Bankruptcy and Restructuring at Marvel Entertainment Group

In: Business and Management

Submitted By frozenviolet
Words 706
Pages 3
Bankruptcy and Restructuring at Marvel Entertainment Group

1. Why did Marvel file for Chapter 11? Were the problems caused by bad luck, bad strategy, or bad execution? What is the amount of debt of MEG (the operating company) and the Marvel Holding Companies (Marvel owners)?

The Chapter 11 bankruptcy provided an opportunity for all the major stakeholders to evaluate their options regarding their investment and control of Marvel. Bankruptcy alleviated Marvel’s immediate cash shortage, protected it from creditors and some litigation, and provided Marvel with a ‘fresh start.’

Bad strategy: Diversified youth Entertainment Company
Bad execution: Overpaying for acquisitions
There’s a combination of bad strategy and bad execution caused the problem. First, Perelman attempted to “expand the industry pie” and decrease marginal costs, which instead only worked to distract Marvel from producing quality product. Besides, Perelman showed a poor judgment in several acquisitions aimed at building Marvel into an entertainment empire but which only further distracted the company and paid more than he could earn from the acquisitions

At the year 1996, there are more than 70% debts at Marvel entertainment group. The public debts issued by Marvel Holding Companies are 47.2% of the old shares and 9.1% new shares by the time reorganization plan

2. Describe and evaluate the proposed restructuring plan. Will it solve the problems that caused Marvel to file for chapter 11?

The restructure plan:
Buy 410m new shares for $350m @ $0.85
Acquire remaining Toy Biz with 32% premium
Bondholders get 14.6% of shares (77.3m)

The restructure will allow Marvel to restructure current debt. Also will allow Marvel to sustain operations while they make improvements in the organizational structure and refocused. Marvel will see profits increasing with focus on movie production.…...

Similar Documents

Tata Group- Corporate Restructuring

...Tata Group: Transforming the Sleeping Elephant “A company does not become global by simply participating in geographical markets around the world. The objective of globalization is to become globally competitive, leverage global opportunities and have the required global capabilities. It implies an organization, which employs talented people without reference to nationality. We are in the process of acquiring such competitive position and global capabilities”. Ratan Tata, Chairman, Tata Sons (Hindustan Times, September 5, 2004). “Despite popular perception Ratan Tata has more than lived up to JRD’s vision and expectations”. Deepakh Parekh, Chairman, HDFC, (India Today, February, 2003). The unfolding of a crisis After proposing the Strategic Plan in 1991, Ratan Tata observed: “I think we are in many more businesses than we should have been in and were perhaps not concerned about our market position in each of those businesses. I think the needs today are that we define our businesses much more articulately and that we remain focused rather than diffused, and that we become more aggressive than we used to be, much more market driven, much more concerned about our customer satisfaction (HBS Working Paper, 9-798-037).” Ratan Tata on being questioned in an interview regarding – what criteria he will choose in deciding what to keep and what not to, in his groups’ portfolio restructuring exercise? To this he replied, “One is certainly going to be: can we be in the first three in......

Words: 8239 - Pages: 33

Business Report for Sky City Entertainment Group Limited and Tourism Industry.

...Business report for Sky City Entertainment Group Limited and tourism industry. Contents Introduction 3 Discussion of findings 3 Industry background 3 Investigation of Financial information 5 Accounting elements 5 Ratios analysis 6 Profitability and Efficiency Ratios 6 Financial Stability Ratios 7 Financial Structure Ratios 7 Investment Ratios 8 Share Market Data 8 Brokers Recommendation 8 Share performance 9 Conclusion: 9 Recommendations 9 Reference List: 10 Appendix 11 Introduction The purpose of investigating the Sky City Group Limited (SKC) and tourism industry is to give a financial advice to a client who has recently asked for it in Vision Consultancy Limited. The sources of information and data used are reliable as it was retrieved from trustworthy websites such as: company’s website, Statistics NZ, NZX company research, tourism industry association New Zealand and Investorwords. The limitations of this business report are that financial statements of SKC used are for previous business year. And SKC does not disclose inventory turnover figure, consequently this ratio cannot be calculated. Also, there might be an increase in tourism after the Hobbit movie is released. Discussion of findings Industry background According to Tourism Industry Association New Zealand (2012), tourism is a fundamental contribution to New Zealand’s economy and way of life. It contributes close to 10% of gross domestic product (GDP), the earning for...

Words: 2308 - Pages: 10

Bankruptcy and Restructuring at Marvel Entertainment Group

...Bankruptcy and Restructuring at Marvel Entertainment Group Bankruptcy and Restructuring at Marvel Entertainment Group 1. Why did Marvel file for Chapter 11? Were the problems created by bad luck, bad strategy or bad execution? Before addressing its bankruptcy, it is necessary to have a general understanding of the company being analyzed. Marvel Entertainment Group began in 1939 as Timely Publications, a comic book publishing company that gained fame around the time of the Second World War. One of its most successful characters from this period was Captain America, who was often depicted fighting against the Germans. Other new characters came in the decades that followed, some of which still maintain popularity to this day, including The Fantastic Four, The Incredible Hulk, The X-Men, and Spider-Man. Attempting to reflect the general “psychological spirit” of the era (WWII, Cold War, etc.), many of Marvel’s creations in the mid-20th century fought against Communist foes. Editor-in-Chief Stan Lee helped usher in the ‘Marvel Age of Comics’ of the 1960’s, writing most of the superhero titles himself, and restoring many of the aspects from the late 1930’s superhero genre. Skipping forward a few decades, Marvel Entertainment Group was bought in January 1989 by Ron Perelman for $82.5 million, financed using only $10.5 million of equity. The remaining portion was borrowed from a syndicate of banks led by Chase Manhattan, seeing this as a relatively insignificant amount for......

Words: 5077 - Pages: 21


...Marvel Case Names: Markus Hesse, Hugo Feis, Joost Welzen & Eric Weijman Bad luck * Drop in sales due to strikes in professional baseball and hockey Bad strategy * There is no strategic response to the trend of new forms of entertainment (e.g. video games). Instead, investments are made in obsolete business like trading cards * Unsustainable focus on increasing the number of monthly titles and raising prices, which only temporarily yields returns from buyers who buy them for speculative reasons * Due to this strategy (focusing on speculative buyers), which means fancy covers and high prices, (also due to the changed distribution model), the Marvel comics do not longer appeal to the core readers. The very foundation of the business is therefore neglected * Rationale for the diversification strategy was a mitigate to cyclicality, but this clearly did not pay off. No clear evidence of alternative synergies between the businesses. Moreover, restructuring charges are substantial * Additional investment in declining trading cards business through the acquisition of SkyBox, while Marvel was already showing signs of distress * Drafting an unconvincing reorganization plan, which among others includes an additional acquisition (which raises new risk and debt in the short term). Selling off unsynergetic business units may have made more senses Bad execution * High leverage using overpriced shares as collateral. Given the this leverage in......

Words: 443 - Pages: 2


...Marvel Entertainment: Marvel Studios Amy J. Keller June 28, 2009 This case study focuses on the Marvel Studios franchise. Marvel Entertainment took a huge risk when it decided to stop licensing its’ characters to outside production companies and develop their own in-house productions via Marvel Studios. This study focuses on the history of Marvel Studios and what harm or benefit has come from the creation of Marvel Studios and the expansion into filmmaking. Biography/History Marvel Entertainment, Inc. is a prominent character-based entertainment company that is worldwide. The have a collection of 5,000 characters that cover a 70-year company span and sever media types (comics, toys, movies, et cetera). “Marvel’s strategy is to leverage its franchises in a growing array of opportunities around the world, including feature films, consumer products, toys, video games, animated television, direct-to-DVD and online” (Viacom). Marvel Studios mission is to “develop and manage entertainment projects that leverage Marvel’s vast universe of creative content” ( Throughout the 1970s and 1980s, Marvel had licensed out a number of their characters for movies and direct-to-TV productions. Very few of these are remembered today. One that you might recall is Howard the Duck; it didn’t do so well in the box office. The reasoning behind such failures was the lack of research the company put into it’s licensing (Stax). Marvel......

Words: 1975 - Pages: 8


...Marketing Strategy 8050 Marvel Enterprises, Inc. Case Writing by Xiaodan Dong February, 2008 Marvel Enterprises, Inc. (b) Why was Marvel’s turnaround so successful? Would you characterize that success as a fluke? Or do you view it as sustainable? Why? How? Marvel’s success is not a fluke because its business model is sustainable. Marvel’s new strategy monetized the content library by licensing characters for use with media products. During an era in which mass media is very important in people’s life, only one media tool, publishing, is not strong enough to expand Marvel’s influence to consumers. Comic books can target a very limited market, mostly composed of male teenagers and young adults from 13 to 23 years old. It is very difficult to expand this traditional market. After many years of development, this market has matured and is very stable. Meanwhile, people have been more exposed to movies, televisions, and video games, which more effectively influence people’s consumption behavior than do comic books. All these media modes are able to reach more consumer segments than traditional comic-book publishing. Marvel’s potential to develop increased dramatically when its market expanded to broadcast media. Other consumer products, such as toys, worked in conjunction with media products, these two kinds of products reinforced each other. Marvel’s market expansion developed in both a comprehensive and intensive manner. Marvel emphasized long-term value in......

Words: 1226 - Pages: 5

Regal Entertainment Group Financial Analysis

...Regal Entertainment Group FINANCIAL ANALYSIS Description of Business Regal Entertainment Group is a publicly traded corporation based in Knoxville, Tennessee and incorporated in Delaware. REG was founded in 1989 through the mergers of three larger movie chains Regal Cinemas, United Artists Theaters, and Edwards Theatres and has since acquired several smaller chains to boost market share. It has become the most geographically diverse theatre circuit in North America with 7,394 screens with 229 million attendees in fiscal year 2013 (Regal P.4). Regal’s fiscal year ends the first Thursday after December 25, and subsequently may have a 53-week fiscal year. In 2013 they reported total revenues of $3,038.1 million, income from operations of $339.8 million, net income attributable to controlling interest of $157.7 million, and cash flows from operating activities of $346.9 million (Regal p.4). Financial Statement Information While there are no extraordinary items or discontinued operations on their 2013 financial statements, Regal did report a $1.02 per share basic earnings for both Class A and Class B common stock for fiscal year ending 2013 (Regal p.113). Both Class A and Class B stock have a par value of $0.001 (Regal p.57). The Class A common stock has 500,000,000 shares authorized with 131,743,778 shares issued as of December 27, 2012 and the Class B common stock has 200,000,000 shares...

Words: 1697 - Pages: 7

Marvel Restructuring

...From the perspective of Marvel’s debt holders, they have two overall options: continue to hold their investments in Marvel or sell their holdings. Depending on their preferences they should vote for or against the restructuring plan. However, if they do not vote for the restructuring plan, they lose ability for possible future gains and recovery of the firm. The first option can be realized if investors are at least risk-neutral and they believe in the improvement of Marvel’s performance in the future. If the restructuring plan will be realized well, the debt holders could hold their existing stakes in hopes that Marvel turned around successfully. Perelman’s restructuring plan includes divesting of non-core assets and merging with Toy Biz. In case of successful realization of this plan, secured and unsecured debt holders will be paid in full. However, the debt holders already faced a massive loss today along with a real possibility that they would not fully recover their losses in the future. Benefits Capitalize on Marvel’s turnaround (assuming it is successful) Provides Marvel’s team with faith Creates greater returns in the future Reduces current losses if sold stakes during Marvel’s bankruptcy Avoids liquidation of Marvel’s assets (potentially sold significantly under value) Risks Increase in losses because Marvel may never successfully turnaround Lose option to minimize losses (potentially paid in full) Under the second option, the debt holders......

Words: 499 - Pages: 2

Marvel Enterprises, Inc.

...507-P01 5 DE MAYO DE 2005 ANITA ELBERSE Marvel Enterprises, Inc. Era 29 de junho de 2004, um dia antes do lançamento nos cinemas da tão esperada seqüência do filme Homem-Aranha, baseado no personagem mais popular da Marvel Enterprises. O filme parecia destinado a seguir os passos do recordista de bilheterias original ao oferecer sua mistura familiar de forte ação e drama. Porém, Peter Cuneo, o Vice-Presidente e ex-CEO, sabia que sua equipe havia realizado um resgate que nem o Homem-Aranha (ou qualquer outro dos super-heróis sobre os quais a Marvel detinha direitos) teria sucesso – o resgate da própria empresa. Apenas seis anos depois da firma ter emergido da falência, e apenas três anos depois de ter publicado prejuízos de US$100 milhões e ver suas ações serem negociadas próximo a US$1, a Marvel acumulara um valor de mercado de mais de US$2 bilhões, registrando vendas de US$300 milhões e um lucro operacional de cerca de US$170 milhões em 2003, com suas ações sendo negociadas por mais de US$20 (veja o Anexo 1). “O ápice de nosso trabalho veio a algumas semanas atrás, quando o Wall Street Journal selecionou nossas ações como as de melhor desempenho,” disse Cuneo. “Adivinhe quem foi a ação número 1 na Bolsa de Valores de Nova Iorque nos últimos três anos?” Não apenas o negócio original da Marvel de publicação de histórias em quadrinhos foi transformado em uma divisão lucrativa; suas operações de licenciamentos e brinquedos também geraram retornos......

Words: 9506 - Pages: 39


...Bankruptcy and Restructuring at Marvel Entertainment Group Chen Ziqiang Wu Libin Lin Yingshuai Deng Linli Lim Yihao 2011/11/29 1. Why did Marvel file for Chapter 11? Were the proble ms caused by bad luck, bad strategy, or bad execution? We think that Marvel filed for Chapter 11 mainly due to its bad business strategy. Three of its six business lines, Trading cards, Stickers and Comic Books started facing the decline in sales after year 1993. There were two main reasons for this decline: First, these businesses increasingly had to compete with alternative forms of child entertainment (mainly video games). Second, the decline in sales was driven by disappointed collectors who had viewed comic books as a form of investment and stopped buying them as company stopped increasing the prices. We believe that the company should have foreseen these events while performing a market research and forming a long-term business and financial strategy. The three unpromising business lines accounted to 61% of total revenues of a company in year 1995. At the same time, the company's financial strategy was based on highly optimistic business expectations and was not suitable for unfavorable turn of demand for entertainment products towards video games. Due to its high leverage (52%), the company was not able to serve all the debt in case of sharply declining revenues. It is obvious that the company did not anticipate the change in customers' preferences and was......

Words: 2174 - Pages: 9

Marvel Case

...When Marvel had filed for Chapter 11 and bankruptcy they were truly In a time of hardship. In the mid 1990s, Marvel experienced sharp declines in both businesses, causing them to file for bankruptcy in December 1996. The problems were caused by a number of things, but I would have to say bad strategies overall being the biggest reason in which they had to file for bankruptcy. Marcel had six principle lines of business. Sports & Entertainment Cards, Toys, Children’s Activity Stickers, Publishing, Confectionary & Consumer Products and Licensing of characters. While continuing to run the company and trying to maintain operations constant, Marvel was not paying attention to the hottest means of entertainment that was trending; video games. Had they been paying attention to the industry they would have developed a strategy to enter this market. Also, the interest of comic books by consumers were falling sharply, which was another thing Marvel neglected to address. The new restructuring plan suggested by Perlman had three parts. First was an investment of $350 million by Andrew Group. Investments made by Andrew Group will relax the Cash flow position of Marvel. It will in turn increase its net cash reserves, after the acquisition of Toy Biz, by $33.5 billion. Next, as just mentioned was the acquisition of Toy Biz. Toy Biz is engaged in the business of manufacturing toys based on Marvel characters. It generates cash flows of approximately $60 million per annum which can be used......

Words: 364 - Pages: 2


... Marvel Enterprises, Inc. (b) Why was Marvel’s turnaround so successful? Would you characterize that success as a fluke? Or do you view it as sustainable? Why? How? Marvel’s success is definitely not a fluke and its business model is very sustainable. Because Marvel’s new strategy chose to monetize the content library via licensing characters for use with media products. In an era during which mass media is so important in people’s life, only one media tool - publishing is not strong enough to expand Marvel’s influence to consumers. Comic books can only target a very limited market that most is composed of male teenagers and young adults from 13 to 23 years old. It is very difficult to expand this traditional market significantly. After many years development, this market has become matured and very stable. Meanwhile, people are more and more exposed to movies, televisions, and video games, which are very effective to influence people’s consumption behavior than comic books. All these media tools are able to reach more consumer segments than traditional comic-book publishing. Marvel’s potential to develop has increased dramatically when its market has significantly been expanded by broadcast media. Other consumer products, such as toys, work with media products reinforced each other. This market expansion develops not just in a comprehensive manner, but also in an intensive manner. Marvel emphasizes a long-term value in its new management. They plan career for......

Words: 1079 - Pages: 5

Distressed M&a and Corporate Strategy Lessons from Marvel Entertainment Group's Bankruptcy

...lessons from Marvel Entertainment Group’s bankruptcy Joseph Calandro Jr Joseph Calandro Jr is the Enterprise Risk Manager of a global financial services firm and a Finance Department faculty member of the University of Connecticut (joseph.calandro@ s the current recession unfolds, indications are that corporate executives and strategists will be making decisions in an economically distressed environment for some time to come.[1] Historically, investment and M&A activity tend to decline during periods of economic distress. However, a specialty form of acquisition, known pejoratively as ‘‘vulture investing’’ has flourished during such times. Perhaps because it has been practiced as a specialty by financiers accustomed to balancing high risks for quick rewards, acquiring distressed companies has not been widely viewed as a corporate strategic opportunity. Recently, however, distressed M&A has become more common: A B as of April of 2009, there were 60 distressed M&A deals for the year including Valero Energy Corporation’s purchase of VeraSun Energy Corporation’s assets in bankruptcy; in 2008, there were 220 distressed deals; and in 2007, there were 134.[2] B B When assessing distressed M&A opportunities, corporate strategists should leverage their industry knowledge and expertise to search for hidden value, and also to select qualified industry experts to validate strategic and valuation assumptions. The interesting bankruptcy of Marvel......

Words: 4945 - Pages: 20


...How To Make Restructuring Work for Your Company Published: | October 1, 2001 | Author: | Stuart C. Gilson | Executive Summary: A bungled corporate restructuring can turn a good idea into disaster. In an excerpt from his new book, HBS professor Stuart Gilson outlines the keys for a successful corporate makeover. Plus: Gilson Q&A. About Faculty in this Article: Stuart Gilson is the Steven R. Fenster Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School. * More Working Knowledge from Stuart C. Gilson * Stuart C. Gilson - Faculty Research Page Editor's Note: The following excerpt is taken from the "Lessons of Restructuring" section of Gilson's introduction to Creating Value through Corporate Restructuring. Although the case studies in this book span a wide range of companies, industries, and contexts, some common issues and themes emerge. Taken together, they suggest there are three critical hurdles or challenges that management faces in any restructuring program: 1. Design. What type of restructuring is appropriate for dealing with the specific challenge, problem, or opportunity that the company faces? 2. Execution. How should the restructuring process be managed and the many barriers to restructuring overcome so that as much value is created as possible? 3. Marketing. How should the restructuring be explained and portrayed to investors so that value created inside the company is fully credited to its stock price? Failure to address any one......

Words: 4255 - Pages: 18


...BANKRUPTCY This article is intended to provide some general bankruptcy information and is certainly not intended to replace the tailored information a debtor will receive from an attorney. Bankruptcy is governed by Federal Law (Title 11 of the US Code separated into individual Chapters, each dealing with a different type of bankruptcy) but the bankruptcy laws of each state also play an important part; consequently, though there are bankruptcy kits, you will probably need a lawyer to successfully file and a lawyer search should focus on a bankruptcy attorney or bankruptcy law firm licensed in the debtor’s state of residence. The attorney licensed in your state can tell you how to file for bankruptcy in a federal court within your state. American bankruptcy is actually a form of relief granted by a court, so it is not so much a matter of a debtor “declaring bankruptcy”; rather, someone files a petition requesting that the court discharge or reduce or restructure debts in bankruptcy. In American bankruptcy, a federal court manages a debtor’s property to protect the debtor from his/her creditors and to benefit the creditors as much as possible under the circumstances. While bankruptcy is designed for long-term relief, one of the most important features of filing for bankruptcy is the “automatic stay.” When a petition is filed for bankruptcy, either by the debtor (“voluntary bankruptcy”) or by one of his/her creditors (“involuntary bankruptcy”), most collection efforts......

Words: 960 - Pages: 4