Free Essay

Because Freedom Can't Protect Itself

In: English and Literature

Submitted By kaayy117
Words 1532
Pages 7
Kayla Yelton
Dehr/ Huffman
ENG W131-46
10/11/2012
Final Draft Rhetorical Analysis
Because Freedom Can’t Protect Itself
ACLU’s website is very large and a reader would probably only come across it if he or she was on a search for specific information. The website is built mostly off of their credibility. The main point made by the website is that the reader has to protect his freedom, someone has to take a stand. ACLU builds up much of their credibility, and through articles and blog posts they try to gain support. Many of their articles are argumentative and informational as a way to gain support for their cause.
When searching a popular, controversial topic ACLU will most likely pop up on the first page of one’s search results. When doing a search about “drug testing in the workplace” ACLU came up second with a link to the article, “Privacy in America: Workplace Drug Testing.” The ACLU’s concerns and values can be summarized by going to the bottom of any page on their website. The headers of links at the bottom of the page give away what topics they’re working with such as Human Rights, Immigrants’ Rights, LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender) Rights, and Racial Justice. When using a search engine to search for any topic in these categories ACLU usually comes up on the first page of websites. ACLU comes up at least fourth or fifth most of the time when searching topics they are working with. This gives them more credibility because it tells the reader that this website is popular among many readers or that it is visited quite often.

“Because Freedom Can’t Protect Itself,” and the page logo are the first things a reader sees on the website because they are placed at the very top in darker shades of blue. These two things give the reader an idea of who is behind this website. The logo says, “ACLU, American Civil Liberties Union,” and the Statue of Liberty is featured in the top left corner of the logo. The name of this group has been made very popular among Human Right’s activists throughout the years. The name says they’re a union which also tells the reader that this is a group of people and not just one person. The reader understands from the logo that this is a group fighting for human rights because that is essentially what “civil liberties” suggests. Then, the motto backs that idea up. “Because freedom can’t protect itself,” means that as a people we have to fight for our freedom. If the reader doesn’t fight for freedom it will be taken away or limited. The motto tells the reader that freedom is helpless unless the people work to preserve it and that is what ACLU is working to do.
The article “Privacy in America: Workplace Drug Testing,” is surrounded by links, most links are categorized. The website has the main or more important tabs listed in red unlike the rest of the tabs on the page, which are blue, to draw the reader’s attention these tabs. The reader is drawn to many of these different links either by personal interest or because it is bolded and sticks out. Right away it is apparent to the reader by the number of links, and the topics throughout the links, that this is a very large and active website. Throughout the page ACLU is constantly trying to draw the reader to other topics because they want as many readers’ support on as many topics as possible.
The article only uses quotes twice. The first quote is after the first couple of paragraphs while the other one is right past the middle of the article. The first quote has the author right below it, but the second one doesn’t seem to have an author. The quotes set a trend of negativity. The quotes are much larger than the regular text and are light blue as a way to stand out from the rest of the article. The first quote is bolded entirely unlike the second one where only the title is bolded. This leads the reader to pay attention to the first quote before they read the second one. The quotes are set up with a similar purpose to the technique of bolding certain phrases. The quotes give these sections of the article more light, or attention, and also makes the reader feel upset or sympathetic. The quotes communicate feelings of error, humiliation, degradation, and mortification by putting the reader in the author’s shoes for that moment. This enhances the theme of getting the reader to feel wronged and sympathetic.
The bias of the article is clear from the very beginning. In the second sentence it starts by negatively addressing drug testing as unfair, inaccurate, and states that it’s an unproven method to stopping drug use. The article then tries to share the feeling of having privacy invaded by stating how few laws we have to protect privacy and how innocent people are tested and invaded personally without suspicion. The article bolds some phrases to give certain emphasis and attention. The audience is lured in to feel sympathetic towards these bolded points, such as, “Even though they aren’t suspected of drug use.” The bolded points throughout the article are mostly negative using terms like invasion, error, humiliation, degradation, mortification, and fail.
There were no sources in the article to show where they got their information, but instead they were all placed at the end. This is confusing to the reader since they cannot tell which information came from which source unless they go to the sources themselves. They used 3 different types of sources. They used a survey, 2 books, and a scholarly journal article. These sources give the article credibility since the information was found in several different locations and by 3 different means.
The end of the article is followed up by a response article which is about 4 paragraphs long. This last article is labeled “What We Are Doing.” This article is short so the reader can quickly read it over without getting bored or distracted. ACLU wants people to know what they are doing; by keeping it short more people are more likely to see the important points and draw out that information. If they would have elaborated and made this section longer they could possibly lose the reader in the text. The important information such as their work would be skimmed past. Keeping things short avoids this. The response starts by sharing what ACLU has done to further their cause, which establishes more credibility by showing these people are going out and actually working to make a difference on these issues, and then moves on to explain the progress that has been made in the states. The response finally ends by putting the power in the readers’ hands by saying that the reader can help make a difference. When moving on through the website the reader can see it is mostly comprised of articles on topics they have worked for and the history of the organization. These articles stand as a way to inform people and to get them behind ACLU’s cause. Most of their articles are argumentative or informative.
When at the home page one of the first things the reader sees is a display that is flashing news and updates about their work. This builds on their credibility because all of the updates are recent human rights cases. Then below there are several blogs and press releases posted daily. This is also a strong backing to their credibility since these blogs are discussing work actually being done by them and the press releases confirm it since those are public and made by outside sources.
If the reader were to go on to the About Us page the foundation of credibility built throughout the website would be concreted. In this portion of the website ACLU discusses how they were formed and lists all the work they have done since. This concretes their credibility because they have been around since the beginning of the twentieth century and have been in many legitimate cases. This gives the reader an idea of what type of people ACLU is comprised of by seeing what issues they have worked with.
The voting and working publics are the targeted audiences because these people can help make a difference and support their cause. Politicians, voters, workers, and activists are the most likely to come across this page. The topics fall in line with the interests or lives of these types of audiences. This website is on a mission to get as many supporters as possible. That is the main purpose of the website. The second reason for this site is to inform. ACLU draws people in with topics people are interested in or that affect them. In the articles they talk about what the public cares about. They often talk about what’s wrong or what they don’t agree with. Then, they try to get the audience to see things from their point of view. This way they can gain the support of many more civilians.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Freedom and Democracy

...Direct Democracy What is freedom and democracy? Freedom and democracy have multiple different meanings that can be interpreted in many ways. Countries that have never enjoyed these experiences before, for example Afghanistan should ease into this type of democracy. The ideal type of democracy for this county would most certainly be direct democracy where the people are far more intelligent and wise than selfish, greedy politicians, whose time horizon is just the next election. Democracy is certainly not synonymous with freedom. For the most part, democracies are controlled by those people with the financial means to run for office or by those people who are backed by some external power. While we would like to believe that our votes count and that our voice is heard, for the most part, people find themselves increasingly told what to believe by those who have the money or power to have their message heard. If the people who represent us in the government are nothing like us, how can they represent us? They can't. However laws have been passed to make it difficult for anyone without the necessary capital or connections to run for any office for the most part. When the majority of us are slowly regressing towards poverty and the rich have absolute power and influence through both the people who represent us and through the power of lobbies then it is time to examine our options. We are essentially not free. We have been brainwashed into believing we are through the illusion......

Words: 1629 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Freedom of Speech

...some of the types of censorships enforced in the countries; however, people have the right of freedom of speech and the knowledge behind political issues, so these should not be censored by the country. Censorship is a problem that is known from before World War 1 and it is still a controversial issue with many people who are with the act and laws set regarding censorship and many who are against. Censorship is the restraint over any type of communication like speech regarding many different matters. For example, being against rules set or some political moves that a country performs, things that are considered to be harmful, sensitive, or inconvenient to the general body of people. These things that constraints are set upon are determined by the government, or media outlet. There are a lot of debates behind the topic “censorship.” One of them is, should governments put regulations on broadcasters, or does that affect people’s freedom, other debates are about whether the flag amendment in America is considered a threat to liberty or no. In the United States there are a lot of acts that would control the freedom of speech of people. For example, the sedation acts that prohibited the people in America to judge or criticize the policies exercised by the government (Bauder, 2007). Other acts like the First Amendment law, exercises a set of rules including the rule of protection for freedom of speech which includes entertainment. After the outrageous act preformed by Justine......

Words: 3670 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Power of Freedom

...How far would you go to defend freedom? Would you overcome impossible odds? In the films “Braveheart” and “The Lord of the Rings,” the main characters, Mel Gibson and Elijah Wood, go to the ends of the earth to achieve their goals and bring freedom to the people within their society. The two main plots emphasize the concept that no matter what nation you live under, any man or woman will fight to defend their right to freedom. In “Braveheart”, Mel Gibson, plays William Wallace. In the movie his wife is brutally killed by one of the English kings. Before the death of his wife, Wallace also experiences the death of his brother and father by the hands of the same aggressor when he was a child. After this he decides that any aggressive action against those he holds dear will not be left unavenged. The day of his wife’s death, William waited for his wife at a secret hiding place and when he finds out she isn’t coming because she was killed, he takes the ways of the law into his own hands. When William becomes a revolutionary he leads the Scottish people to an uprising against the English government. William then begins to de-thrown all the kings in the English region. He loses all sense of inhibition while pursuing his desire to avenge his loved ones’ death and brings freedom to his people. “The Lord of the Rings” is a movie about the plight of mankind while defending itself against a great evil of a supernatural kind. In this movie, the main character, Frodo Baggins,......

Words: 599 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Is the Government Justified in Involving Itself in the Private Lives of Citizens?

...Is government ever justified in involving itself in the private lives and personal decisions of its citizens? Why of why not? Yes, the government is always justified when immersing itself in the lives of its citizens, as the benefits of this practice will always outweigh its consequences. This question had a very definite answer when great men like George Washington, John Adams, Benjamin Franklin, John Hancock, etc. found our great nation of America: no. Back then, it was very obvious that government should not spy on its own citizens and make decisions for them. This was actually the philosophy that the nation was based off, the Americans were tired of the British government controlling their lives, so they broke free and found the United States of America. But in today’s technologically advancing information age, the question is severely complicated with inventions like the Global Positions System, the World Wide Web, computer chips, the cellular telephone, etc. Of course, there are laws to regulate surveillance on these devices, but the invention of new technologies is passing these laws. As complicated as the question gets, I believe that the government is justified to immerse itself into the private lives and decisions of its citizens for a multitude of reasons. First, government surveillance practices can save lives, put criminals behind bars, or even find missing people, which definitely warrants the need for cellular surveillance. Another example of this......

Words: 1737 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Freedom of Religion

...Has the UN General Assembly Declaration of Human Rights, made on the 10th December 1948, stood the test of time? A short essay focusing on freedom of religion. Introduction “Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public or private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance.” (Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 18, http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/index.shtml, accessed 14th March 2014) This essay will show that the rights protected in Article 18 - as with many other Articles of the UDHR (Universal Declaration of Human Rights) are protected to varying degrees – to not at all, depending on where you live, the level of democracy in your society, culture and lastly; external factors that dominate ordinary democratic processes and because of the forces applied by the geopolitical and economic forces of the day. The essay will show this by illustrating often controversial and disputed examples of violation on religious freedom in France, Saudi Arabia and Burma (Maynamar) and testing the principles of UDHR on those cases whilst also considering the socio-economic and political drivers. Simply defining human rights and its elements can be complex. This is shown in the minor disagreement between the drafters of the UDHR as described later below. This essay will also use......

Words: 2172 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Fighting for Freedom

...Fighting for Freedom Maria G. Ramirez 07/17/2014 Fresno Pacific University Com-342, Adv Acad Research & Comp. Instructor: Jon Edicott Abstract Females in school are exposed to all kinds of different rules that takes away their right to express themselves. During this essay you will find reasons why dress codes are difficult to follow upon female student. This essay will also explore some of the different controversial issues between schools and female students due to the dress code policy, and the different ways females use to fight back. School dress codes are more for females than males, because schools see women as distraction for males and others. Schools dress codes are messing with the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which gives the students the right to express themselves, without hurting others. We will see how females fight back on what they believe it is taking their freedom of speech and freedom to express their unique personalities. Fighting For Freedom Women like to express themselves through clothing, shoes, hair, make up and all kind of different accessories. Regardless of what color, religion, what body size or shape they have, females like to personalize their style using fashion and new trends. While parents drill on their female children the importance to love and feel comfortable with themselves no matter how they look. Schools portrays women as a “distraction” for men and others. They are......

Words: 3854 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Law and Freedom

...Psychology 3 FREEDOM Freedom starts with a principle of self-control, also known as self-ownership. In a free society, each and every person has legal control (or "ownership") of their own body and mind. As such, the concept of freedom refers to a certain type of political empowerment. It refers specifically to equal empowerment. In other words, a free society is one with an equal distribution of legal rights and in which each and every person has as much legal rights as possible. Because freedom entails political equality, freedom can only logically entail as much legal rights as compatible with the same legal rights in others. In a free society, any one person cannot have so many legal rights that all other people could not logically have the same amount of legal rights. For example, freedom does not include the legal right to enslave someone else because freedom includes the legal right to not be enslaved. In another example, freedom does not include the legal right to non-defensively punch other people in the face against their will because freedom includes the legal right to not be offensively punched. Basically, a free person has the legal allowance to do whatever he or she wants insofar as he or she does not offensively harm or coerce other people against those other people's wills. Remember, the limitation is a logical requirement. Freedom obviously can not include the legal right to limit other people's freedom because that would be illogical. Freedom does include......

Words: 1598 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Academic Freedom

...Definition: Academic freedom  freedom to teach or communicate ideas or facts without being targeted for repression, job loss, or imprisonment. - Freedom to teach and do research without the constraint to discover and promulgate new ideas. ( Robinson & Moulton, 2002) - Protection of the rights of the teacher in teaching and of the student to freedom in learning.(1940 Statement of Academic Freedom and Tenure) - The 1987 Philippine Constitution states that, "Academic Freedom shall be enjoyed in all institutions of higher learning Historical Event that suppressed Academic Freedom: • Socrates (470-399 BC) was put to death for corrupting the youth of Athens with his ideas • Galileo (1564-1642) was sentenced to life imprisonment for Advocating Copernican view of the Solar System • (1882-1890) – Teachers were fired for telling their students on Darwins view The principle of Academic Freedom which were originated in Greece, arose again in Europe during the Rennaisance Period in which the Age of Reason came to maturity. Origin of the Academic Freedom in the United States • Academic Freedom in the United States were heavily influence by the German universities and the growth of the non sectarian America universities. The rise of ideological conflicts, especially relating to economic theory. The faculty began to feel the need to protect the faculty against the......

Words: 1608 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Freedom

...Therefore, freedom is not absolute. In the West where personal freedom is held in the highest esteem, there are still definable limits. Freedom of speech, in the words of an American jurist, does not include the freedom to yell “Fire!” in a crowded theatre, unless of course there is a fire. America has enshrined in its constitution the Bill of Rights with the specific purpose of protecting the civil liberties of its citizens. Among its provisions are the freedoms of speech, religion, and peaceful assembly, together with the rights of due process. These statutes notwithstanding, they did not protect Japanese Americans from being forcefully relocated and incarcerated during World War II, and more recently, the detention of thousands of Arab-Americans following the 9/11 attacks. Today the injustices perpetrated on those Japanese-Americans are widely acknowledged, but significantly, the Supreme Court decision affirming the legality of that mass detention has yet to be overturned. There will always be limits to freedom; the pertinent question is where those lines are drawn and the role they play in the ordinary lives of the citizens. Limits on human freedom can be viewed likewise. In America there are definite limits but they are more like the moat; the citizens are hardly aware of them. They are not intrusive. Executive powers to establish military tribunals for example, are definite boundaries and gross infringements on the citizens’ freedom. Similarly Canada has its War......

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Protect

.......... 334 AWS Is the Leading Cloud-Computing Service Provider......................... 334 AWS Enables Innovation.............................................................................. 335 AWS Is Cost Effective................................................................................... 336 AWS Aligns Your Organization with the Future of Technology.............. 336 AWS Is Good for Your Career...................................................................... 337 Chapter 14: Ten Design Principles for Cloud Applications . . . . . . . . 339 Everything Fails All the Time...................................................................... 339 Redundancy Protects Against Resource Failure...................................... 340 Geographic Distribution Protects Against Infrastructure Failure.......... 340 Monitoring Prevents Problems................................................................... 341 Utilization Review Prevents Waste............................................................. 342 Application Management Automates Administration............................. 343 Security Design Prevents Breaches and Data Loss.................................. 343 Encryption Ensures Privacy........................................................................ 344 Tier-Based Design Increases Efficiency..................................................... 345 Good Application Architecture Prevents Technical Debt.............................

Words: 121491 - Pages: 486

Premium Essay

Freedom of Speech

...Freedom of Speech: The Burning of the American Flag DeAnna Parker March 24, 2015 Mark Wallace Sanford Brown College Online Over the years, there has been a question burning (no pun intended) in people’s minds. Is burning the American flag, freedom of speech? It’s not hurting anyone; it doesn’t put anyone in danger, unless you’re close to something flammable. Some say it is a symbol of our long fought for freedom, and whatever else this country was built upon. Others just think that it’s a peace of cloth, it that burning the flag is just symbolic. When the government, or law enforcement acts against the rights of the people that they are acting against what the people have fought for. Then there is the thought that the flag just represents mass genocide of innocents, so why not burn it. As of today flag burning is not illegal in the United States, and the Supreme Court of the US protected it under the First Amendment back in 1969. Nevertheless, anyone who burned the flag can be found guilty in court under a misdemeanor, for having started a fire without a permit. The right to protest just got thrown under the bus, despite the fact that flag burning is protected under the First Amendment. The case at the US Supreme Court was in 1907, the Halter v. Nebraska case, later on in 1968, in light protests against the Vietnam War, Congress passed a the Flag Desecration Law. (Danilina, 2015) People want to send out a message by burning the flag. Though it is extreme burning......

Words: 591 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Freedom of Press

...Allison Ash Mrs. Morris CWI March 26th Freedom Of Press Freedom of press is the right to publish newspapers, magazines, and other printed matter without governmental restriction and subject only to the laws of libel, obscenity, sedition, etc. Freedom of press is what helps us know what’s going on around the world. Freedom of press tells us also what is going on outside of our country and what is going on to places we have never been to, or heard about. Bolivia does not allow freedom of press because people’s opinions and thoughts don’t seem to be as valued as they should. The reporter’s rights could cause them to be in prison for up to five years. Not only are their rights taken away but their records to find a job and all that they must need to live. All because of an opinion and them expressing it to others. This world report talks mainly about the issue of Freedom of expression and how in October 2010 that all media that includes “endorsement or publishing or discriminatory ideas” reporters can be fined and their licenses can be taken away and that means that they are out of a job. If journalists “spread ideas based on racial superiority or hatred” they could face prison for about five years. In one instance in the Página Siete and El Diario newspapers there was a criminal complaint from the government that stated there was an anti-racism law against the Fides News Agency that objected the coverage of a speech by Morales about food shortages. What was......

Words: 1131 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Freedom or Liberty

...Freedom and Liberty Every day the federal government as well as state and local government pass laws to make us a safer society. As they make society safer they are slowly chewing away at our rights, liberties, and personal freedom. Where is the balance? A serf toiling away in a field had very little liberty. He couldn’t vote and didn’t have any true freedom of speech or assembly. But he did have freedom to think his own thoughts, and he was given by his creator the right to moral agency. Within his confined world, he had the freedom to make choices, either good or bad. We now have laws regulating everything. We are forced to wear seatbelts, to wear motorcycle helmets. Smokers can’t even smoke outside. Kids are expelled from school wearing t-shirts with colorful statements. The government wants to regulate abortion, child discipline, and free speech. If you spank your kids you can be charged with child abuse. We have gone from a foreign policy centered on defending our boundaries to one where we engage in foreign wars around the world in an aggressive attempt to maintain an empire. Because of the supposed threats to our country, we have authorized the government to spy on its own citizens. But freedom has a price. Our soldiers have gone to war and fought and died so that we can remain free. As we all know though, there is nothing in life that is derived from nothing of substance. So, the question exists what constitutes individual freedom when......

Words: 1145 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Freedom of Speech

...extent are restrictions on freedom of speech justified in Australia? While there are laws that restrict Freedom of Speech in Australia in order to protect fundamental rights and to limit discrimination which emerged from multiculturalism, the same laws can also clash with the liberty of the citizens and with the right of Freedom of Speech itself. Introduction To establish the boundaries between the defense of Freedom of Expression and of minorities has become a challenge for modern states. The consolidation of different groups (ethnocultural , sexual diversity , immigrants, religious) within the base community has generated the need to redefine and strengthen the defense of the human rights. As Will Kymlicka explains, cultural mix requires an inclusive process, which involves the establishment of a group of rights that recognizes and protects the minorities. Conversely, the ongoing struggle of the minorities has a major difficulty: the delicate border between the defense of their rights and the violation of the rights of the community. Firstly, this essay aims to explain the current conception of Freedom of Speech, since it is a controversial issue, focusing on the importance of that right for the Australian society and for the world. Secondly, we will analyze whether Freedom of Speech needs limits and the role of harm speech and offense speech in that topic in Australia. Finally, the third paragraph will focus on the restrictions of Freedom of Speech in......

Words: 886 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Struggle for Freedom

...Andrew Papis 1 May, 2012 Perspectives on the Individual Final Course Paper The Struggle for Freedom Human beings are emotional individuals. Their feelings direct them in one direction or the next, and brutally establish who they are, and what they do. It is the human environment that activates these emotions, and these emotions that in turn impact the human environment. They can be either positive or negative in nature, and are centered with government and society. When life is attained from a human being, their outlook on life becomes devious. Having a positive on life conceives comfort in many people’s lives. When an outside fury comes along and changes someone’s life, his or her attitude is going to change drastically. In three books I’ve read, “Night”, “The Handmaid’s Tale”, and “The Autobiography of Malcolm X”, each struggle with the society they are dealt with. To be more specific, each main character has to struggle for freedom in the society that is surrounding them. ...

Words: 2308 - Pages: 10