Barbara Norris: Leading Change in the General Surgery Unit

In: Business and Management

Submitted By khairilthegreat
Words 441
Pages 2
Barbara Norris facing many difficulties. The GSU which she lead is currently short-staffed and does not perform as she expected. Her staffs have low morale and low motivation to do their daily job. On top of that, there is a cultural issue where confrontation, blaming, and favoritism are typical in her unit. She also facing a budget problem where overtime has been eliminated due to cost cutting measure implemented on the hospital. The budget cut make it difficult to Barbara to allocate a right personnel in case of some staff take a personal or vacation leave. In many cases, she has to rely on nurses from general float pool to cover the staff on leave, but this often lead to negative effect to her staff dynamics because the substitute nurses is not familiar with the GSU.

There are three broad problem Barbara has to solve: lack of collaboration and teamwork, staff conflict either within her unit or within the hospital, and lack of transparent performance appraisal procedures. All of this three issues need to be address simultaneously to ensure that the unit perform as Barbara expected.

It is evident that there is conflict between junior nurses, senior nurses, and PCAS’s which lead to ineffective collaboration among them. Junior nurses feels like the don’t belong to the team and they don’t get positive feedback from senior nurses. On the other hand, senior nurses feels that many junior nurses and PCA’s are incompetent and feel overwhelmed to support them. To solve this issues, Barbara need to redefine a clear role among the nurses and make sure that the role is properly understood by all her staff. In redefining the role, she must include advice from her staff to ensure that the role definition fit within her unit. She also need to develop a transparent communication mechanism to solve any role discrepancy within her unit.
To address the performance appraisal…...

Similar Documents

Leading Change

...Synthesis Paper Leading Change Deborah Sarrion Nova Southeastern University August 10, 2012 Introduction Leadership is a work in progress. Just as we grow and change into adults, we grow and change as needed in the leadership roles we have throughout our professional life. Leaders need to be open to change, to give others the chance to make decisions and lead. A good leader is a humble leader. Webster's dictionary defines Humility as the state or quality of being humble; absence of pride or self-assertion (2010). When organizations introduce humility inducing opportunities, the experience causes newcomers to question their prior behavior, beliefs, and values (Miracles, 2010). Leadership can be defined as the ability to influence someone or a group of people to follow ideas or certain steps to ultimately attain change. It is change that leads organizations to reach their goals. Leadership, is identified by Northouse (2010), as a concept related to power for of its ability to influence. Wise (2011) mentions the importance of leadership coaching. Leadership coaching is exceptionally good for school administrator. It’s simple coaching to help communicate and understand the needs of the students,......

Words: 1284 - Pages: 6

Leading Change.

...PPT: 3. Leadership and Managing Change (Week 10) Think about: Differences between management and leadership The role of managers and leaders in change Impact of leadership on change outcomes 3. Critically analyse the influence a leader can have on the outcome of proposed organisational change with reference to the differences between leadership and management. A. The difference between the leadership and management: 1. Management is concerned with maintaining the current organisation (doing things right)-contractual exchanges and compliance. 2. Leadership is concerned with change (doing the right things) – inspirational exchanges and empowerment ( Bennis and Manus, 1985; Covey, 1996; Hayes,2010) 3. Managers and leaders attend to similar functions - but do so in very different ways. 4. However, managerial work in times of change is increasingly a leadership task (Hayes, 2010) 5. Deciding what needs to be done: Managers: Set goals, establish detailed steps; Identify and allocate resources in order to achieve these objectives. Leaders: Create vision, set a vision Develop the necessary strategies to get there 6. Developing the talent (才能)to do it: Managers: Focus on aligning(调整)resources-organising and staffing Leaders: Focus on aligning people, communicate the new direction and creating coalition to get there. 7. Ensuring that is done: Managers: Ensuring people accomplish plans through control and......

Words: 1221 - Pages: 5

General Surgery

...General Surgery is a surgical specialty that focuses on abdominal contents including esophagus, stomach, small bowel, colon, liver, pancreas, gallbladder and bile ducts, and often the thyroid gland (depending on the availability of head and neck surgery specialists). They also deal with diseases involving the skin, breast, soft tissue, and hernias. Services Offered : Trauma surgery – Often they are the first port of call to critically ill or gravely injured patients, and must perform a variety of procedures to stabilize such patients, such as intubation, burr hole, cricothyroidotomy, and emergency laparotomy or thoracotomy to stanch bleeding. Laparoscopic surgery – This is a relatively new specialty dealing with minimal access techniques using cameras and small instruments inserted through 0.3 to 1 cm incisions. Robotic General surgeons that are trained today are expected to be proficient in laparoscopic procedures. Colorectal surgery – General surgeons treat a wide variety of major and minor colon and rectal diseases including inflammatory bowel diseases (such as ulcerative colitis or Crohn's disease), diverticulitis, colon and rectal cancer, gastrointestinal bleeding and hemorrhoids. Breast surgery – General surgeons perform a majority of all non-cosmetic breast surgery from lumpectomy to mastectomy, especially pertaining to the evaluation and diagnosis, of breast cancer. Vascular surgery – General surgeons can perform vascular surgery if they receive special training...

Words: 315 - Pages: 2

Leading for Change

...EXAM DETAILS Course Code: Course Description: Date of exam: BUSM4177 Leading for Change 04/06/2012 Start time ofexam: 8 09:15 Duration of exam: 2hr 15min Total number of pages (incl. this cover sheet) ALLOWABLE MATERIALS AND INSTRUCTIONS TO CANDIDATES 1. Write your full name and student number on each exam booklet together with the number of exam books used. Students must not write. mark in any way any exam materials, read any other text other than the exam paper or do any calculations during reading time. 2. 3. All mobile phones must be switched off and placed under your desk. You are in breach of exam conditions if it is on your person (ie. pocket). This is a CLOSED BOOK Exam. 4. 5. Commence each question on a new page. Carry out the instructions on the front cover of the exam script book and the front of this exam paper. 6. Calculators are not allowed. 7. 8. 9. This exam comprises 50% of the overall marks available in this course Each question has a Part A (8 marks) and a Part B (7 marks) to give a total of 15 marks. Answer any THREE (3) questions 10. Up to 5 additional 5 marks (in total) may be awarded if there is evidence of critical thinking in your answers. BUSM 4177 Leading for Change Semester 1, 2012 Examination page 1 BUSM 4177 Leading for Change (Melbourne semester 1, 2012) Exam Case study Yarra Valley Water: Learning and change for sustainability By PATRICK CRITTENDEN, SUZANNE BENN AND DEXTER......

Words: 3422 - Pages: 14

Leading Change

...Leading Change Paper University of Phoenix Good Sport, Inc manufactures and sells fitness equipment such as treadmills, exercise bikes and other exercise equipment. The company was founded by an ex-basketball player Jason Poole in Coral Springs Florida. The company has created a hierarchy organizational structure which includes a span of control. “Span of control is the number of people directly reporting to the next level in the organizational hierarchy,” (McShane & Von Glinow, Chpt. 15 pg 17) which includes team members, team managers, vice presidents, Chief Executive Officer (CEO), and other management officials, for Good Sport. Within the span of control there are various subsections creating a form of departmentalization. “Departmentalization specifies how employees and their activities are grouped together. It is a fundamental strategy for coordinating organizational activities because it influences organizational behavior in the following ways: (1) Departmentalization establishes the "chain of command," that is, the system of common supervision among positions and units within the organization. It establishes formal work teams (2) Departmentalization usually creates common measures of performance. (3) Members of the same work team, for example, share common goals and budgets, giving the company standards against which to compare subunit performance and (4) Departmentalization encourages coordination through informal communication among people and subunits. With......

Words: 2529 - Pages: 11

Leading Change

...Leading Change Leaders who successfully transform a business do 8 things right and they do them in order. 8 Steps for Transformative Change: 1. Establish a sense of Urgency “Make status quo more dangerous than launching into the unknown” a. Examine market & competitive realities b. Identify & discuss crises, potential crises or major opportunities 2. Form a Powerful Guiding Coalition a. Assemble a group with enough power to lead change b. Encourage the group together as a team (H.P.T – 5 Dysfunctions of a Team) 3. Create a Vision a. Create a vision to help direct change effort b. Develop strategies for achieving that vision 4. Communicating the Vision a. Use every vehicle possible to communicate the new vision & strategies b. Teaching new behaviours by the example of the guiding coalition (team) 5. Empowering Others to Act on the Vision a. Get rid of obstacles to change b. Changing systems or structures that seriously undermine the vision c. Encourage risk taking and non-traditional ideas, activities and actions “If it feels comfortable – you aren’t doing anything different or challenging yourself enough” 6. Planning for & Creating Short-Term Wins a. Planning for visible performance improvements b. Creating those improvements c. Recognizing & rewarding employees involved in the improvements 7. Consolidating Improvements & Produce More Change a. Using increased credibility to change systems, structures and policies that don’t fit the......

Words: 1052 - Pages: 5

Barbara Norris Facing Many Difficulties. the Gsu Which She Lead Is Currently Short-Staffed and Does Not Perform as She Expected. Her Staffs Have Low Morale and Low Motivation to Do Their Daily Job. on Top of That, There

...Case Barbara Norris: Leading Change in the General Surgery Unit باربارا نوريس التغير القيادي في الجراحه Harvard Business Review Boris Groysberg Nitin Nohria Deborah Bell March-13-2009 Permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu or 617.783.7860 It was 10 PM and Barbara Norris, nurse manager for the large General Surgery Unit (GSU) at Eastern Massachusetts University Hospital (EMU) sat down at her desk to catch her breath. She had been on the unit since 6:30 AM but planned to stay for another two hours to help with the transition from the second to third shift and the orientation of two registered nurses (RN) from the float pool. It had been one month since she had assumed the nurse manager role for the troubled unit. During this time she felt, as she did this evening, tired and overwhelmed. As nurse manager she was responsible for managing the staff, scheduling and budget for the unit. Her 33-person staff included 25 RNs and eight patient care assistants (PCAs). In her first month as nurse manager she had already lost two RNs and in the six months prior to her joining the unit three RNs had left. But because of the recently instituted hiring freeze at EMU, Barbara was not able to replace some of these positions. The unit was short-staffed; stress levels were high and employee morale low. In fact, GSU had the lowest employee satisfaction scores and highest employee turnover rate among all of the departments at EMU. And although its patient satisfaction scores......

Words: 2565 - Pages: 11

Barbara Norris Case

...Barbara Norris Case Analysis Synopsis ­ Barbara month into a management position of a unit that is ‘Troubled’ she has had no experience in managing a large units which included managing, scheduling and budgeting. The unit is short staffed, stressed and there is a high turnover with a poor culture. Indicated by the 29 one­to­one that were requested page 2 & top of 3. Worst performing unit John Frappewell (Nursing Director) needs her to ‘turn this unit around and do it fast’ could be used as a vote of confidence and a leverage point? Management have enacted a hiring freeze and stopped all overtime across the EMU Barbara has the benefit of knowing what good management looks likes with Betty Nolan her old mentor people / leadership skills (2nd last para page 2) and procedural performance reviews (top of page 3) ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ Summary Notes Problems: ­ The GSU has a history of less than effective management in the past (page 3 para2) ­ Culturally poor collaboration and teamwork (page4) ­ Performance review system is a “mystery” (page4) ­ No clear communication (page4) ­ Delegation process is unclear (page4) Over aching all this is the presence of the hospital budget cuts which makes a monetary solution difficult to enact. 29 one on ones requested on the first day does some up the feeling of resentment and negativity. Solutions Barbara clearly has an excellent grasp on what the issues are but the question is what to tackle first and where is the most benefit going to be. Her......

Words: 1058 - Pages: 5

Barbara Norris Case-

...As you are aware, Barbara Norris has recently been promoted as nurse manager in the General Surgery Unit (GSU) here at Eastern Massachusetts University Hospital (EMU). She has inherited a unit with the lowest employee satisfaction scores and highest employee turnover rate among all the departments at the hospital. GSU is known for its culture of confrontation, blaming, and favoritism. Additionally, the staff that has remained is dissatisfied, unmotivated and does not function as a team to deliver care. As a result of the lack of unity, GSU’s patient satisfaction scores, although average, have been declining steadily over the past few years. One of Barbara’s main objectives for accepting the position was the challenge to try to turn the unit around. While Barbara has a tough job ahead of her, she is off to a good start in showing the staff that she is genuinely interested in hearing their problems and concerns. The purpose of this memo is to analyze the main issues in the unit and offer recommendations to solve them. The Off-site In an off-site workshop that Barbara conducted earlier this week, the GSU staff revealed to her several problems in the unit. Megan Mahoney, who had only been on the unit for one year, expressed her disappointment with some of the senior nurses. She said, “You make me feel like I am doing everything wrong but won’t address me directly or in a straightforward manner” and “you said you were tired of me and all of my questions and called me a......

Words: 1130 - Pages: 5

Leading Change

...Leading Change by John P. Kotter Introduction of author John P. Kotter, a worldwide famous expert on leadership at Harvard Business School, was a graduate of MIT and Harvard. He joined the Harvard Business School faculty in 1972 and who was voted tenure and a full professorship at the age of thirty-three in 1980. Kotter's honors include an Exxon Award for Innovation in Graduate Business School Curriculum Design and a Johnson, Smith and Knisely Award for New Perspectives in Business Leadership. He again gained the title as the #1 ¡§Leadership Guru¡¨ from a survey for 504 enterprises that was conducted by Business Week magazine. Outline of this book Leading Change was named the top management book of the year by Management General. There are three major sections in this book. The first section is ¡§the change of problem and its solution¡¨ ; which discusses why firms fail. The second one is ¡§the eight-stage process¡¨ that deals with methods of performing changes. Lastly, ¡§implications for the twenty-first century¡¨ is discussed as the conclusion. The eight stages of process are as followed: (1) Establishing a sense of urgency. (2) Creating the guiding coalition. (3) Developing a vision and a strategy. (4) Communicating the change of vision. (5) Empowering employees for broad-based action. (6) Generating short-term wins. (7) Consolidating gains and producing more changes. (8) Anchoring new approaches in the culture. Perspective on this book This book carries great...

Words: 925 - Pages: 4

Leading Change

...order). Leading Change Why Transformation Efforts Fail by John P Kotter . • Included with this full-text Harvard Business Review article: 1 Article Summary The Idea in Brief—the core idea The Idea in Practice—putting the idea to work 2 Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail 10 Further Reading A list of related materials, with annotations to guide further exploration of the article’s ideas and applications Reprint R0701J BEST OF HBR Leading Change Why Transformation Efforts Fail The Idea in Brief The Idea in Practice Most major change initiatives—whether intended to boost quality, improve culture, or reverse a corporate death spiral—generate only lukewarm results. Many fail miserably. To give your transformation effort the best chance of succeeding, take the right actions at each stage—and avoid common pitfalls. Why? Kotter maintains that too many managers don’t realize transformation is a process, not an event. It advances through stages that build on each other. And it takes years. Pressured to accelerate the process, managers skip stages. But shortcuts never work. Equally troubling, even highly capable managers make critical mistakes—such as declaring victory too soon. Result? Loss of momentum, reversal of hard-won gains, and devastation of the entire transformation effort. COPYRIGHT © 2006 HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. By understanding the stages of change— and......

Words: 6152 - Pages: 25

Leading Change

...B EST OF HBR Leading Change Why Transformation Efforts Fail To give your transformation effort the best chance of succeeding, take the right actions at each stage—and avoid common pitfalls. The Idea in Brief The Idea in Practice Stage | Actions Needed | Pitfalls | Establish a sense of urgency | * Examine market and competitive reali- ties for potential crises and untapped opportunities. * Convince at least 75% of your man- agers that the status quo is more dan- gerous than the unknown. | * Underestimating the difficulty of driving people from their comfort zones * Becoming paralyzed by risks | Form a pow- erful guiding coalition | * Assemble a group with shared commit- ment and enough power to lead the change effort. * Encourage them to work as a team outside the normal hierarchy. | * No prior experience in teamwork at the top * Relegating team leadership to an HR, quality, or strategic-planning executive rather than a senior line manager | Create a vision | * Create a vision to direct the change effort. * Develop strategies for realizing that vision. | * Presenting a vision that’s too complicat- ed or vague to be communicated in five minutes | Communicate the vision | * Use every vehicle possible to commu- nicate the new vision and strategies for achieving it. * Teach new behaviors by the example of the guiding coalition. | * Undercommunicating the vision * Behaving in ways antithetical to the vision | ......

Words: 5665 - Pages: 23

Leading Change

...According to John Kotter, there are eight essential steps to take when you are leading change. The first step is to create urgency, meaning you need to create the initial motivation to change within the organization. In the case of Blockbuster, we will need to not only communicate our poor performance, but express the urgent need for us to change our business, or face being pushed out of the market by our competitors. Seventy five percent of people within the organization need to be on board with change in order for the change to be successful (Kotter). The first step is very important, as failure to get everyone motivated to change will result in the change not gaining momentum, and ultimately failing. The second step is to build what Kotter calls a “change coalition”. This step involves asking members of the organization to make a commitment to change, and a commitment to communicate the urgent need for change with others. The people who will be most effective will be good leaders, and of course, those with a large stake in the organization. The third step is to create a clear vision for change, and communicate that vision frequently. We will need to determine the values that are essential to the change, and summarize what we see for the future of our company. We will then create a strategy for facilitating change, and make sure that every member of our change coalition can communicate our vision accurately, and with a short summary. The fourth step is all about......

Words: 857 - Pages: 4

Leading Change

...Kotter, John P. "Leading Change. Why transformation efforts fail", Harvard Business Review, January 2007, pp 92-107 HSN O T H E T E S T S F A L E A D E R 8 H S TS F 1995 ultimate test of a leader no busrness Editors Note: Gulding changemay be the itself' But' human nature betng survives over the long term if it can't reinvent resistedmighttly by the people it most what it is, fundamental changeis often leading change is both affects: thosetn the trenchesof the business'Thus' absotutelyessentialand incredibly difficult change better of organizatronal Perhapsnobody understandsthe anatomY P Kotter'Thisarticle' professorJohn than retiredHarvard Business School prevtewedKotter's1996book Leadtng of spring 1995' in originallypubtished the a factors f rom establishtng sense of ergnt criticalsuccess Change.lt outlines ("lhe wins' to changtngthe culture to e\traordinarY urgencY, creating short-term famitiarwhen vou read it' in pan way we do things around 6srs") lt will feel becauseKotter'svocabularyhasenteredthelexiconandinpartbecauseit containsthekindofhometruthsthatwerecognize,immediately'asifwe'd work on leadtngchange remains alwaysknown them.A decadelater, his definitive. Change Leading Efforts whyTransformati0n Fail theydo them do businesses eightthingsr ight( and y w L e a d e r s h o su cce ssfu l ltra n sfo rm in t h e r i g h to r d e r). by John P.Kofter I L l lt I DECADE,have watched more than......

Words: 1806 - Pages: 8

Barbara Norris Case Study

...Term Paper Case Study: Barbara Norris, Leading Change in the General Surgery Unit Term Paper Case Study Hodges University HAS 3129 Professor Mary MacLaughlin 12/10/15 Table of Contents Introduction to the Case Study…………………………………………………………………………………………..1 Statement of the Problems………………………………………………………………………………………………..2 Generating Alternatives and Analyzing the Data……………………………………………………………….2 Selecting Decision Criteria…………………………………………………………………………………………………..3 Analyzing and Evaluating Alternatives and Action………………………………………………………………4 Recommendations and Implementation Plan…………………………………………………………………….6 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………9 References………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….10 Term Paper Case Study Barbara Norris: Leading Change in the General Surgery Unit Introduction to the Case Study Healthcare is defined as the maintenance and improvement of physical and mental health, especially through the provision of medical services (healthcare.gov). Most healthcare organizations have a mission statement that reads something like this: Our mission is to provide extraordinary care, where the patient comes first, supported by world class education and research. The job of Nurse Manager within such an organization is to help patients by managing the nurses who care for them. This includes fostering a work place where nurses respect each other and feel valued while providing quality care to patients and their families. “A......

Words: 3154 - Pages: 13