Basic Education REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA CurriCulum and assessment PoliCy statement Grades 10-12 life sCienCes CAPS LIFE SCIENCES GRADES 10-12 department of Basic education 222 Struben Street Private Bag X895 Pretoria 0001 South Africa Tel: +27 12 357 3000 Fax: +27 12 323 0601 120 Plein Street Private Bag X9023 Cape Town 8000 South Africa Tel: +27 21 465 1701 Fax: +27 21 461 8110 Website: http://www.education.gov.za © 2011 department of Basic education isBn: 978-1-4315-0578-4 Design and Layout by: Ndabase Printing Solution Printed by: Government Printing Works CURRICULUM AND ASSESSMENT POLICY STATEMENT (CAPS) LIFE SCIENCES GRADES 10-12 FOREWORD by thE ministER Our national curriculum is the culmination of our efforts over a period of seventeen years to transform the curriculum bequeathed to us by apartheid. From the start of democracy we have built our curriculum on the values that inspired our Constitution (Act 108 of 1996). the Preamble to the Constitution states that the aims of the Constitution are to: • heal the divisions of the past and establish a society based on democratic values, social justice and fundamental human rights; improve the quality of life of all citizens and free the potential of each person;......

Words: 21816 - Pages: 88

Advantages and Disadvantages of Organisational Change

...Advantages and disadvantages of organisational change Change Might Not Equal Progress Many companies emphasize a culture of continuous improvement. While never being satisfied with the status quo can drive excellence in your organization, there is some wisdom in the old adage, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." Mistaking change for progress is similar to the common problem of mistaking activity for productivity. Every organization can be improved, no matter how well it is performing, but a manager should always ask the question, "How is this proposed change going to improve my organization's ability to achieve our key goals?" Cost-to-Benefit Ratio Change is never free. Changing the oil in your car takes time and materials, which cost money. Changing the phone system in your building costs time, money and training. Every change also has opportunity cost; spending your equipment budget on new computers means you have to wait to upgrade the phones. And there are intangible costs such as morale and customer satisfaction during the adjustment period. Determine whether the cost of a change is outweighed by the benefit that change will create. Internal Resistance According to an article by organizational change expert Garrison Wynn, the top two reasons people resist change are lack of knowledge about coming changes and fear of the unknown. You can expect some level of resistance to any change, no matter how small or how much benefit it might promise. The key tools for......

Words: 397 - Pages: 2

Voip Advantages and Disadvantages

...VoIP Advantages and Disadvantages The pros and cons of IP technology by Daniel Kochmanski DDK Telecommunications Buffalo, New York VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) is the ability to transmit and receive voice telephone calls over an Ethernet data connection. Ethernet data connections are used to connect computers inside an office building across a LAN (local Area Network) also known as intranet as well as connect computers to the world wide web (www) also known as a WAN (Wide Area Network) or internet. I must explain that VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) is utilized in two different ways. The first method, and the first one created, is for inbound and outbound phone service via VoIP service providers. The service can be via SIP (Session Initiation Protocol) trunking or a VoIP adapter. The second method is utilizing VoIP signaling directly to a business multi-line telephone is known as an IP (Internet Protocol) based phone or IP phone for short. I shall explain the advantages and disadvantages of IP business phones later in this article. I’ll also explain why a Hybrid system may be your best solution in the final paragraph. VoIP service provider companies, such as net2phone (IDT Corp) and iConnectHere (DeltaThree Corp.), started selling VoIP phone service back in the 1990’s. My personal experience back then was that the quality was very poor mostly due to lack of sufficient bandwidth, internet speed and compression techniques. Today there are......

Words: 4676 - Pages: 19

Solution and Advantages

...Solution and Advantages Derrick L. Catley Strayer University Professor Dimetri Richardson ENG 215 February 21, 2013 Is Hydraulic Fracking the Answer For the Future Some may say that hydraulic fracturing is the key to our future. Various people say that it will give America a secure energy future. A number of people say it is a step to energy independence. Others say that it is a threat to our society, environment, and our water supply. Others also say that it can cause major damage to home and areas in and around the fracturing sites. Corporations and many in the legislative branch want to see hydraulic fracturing as a major part of America moving forward towards energy independence. For the majority of individuals, the good outweighs the bad. The people in and around these fracturing sites tend to disagree. Logically, this would be the thing to do if safety measures were to be tightened. Ethically, they have to think of the dangers that it can pose to humans, wildlife, and the water supply. This is a very emotional subject to the people that live within the boundaries of the danger zone involved with hydraulic fracturing. Hydraulic fracturing regulations should be changed because blowout, gas leaks, and home explosions can occur during hydraulic fracturing undertakings (Ehrenberg, 2012). With hydraulic fracturing being a major contributor to earthquakes, gas leaks, contaminated drinking water, and various other catastrophes, it is......

Words: 2171 - Pages: 9

Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Facebook

...Today, Facebook is the world's largest social network, with morethan 1 billion users worldwide. Importance of the Study The importance of this study is to give knowledge to people about the advantages and disadvantages in using this social networking website which is Facebook. To give precautionary measures on how to be safe in using Facebook and to protect the people about the bad effects of using Facebook. Objectives of the Study General Objective: • To determine the advantages and disadvantages of using Facebook Specific objective: • To let people recognize how Facebook affect one’s life. • To prepare people on the effect of using Facebook • To identify the opinion of others about our study. 1 CHAPTER 2. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE According to tnvrstar.hubpages.com, Facebook is the most popular social networking site of all time. The popularity of Facebook has increased drastically. Within 6 years Facebook has reached more than 1 billion users and still growing rapidly. Nowadays Facebook has become very important part of our life. It is helping us in many ways and also harming us in some other ways. The use of Facebook could be very useful if any kind of addiction is avoided. This article contains full details about the pros and cons of Facebook in our daily life. Advantages of Using Facebook • Facebook is free and it's one of the best medium for communication. You can send message, start a video call, and upload photos and videos for free. • Facebook......

Words: 1889 - Pages: 8

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Main Events Software:

...The Advantages and Disadvantages of Main Events Software: The advantages of using main events software would be from using centralized web-based CMS you will have secure remote access from via internet; there is no software to install on your computer this will eliminate desktop maintenances and from this they can maintain and manage all of the electric and physical equipment that will run the programs. Centralized data storage and searching regardless of the location that you are in. This software is used by thousands of user’s every day and expanding to gain more users from new software. There is a full support staff to help with any programs from an on-line issues reporting. From the main events, you can have schedules that will track the data that is needed for any event. From the software, you are able to increase productivity and then lowering administrative cost. There is no annual license fee, and then the organization can significantly reduce the organization communication overhead. Main Event is always developing new software with new features to stay up with new changes in any agency’s needs. Scalable platforms grow when the agency grows. Main events software offers several advantages some of the advantages of this software would be dashboard performances to your staff then would be able to receive results in a graphical format. The staff will be able to customize their interfaces to match their styles with no cost to the company. From this program,......

Words: 747 - Pages: 3

Advantages &Disadvantages

...Advantages and Disadvantages of Convention and Concept Advantages of accounting concepts, conventions and regulations. There are many advantages that accounting concepts have on financial statements. Four important accounting concepts that underpin the preparation of any sets of accounts one of which is going concern that helps an account to assume for any future problems that occur in a business. This helps companies to make future plans and gives them time to gather money to sort out any financial problems. Consistency also has an advantage in helping in accounting by users of accounts can make more meaningful comparisons of financial performance. Prudence helps investors sort out financial performance such as future problems and cost of the business before recognising any signs of profits. Accruals also help financial data to be useful for users by all business revenues and cost are recorded in the appropriate statements and at the appropriate time. Conventions also have many advantages in influences financial statements to be useful for investors. Separate entity is one example this convention seeks to ensure that all private transactions and matters relating to the owners are segregated from transactions that relate to the business. This is an advantage because owner’s transactions are kept private. Also they are not mixed with the business finance so that users can clearly see the business financial state. Also materiality is also an important convention in a......

Words: 327 - Pages: 2

Advantages and Disadvantages of Globalization

...1 Introduction "No two countries that both had McDonald's had fought a war against each other since each got its McDonald's.” This quote of Thomas L. Friedman, a well-known US-American foreign affairs and globalization expert, shows two of the main results of globalization: Companies that are becoming more international and a world in which the countries start cooperating more and more instead of fighting wars. People start in-teracting borderlessly and politicians and newspapers mention the “world community.” There are mainly three forces that are contributing to the process of globalization: the liberalization of capital movements, the opening of global markets to trade and invest-ment, and the increasing use of information and communication technologies. If you want to define globalization you have to emphasize that Globalization is a multi-dimensional phenomenon that not only touches political, economic, social and cultural spheres of any society but also reshapes the traditional way of studying the “social world and human nature” first. At political and economic level, globalization is the process of denationalization of markets, politics and legal systems, it is the rise of global economy. Good examples for this development are e.g. the European Union or the negotiations of the European Union with the United States to create the biggest trade zone of the world. At the business level, globalization is when companies decide to take part in the emerging global......

Words: 2370 - Pages: 10

Advantages and Disadvantages of Database Management

...layer between programs and the data. Programs access the DBMS, which then accesses the data. There are different types of DBMS ranging from small systems that run on personal computers to huge systems that run on mainframes. There are a lot of database software manufacturers out there and a wide range of prices, sizes, speeds and functionalities. At the lower end of the scale are personal database software products like Microsoft Access, which is designed to be used by individuals or small companies relatively little data. User friendliness and ease of use are the priority rather than speed and scalability (in other words, it works well when you have 100 records but not when you have 100,000). At the higher end are full-fledged enterprise solutions, such as Oracle Enterprise Edition. These database software products can handle millions of data entries and are fast and efficient. They have ·many optimization and performance tools and generally require a Database Administrator (DBA) to look after them. Products in this range can also be very expensive. In file system, each application has its own private files, which cannot be shared between multiple applications. This can often lead to considerable redundancy in the stored data, which results in wastage of storage space. By having centralized database most of this can be avoided. It is not possible that all redundancy should be eliminated. Sometimes there are sound business and technical reasons for· maintaining multiple......

Words: 631 - Pages: 3

B2B Advantages and Disadvantages

...teach me about what is truly important. To my teachers, colleagues, and students, from whom I continue to learn every day. —H.T. Fred R. McFadden 1933–2009 Founding author of Modern Database Management, Fred McFadden, passed away on August 9, 2009. Fred was a dedicated educator for 30 years in the College of Business at the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs. He received his bachelor’s degree in Mechanical Engineering from Michigan State University, his MBA from the University of California, Los Angeles, and his PhD in Industrial Engineering from Stanford University. He began writing Modern Database Management in 1980 and was considered a leading information systems educator in database management, systems analysis, and decision support, all areas in which he was a scholarly author. Fred’s work on the initial design of this textbook was pioneering, as few books existed then to present information technology to business students. Fred was an inspiration to his students and colleagues. An outstanding communicator with a strong sense of clarity and the needs of students, he was a mentor to his co-authors. Fred’s first concern was always what was best for the students using the book, and he worked tirelessly to make passages succinct, readable, and motivating. He taught through examples and imaginatively told stories with graphics. He was skilled at blending the latest and best industry practices with leading research results into......

Words: 193467 - Pages: 774

Advantages and Disadvantages of Franchising

...understandable issue. However we can identify and summarize the possible responses putting in evidence all economic advantages for the franchisor. In this instance, he can extend and increase his units thanks to the investment risk assumed by other parties in the host country. One of the main financial benefits includes the fact that the franchisor gains from additional incomes such as franchisees fees and on-going royalties. This increase of capital improves profits and return on investments. McDonalds, for instance, sell their name for $1,800,000 a piece. This is huge for the franchisor because for every new McDonalds they open they make a profit from the name and products they sell to the franchisee and also have a stake in the profits that the franchisees make (AssociatedContent, 2010). Another financial benefit is the reduced operating, distribution and 1 advertising costs. This, in turn, will mean more funds will be allocated for research and development. The key operational benefit is the ability for the franchisor to have a far smaller centralized headquarter, compared to having to owning many business locations and developing then into franchisees. Moreover, the management can ensure conformity across the company, through the use of standardized procedures achieving consistent outcomes, greater productivity levels and better quality results. Another advantage is the ability to instigate effective quality control. Particularly where the franchise agreement is......

Words: 2302 - Pages: 10

An Analysis on the Advantages and Disadvantages of Playing Computer Games or Online Gaming”

...St. Rita’s College of Balingasag Balingasag, Misamis Oriental Basic Education Department School Year 2013-2014 TERM PAPER “An analysis on the advantages and disadvantages of playing computer games or online gaming” August 19, 2013 Presented by: Rey Pahunang Presented to: Ms. Michelle Odchigue Introduction Playing game is a natural part of growing up. It is one way that person can learn to socialize and compete. Computer and online games , in most instances are no more dangerous than other games that people plays. But sometimes computer and online games become more than just play. They become an addiction and when they become in addiction teenagers psychological and physical well being may be in danger. Addiction to computer and online games is a real and growing problem. It affects both kids and adults specially teenagers. Often the most addictive games are the online multi-player game they include role playing and endless of achievements and an IM or a chat function. Groups of players play and chats online, creating a fantasy world that provides an escape from real life. Kids can get caught up in this fantasy world to the exclusion of their real life responsibilities. Playing online games is an innocent hobby that can become a pathological behavioral problem, in which playing games becomes more important than other aspects of life. Addicted teenagers spend hours on the computer to the exclusion of other......

Words: 626 - Pages: 3

Explain the Advantages and Disadvantages of the Main Forms of Business Organizations

...The four main forms of business organizations namely sole proprietorship, partnership, C corporation, and S corporation have various advantages and disadvantages in terms of tax implications, legal status, financial obligations, and even set up time and compliance issues. A sole proprietorship is an individual based business. The advantages of sole proprietorship are various including the easiness to start and dissolve the company, the ability to have personal and complete control over the company, and the ability to retain all profits and include them in personal tax returns. Sole proprietorship has some disadvantages that include the owner’s unlimited liability over the company. The owner is legally responsible for all the debts of the company. Another disadvantage is that it is hard to raise funds because it depends on one person who might not have sufficient funds. It may also be difficult to attract high skills and professional employees because some would want to either have a high ranking position in the company or the chance to buy stock. Sole proprietors are also taxed more than corporation for example corporations pay 15% tax for income up to $ 50,000 while sole proprietors pay 15% (if filing married filing jointly) for income up to 35, 800 only. Financial statements for sole proprietorship are the income statement, the balance sheet, the statement of cash flows, and the statement of owner’s equity. In a partnership there are two or more owners. Partnership is......

Words: 667 - Pages: 3