Asylum Seeking Youth Should Be Released in the Community

In: English and Literature

Submitted By dilukajay
Words 677
Pages 3
Would you not resent being locked up when you have not really committed an offence? Indeed, you would! Well, this is the plight of asylum seeking youth who are confined to detention centres.

The issue whether youngsters seeking asylum should be confined to a detention centre or be assimilated into the community has become so controversial that it has attracted much public opinion and media coverage. In this context, youngsters or youth means teenagers of 15 to 18 years and a detention centre is defined as a place where refugees or illegal immigrants are confined till their case is determined. My contention is that asylum seeking youth should be integrated into the community. Youngsters incarcerated in detention centres are denied their education, exposed to moral corruption and are subjected to a stunted psychological growth. My critics argue that these youngsters should not be released to the community because, if released, they would resort to unbecoming conduct. I will prove that this argument is not tenable.

When such children are incarcerated in a detention centre, they are denied the education that such youngsters deserve. Reporting about the Broadmeadows Detention Centre, the Herald Sun of 16 November 2010 comments: “seven boys were hospitalised after a brawl over the single computer”. Resorting to fisticuffs to grab the computer is their way of communicating their need for mental activity. This is their way of asserting that they need an educational curriculum to keep them mentally occupied. This is their way of expressing their pent up frustration in not having what they need. Are the authorities so naïve that they are unable to perceive this? Thus, being denied educational opportunities, these youth cry out for their release to the wider community.

Furthermore, asylum seeking youth in detention centre are strongly tempted to become morally…...

Similar Documents

The Asylum Seeker Policies in Australia Are Inhumane. Do You Agree?

...Throughout the years, there have been articles about asylum seekers resorting to violence due to discontentment with the Australian government regarding the assessment of their refugee status. These are evident cries for help which sparks off debates on the government’s abilities to find a successful solution to the asylum issues. Australia has been criticized due to the requirements of compulsory immigration detention for ‘all unlawful non-citizens, (including asylum seekers)’ (Phillips & Spinks 2013, p.1). The other controversial issue of Australia regarding the asylum seekers is also the claims that it has been avoiding it’s responsibilities under the United Nations refugee conventions by making it hard for asylum seekers to claim refugee protection. Although the Australian government is undertaking various asylum policies in response to the constant increasing influx of refugees and asylum seekers entering the country, many are still constantly suffering and the human rights of these inhumane policies need to be further addressed. This essay will emphasize the inhumane asylum policies by weighing the negative aspects, but also addressing the government’s response in dealing with the asylum issues. Many have questioned the need for the mandatory detention of asylum seekers upon arrival especially when there is no exclusion for women and children. The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC) has found that this policy is an infringement of human rights as......

Words: 1369 - Pages: 6

Australia's Legal Obligation to Refugees and Asylum Seekers

...Australia has a legal obligation towards asylum seekers and refugees. Australia has a legal obligation towards Asylum Seekers and Refugees as it is a signatory to the UN Human Rights and Refugee Conventions. Furthermore, Australia has a moral obligation based on its membership of the world community. “Australia is one of the 146 signatory countries to the United Nations 1951 Convention and or/ 1967 Protocol relating to the status of refugees”. (Asylum Seeker Resource Centre, 2009) According to Australian Human Rights Commission an asylum seeker is someone who has fled their country and applies to the government of another country for protection as a refugee, (Australian Human Rights Commision, 2012) whereas a person is a refugee the moment he or she fulfils the criteria of the convention. As part of signatory countries to the United Nations 1951 Convention they are “obliged to act according to their efforts to allow everyone to seek and enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution. This right may not be invoked in the case persecutions genuinely arising from non- political crimes or acts of contrary to the purposes and Principles on the United Nations”. (United Nations, 2011) This means that Australia has committed to respect the rights of refugees and to uphold the obligations set out in the treaty. This is in contradiction to the Migration Act 1958, which states, “Australian law requires that asylum seekers who have not been successful in their claims for......

Words: 1822 - Pages: 8

Firms Should Get Their House in Order Before Seeking to Manage Supplier.

...firms seeking for long-term sustainable development. Thus it can be seen that more and more entities experienced the importance of manage suppliers. Moreover, the savings from transaction progress could contribute to a significant amount and also lead company products more competitive as well as provide funds for innovation. Therefore, it seems like procurers play an important role within firms. But how the firms could achieve best value for money in procurement management? It seems likely that firms should seek to ‘get their own house in order’ before attempting to deal with suppliers. This essay aims to discuss this issue and illustrated the discussion with some successful examples. In the following sections, it shows a standard purchasing & supply management process. Additionally, the factors of outsourcing decision will be pointed out, organization buying behaviour will also be included in the essay. 2. Purchasing & Supply Management Process 3.1 Standard Process In Figure1, this is a commonly standard purchasing and management process which used by different sizes of firms worldwide. However, some smaller entities probably skip some stages of purchasing process, but basically it appears sequence of operating procurement principle. It illustrated clearly that the best value for money involves internal and external management, not a single one can be omitted. And it is also a strongly evidenced that before firms manage suppliers, it should......

Words: 1805 - Pages: 8

Asylum Seekers Persuasive Essay

...persecution, or threats to their lives. But there is no reason why the Australian government should be obliged to welcome asylum seekers who use illegal methods to come here. We have the responsibility to protect our borders and way of life against what could amount to a huge arrival of immigrants whose backgrounds and possible criminal status are unknown.Australia shouldn’t accept the refugees as they are over populating the country and if we do more and more will come. People believe that asylum seekers deserve a fair go just like everyone else, but why should they if they are receiving everything off tax payers money. With the ever increasing number of refugees entering our country, many Australians are struggling to sustain what they once had. Many Australians were already struggling before the arrival of the refugees, and are only suffering more. Most Australians don’t earn or own substantial amounts of money and with the arrival of the asylum seekers it just puts more strain on them. Many people are now loosing their jobs and houses as they can no longer pay their mortgages, bills and purchase everyday needs as the government believes it is better to support the arrival of asylum seekers. Many Australians are in need of public housing and extra cash and the government seems to be failing its own people and giving it all away to the asylum seekers awaiting processing. The asylum seekers are given free clothing, housing, money, discounts, schooling, medical attention......

Words: 1575 - Pages: 7

Community Service Should Be Encouraged in a University

...Community Service Should Be Encouraged In A University Community service is a voluntary work which is intended to help people. This kind of service is important because the needy people will be help by the volunteers so their life will be improved and become easier. Other than that, the relationship between the volunteers and the helped people become stronger and also firms the bond among the volunteers themselves. So, should community service be encouraged in a university? I strongly agree that community service should be encouraged in a university because joining it gives benefits to the students. As a student there is much free time during every single semester. Why do the students have to spend the precious time by doing something which lead to waste that precious thing such as going to malls, playing computer games and other unnecessary activities to be done. By participating in community service, students can spend their leisure time by helping people in need such as visiting old folks or orphans home, picking up trash and donating money and goods. They can complete these unpaid jobs by joining organizations organized in the university. By doing these kind of activities, their leisure time will be spend greatly. Furthermore, the other benefit of this service is people which are in need will be help by the community service volunteers. Indeed, helping people such as the victims of natural disasters like tsunami, flood, fire , and......

Words: 526 - Pages: 3

Asylum Seekers as a Vulnerable Group

...21266789 Traditionally, asylum seekers are a group of heterogeneous people who have moved from their home countries to seek refuge in other countries which are perceived to be more habitable. The reason for this exodus varies, and can range from natural disasters to armed conflict, imprisonment and or torture. One thing shared among people in this group is the uncertainty presented to them in their new abode. These challenges become even more daunting when the need to access healthcare arises. In the course of this piece, I will be exploring some factors that contribute to the vulnerability of asylum seekers in accessing healthcare in the United Kingdom. It should be noted that while some of the factors that contribute to the vulnerability of this group are associated with the flaws of systems in the United Kingdom, a lot more have got to do with their experiences(in their home countries, during their journey and on arrival in the United Kingdom), cultural and religious believes. With regards to this kind of migration, asylum seekers mostly embark on their journey without proper planning and with little knowledge about the systems that exist in countries they end up. On arrival in the UK, they are have to cope with past experiences, some of which may stem from being forced to leave their homes or family members behind and may not know their whereabouts. Some asylum seekers will have to live with the trauma of being unsure if members of their family are dead or alive.......

Words: 2222 - Pages: 9


...Country of Asylum T. Cole Andrews Chapter 1 4 Chapter 2 11 Chapter 3 21 Chapter 4 30 Chapter 5 40 Chapter 6 53 Chapter 7 65 Chapter 8 86 Chapter 9 98 Chapter 10 107 Chapter 11 123 Chapter 12 136 Chapter 13 150 Chapter 14 167 Chapter 15 173 Chapter 16 188 Chapter 17 202 Chapter 18 216 Chapter 19 219 And among the cities which ye shall give unto the Levites there shall be six cities for refuge, which ye shall appoint for the manslayer, that he may flee thither. Numbers 35: 6 Country of Asylum Chapter 1 It was just beginning to get hot in Tikrit when I first realized I might have to kill this new man of my wife’s. It’s possible I overreacted to everything. You have to get up pretty early to call the States, if you want your privacy and you want to catch anybody awake at home; at home it’ll be sometime the night before. The desert is cool in the mornings too, or cooler, so that you’ll see the occasional soldier getting his PT in before it gets too hot, but he’s usually far enough away that you don’t have to whisper. I would watch the big black beetles fighting with each other in the dirt (they’re way bigger here than they are at home) while waiting for the call to go through. It......

Words: 70850 - Pages: 284

Asylum Seekers

...ASYLUMS SEEKERS AND REFUGEES “Like many members of the Hazara minority in Afghanistan, Chaman Sha Nasiri fled his homeland to escape persecution. At the time, the Taliban had been hunting for young men to either recruit or kill. Chaman then spent three years in the Nauru processing centre. It was a time of uncertainty, and as with many other asylum seekers, he became increasingly anxious and desperate” 1 Chama’s Story is just one of many for asylum seekers who seek refuge here in Australia. They come to our country expecting safety and freedom alongside the most basic human right. Yet when they arrive they are imprisoned and treated as criminals. It is clear that the laws surrounding this issue are in dire need of change. Australia is a country well known for its diversity of beliefs and religions, it is said to be accepting of others, however, when the topic of asylum seekers is brought forth, the government and media portrays the need for border protection, and “stopping the boats”. This type of hostile political enforcement and negative media coverage only furthers the portrayal of refugees as something fear, in the mind of most Australians. However, although it is not widely broadcasted by the Government or media, Australia has a legal obligation to help asylum seekers under the United Nations Refugee Convention 1951, to which Australia is signatory. According to the United Nations Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, amended by the 1967 Protocol......

Words: 4656 - Pages: 19

Firms Should Get Their House in Order Before Seeking to Manage Supplier

... Role of events in image formation of a destination Events are defined by Getz (2007) as a special occurrence at a given place, with a definite beginning and an end. They require planning and are often publicised in advance in order to attract participants. Traditionally events are valued for their cultural, social, sport, and entertainment benefits. However, since the early 1980s mega events, which are well-known and large in scale, are regarded as a desirable asset for their potential to deliver economic benefits through destination promotion, urban regeneration, and job creation (Gratton et al. 2000; Bowdin et al. 2006). In particular, because of mega events’ ability to attract global attention and publicity, governments and communities use them as part of the marketing strategy in an attempt to create a positive image for the host cities and regions. According to Chon (1990), an image of an entity is a mental representation of a person’s beliefs, feelings, ideas, impressions, and expectations combined. In the context of destination image, it is the mental picture of a destination a tourist or a potential tourist holds. Reynolds (1965) interpreted the image formation process as the development of a mental construct through a selection of a few impressions among a flood of stimulation. Relating this process to shaping image of a destination, Echtner and Ritchie (2003) argued that the flood of stimulation can come from many sources. Other than actually visiting......

Words: 31531 - Pages: 127

Firms Should Get Their House in Order Before Seeking to Manage Supplier.

...herbal stomach remedy that is all-natural – Gilead capsules by Coal 9. And finally, another group of students developed a water vending machine for intimate washing in public toilets – Sanitary Aqua Vendo. This product promotes discipline use of water, preservation of trees through reduced consumption of tissue paper and prevention of urinary tract infection especially among women. So, how exactly does creativity work. Let’s us look at its anatomy. Throughout history, we see communities or places that have produced numerous creative products that literally changed the world, while equally prominent contemporary neighbors within the same cultural zone generated more modest results. This is what Dr. Barton Kunstler calls the “hothouse effect”. In the ancient times, we saw Athens, Greece. In the renaissance period, we saw Florence, Italy. In the modern era, we saw Silicon Valley in the US. In order for creativity to flourish in a company, the individuals that make up that company should have two things: (a) psychological encouragement and (b) nurturing environment. Both would boost one’s confidence level in pursuing new ideas and generating better products for market consumption. Could creativity increase productivity of a company? What happens when we do not have creativity? We would have limited growth, low productivity, a culture of complacency, routinary work, people getting sick and suppressed. How can companies nurture creativity? Certain......

Words: 1737 - Pages: 7

Should Community Colleges/Two-Year Colleges Award Baccalaureate Degrees?

...transfer degrees to help student to enroll in 4 years bachelor’s degrees. Community colleges originally were created to offer individuals higher education opportunities that were not provided in university settings. Through time, the offerings of the community colleges have diversified. Recently some community colleges began offering baccalaureate degrees; this phenomenon has resulted in controversy over the mission and function of the community college. the mission of most community colleges as shaped by the following commitments: * Serving all segments of society though an open-access admissions policy that offers equal and fair treatment to all students * 
Providing a comprehensive educational program * 
Serving the community as a community-based institution of higher education Teaching and learning * Fostering lifelong learning Many believe that a community college cannot be all things to all people and offering four-year degrees may decrease the focus from the open access mission (Dougherty, 2001; Eaton, 2005; Townsend, 2005; Wattenbarger, 2000). Furthermore, the graduates‘ preparedness to compete in the market or be successful in graduate school has been questioned. Others believe that the community college should respond to the needs of its community and the changing student population (Floyd, 2006; Floyd & Walker, 2003; Walker, 2001). There are three reasons why community colleges began offering the baccalaureate degree as a response to......

Words: 1313 - Pages: 6

Seeking Asylum

...Seeking Asylum: The Buffalo State Hospital In American architecture, one thing rang true: America borrowed from the greatest countries and empires. Throughout much of the early years of the United States, there was not a singular distinct type of architecture, both in the domestic and public sectors. Borrowing from well-established counties became a second nature. Hunting and pecking through thousands of years of pre designed architecture helped American architects, like Henry Hobson Richardson, grab the best of the best and led them to create marvelous masterpieces. From Greek and Roman flares to the beauty of Queen Anne and Federal style, American architects have waded through them all. By doing so, elaborate and attractive buildings began to pop up through much of the United States Eastern Seaboard. One of the most influential American Architects to come out of this time period is Henry Hobson Richardson. He helped develop a definite American Style of architecture and one of the most important. His influence on building design has made an impact on such architects as Frank Lloyd Wright and Louis Sullivan. Siegfried Giedion, author of Space, Time and Architecture, states that “Richardson’s study of historical precedence- in this case Romanesque buildings-led to the design of the new forms Richardson was after.” Henry Hobson Richardson was born in a Louisiana Parish on September 29th, 1838 to Catherine Priestley and Henry Richardson. He was born into a......

Words: 5002 - Pages: 21

Youth Criminal Justice Act

...The consequences of the Youth Criminal Justice Act [YCJA] can be referred as too light. Since the YCJA has taken over, youth crime is slowly decreasing. The discipline of the YCJA may need to become harsher. The YCJA has evolved from the harsh Young Offenders Act [YOA]. Stats on youth crime suggest that the YCJA is helping to reduce the amount of young offenders. Some cases suggest that the YCJA is not being tough enough with what young offenders are being sentenced with. The study of the human brain suggest that youths don’t understand the consequences of the crimes that they are committing resulting in the need for them to know the consequences. Through cases and the study of the human brain the YCJA needs some aspects changed for the better of society. The evolution of the YCJA has been formed from many different acts. Each act consists of similarities and differences between them. Different acts are formed over time to satisfy the needs of punishment as the world develops. The YCJA is the newest act which consist of similarities and differences of the YOA. The main difference of the YCJA and the YOA was the severity of the penalty for the crime committed. The YOA “was a highly controversial statute. While conservative politicians criticized the law for being ‘‘soft on youth crime,’’’ (Pulis). Since the YOA was soft on youth punishment, youths were not too concerned if they broke the law. Youths would break the law get a slap on the wrist and move on to......

Words: 1575 - Pages: 7

Should Homelessness Be Considered a Crime in the Community?

... Should Homelessness be Considered a Crime in The Community? Homelessness affects every community. It can happen to anyone no matter what your status, race, gender, or age. It happens for various reasons. For instance, loss of a job, poor physical or mental health, breakdown in family life, domestic violence, drug abuse, etc. When we talk about the homeless, it is important to remember that often times the homeless are being criminalized for being homeless, but is it justifiable to arrest a person for being homeless? Is arresting homeless people really going to benefit the community as well as the homeless? In an article written by Michael Maskin, a senior at Tufts University, titled “No Safe Place: How cities are making it illegal to be homeless,” Maskin explains the case of Jerome Murdough, a 56 year old veteran who was homeless and arrested for seeking a safe place to sleep. Instead of a safe place to sleep, he died in Riker’s Island prison for not having $2,500 to post bail. “Instead of receiving needed assistance, Murdough was treated like a criminal, and ultimately lost his life by trying to protect it” (Maskin 2). This is a saddening story, but it is often very common. Tickets that will not get paid and time in jail will not change the fact that someone is homeless, so it just becomes one more issues added to the many that they deal with. Another testimony Maskin offers in his article is the story of Sandy a homeless woman seeking a safe place to......

Words: 1106 - Pages: 5

Should People Seeking Government Assistance Be Required to Take Drug Tests?

...Should people seeking government assistance be required to take drug tests? INTRODUCTION On August 22, 1996, President Bill Clinton signed the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act, also known as the Welfare Reform Bill, into effect ending welfare as it had been known for many years. “This law transformed the traditional entitlement to cash welfare under Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) into a transitional program, Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF), which requires most recipients to work after two years of receiving assistance, or, at state option, even earlier, with few exceptions. After 60 months of receipt during a lifetime, a recipient is ineligible for federally-funded cash benefits (NPC, 2004)”. (1) The Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act shifted the responsibility of the poor to the states. The Act also made allowance for states to perform drug testing of those who were in need of federal assistance. According to an article in the New York Times “Policy makers in three dozen states this year proposed drug testing for people receiving benefits like welfare, unemployment assistance, job training, food stamps and public housing (Sulzberger, 2011) .” The controversy rising from the proposed drug testing has many debating the question: Should people seeking government assistance be required to take drug tests? PROs/CONs: There are several pros and cons to the new legislature to drug test those seeking......

Words: 1619 - Pages: 7