Free Essay

Book Critique

In: Religion Topics

Submitted By lrichard
Words 1195
Pages 5
How to Write a Book Critique

PURPOSE OF THE ASSIGNMENT: The idea behind this assignment is to give you the opportunity to read a detailed historical account on a particular subject and to analyze the book critically. The paper you will be writing should be a book critique, rather than a book report. In a book report, you simply summarize the book. In a book critique, you go much further - you analyze and evaluate the book.

WHAT A BOOK CRITIQUE SHOULD INCLUDE: There are many things you should do in a good book critique. How much attention you give to these different components of the critique may vary depending on the book you are analyzing.

1. Summarize the book. Yes, despite what I said above about the difference between a book report and a critique, you nonetheless need to do some summarizing in your critique. You need to describe what the book is about in enough detail that someone who hasn’t read the book has a clear idea of the topic the author is addressing, the parameters of the book, and how the book is organized. If you don’t give your reader some idea what the book is about, then you may lose your reader when you start analyzing the book. Note that a chapter-by-chapter summary of the book is not needed. A general summary of the main points will be sufficient.

2. Identify the author’s purpose. What does your author want to accomplish with this book? What audience is the book intended for? Your author may want to fill a gap in historical literature by examining a topic that other historians have neglected, or your author may have an interpretation of the chosen subject that differs substantially from previous books on the subject - your author is trying to accomplish something with the book; you need to figure out what it is!

3. Identify the author’s theme or themes. During the course of the book, the author will probably develop several themes. Does the author have an issue that he or she keeps raising? A point or idea that recurs throughout the book? These are the author’s themes - arguments that the author particularly wants to emphasize.

4. Identify the Thesis: The main point the author is trying to prove is the thesis of the book. You should always explain the author’s thesis.

5. Note where the author stands on controversial issues. Sometimes, the author will make this easy for you, by describing the various positions historians have taken on the topic, and then explaining his or her position on the issue. Professional reviews of books will often point out these controversial issues and will compare your author’s position to that of others who have written on the same topic.

6. Discuss your author’s sources. What types of secondary sources does your author use? Are some of the sources current? What languages are the sources written in? What types of primary sources does the author use? Are potentially biased sources treated with appropriate caution? Does your author neglect any important relevant sources (again, professional reviews will be useful here)? In cases where there may be conflicting views on an issue, does your author examine sources from all sides?

7. Find out relevant biographical information about your author. Is your author trained as an historian? What higher degrees does your author hold - from what schools and in what fields? What is your author’s area of specialization? Is your author associated with any “school” of history? Are there any aspects of your author’s professional or personal life that might affect his or her assumptions or conclusions? You need only discuss those aspects of your author’s life and career that are relevant to his or her performance as an historian - I don’t need to know the names of her four dogs or that his hobby is bungee sumo wrestling. Remember – give the source(s) where you find out information about your author.

7. Look up professional reviews of your book. The book reviews published in professional historical journals will be written by historians who specialize in the area the book addresses. Accordingly, the reviewers will know far more about the author’s topic than you, and they are more likely to recognize important new theories, logical flaws, factual errors, etc. It is important to know how a book has been received by other professionals whose specializations are relevant to the book’s subject. Remember to read a book review with the same critical attention that you used when reading the book itself - when a reviewer disagrees with the author of the book on an issue, it is entirely possible that the author is correct and the reviewer wrong. Note that looking up reviews on Amazon.com or a similar site is not particularly helpful since there is no editorial control over any of those reviews. Use the resources of the library’s reference room (like the online database JSTOR, Book Review Index and Book Review Digest) to track down professional reviews of your book. When looking through these indexes of reviews, do not just check the year your book was published – check a year or two after as well (scholarly journals tend to lag behind in their reviews).

8. Address any other issues that affect the book’s quality. There are various other issues that you may want to discuss, issues that will be more relevant in some cases than in others. How is the book organized? What do you think of the author’s writing style? Does the author include “scholarly paraphernalia” like an index, maps, glossaries, appendices, etc.? Should the author have included more maps, diagrams, or whatever? While these issues may be worth discussing in your critique, generally they should not absorb too much of your time. After all, once you have told me that you think the author’s writing style is confusing or colorless or whatever how much more can you say on the subject without repeating yourself?

FORMAT OF THE PAPER:
This type of paper often runs at least five typed, double-spaced pages unless the assignment requirements indicate otherwise. If your first draft comes out shorter than that, it’s a pretty good guess you’re not doing something you need to be doing! You can include a cover sheet if you want to, but it is not necessary.

At the top of the first page of your paper, give me a complete bibliographic citation for the book. Use either Turabian or The Chicago Manual of Style as a guide for the proper format for a citation. The reference room of the library has both. The Writing Center has a handout that shows you how to do Turabian citations. Kate L. Turabian’s Manual for Writers of Research Papers, Theses, and Dissertations is the official style guide and is relatively inexpensive. Since many History professors on campus use this style, it might be a good investment.

Make sure you proofread your paper carefully - bad grammar will count against you. Use your word processor’s spelling checker, look for sentence fragments, read the paper out loud to listen for awkward phrasing, have a friend read through it, etc., etc., etc.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Planting Churches Cross-Culturally: North America and Beyond Book Critique

...Liberty University Planting Churches Cross-Culturally: North America and Beyond A Book Critique Submitted to Dr. William Brown In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for The Course Evan 505 Liberty University Baptist Theological Seminary By Joshua Byun Lancaster, California Sunday, September 1, 2013 Hesselgrave, David J. Planting Churches Cross-Culturally: North America and Beyond. 2nd ed. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2000. Kindle ebook. pp. 6174. Introduction The importance of both the existence and the role of the church in the New Testament era are prevalent through the scriptures. As a result, numerous books and resources on church planting and church growth have become more available in recent years. David Hesselgrave through the book, Planting Churches Cross-Culturally: North America and Beyond, provides a combination of both biblical principles and a step-by-step approach to church planting in the modern era. From the beginning Hesselgrave states his thesis as he explains, “The primary mission of the church and, therefore, of the churches is to proclaim the gospel of Christ and gather believers into local churches where they can be built up in the faith and made effective in service; thus new congregations are to be planted throughout the world” (161). Hence, the author defines the core Christian mission as church planting then proceeds to explain the concept both biblically and practically through the example established...

Words: 1977 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Why Four Gospels? Book Critique

...BOOK CRITIQUE: WHY FOUR GOSPELS? Tiago Souza NBST 515 September 24, 2013 INTRODUCTION This work will analyze the book “Why Four Gospels” by David Alan Black. The main objective will be compare the Fourfold-Gospel Hypothesis opposed to the Markan Priority. In order to do that, this work will first analyze the historical background and reality context of the composition of each gospel. The author David Black has published over 100 scholarly articles and book reviews in such journals as Novum Testamentum, New Testament Studies, Bible Translator, Journal of Biblical Literature, and many others. He also serves as Professor of New Testament and Greek and the Dr. M. O. Owens Jr. Chair in New Testament Studies at Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary in Wake Forest, North Carolina. SUMMARY The book starts by bringing up a description of the development of the gospels, and a not very known basic historical fact is that the Gospels were written through a not so brief period of time. The “Gospel according to Mathew” was published in 42 AD, and there was a 20-25 years gap between its publication and the publication of “Luke’s Gospel” and “The gospel according to Mark”. And than, another huge gap between the publication of those and finally “The Gospel of John” being published in 96 AD, so there was a 54 years interval between the publication of the 4 Gospels, and that fact shows that sometimes God likes to act in a way that takes time, seems unusual to human eyes, but in...

Words: 3283 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Book Critique -- Paul, the Spirit, and the People of God

...GOD GORDON FEE, AUTHOR A BOOK SUMMARY AND INTERACTION SUBMITTED TO DR. DANIEL MITCHELL IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE COURSE THEO530, SYSTEMATIC THEOLOGY LIBERTY BAPTIST THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY BY EDDIE H FINCH – 22458150 LYNCHBURG, VA THEURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 19, 2013 1 In Paul, the Spirit, and the People of God, Gordon Fee outlines a theology of the Spirit in the Divine Trinity, the basis within Scripture for the experience of the Spirit, and the interaction of the two. Fee, a Pentecostal scholar, “redefines the terms of discussion about the Holy Spirit in a way that transcends today’s paradigm of ‘charismatic’ or ‘non-charismatic’ orientation.” Fee fills the gap between the neglect of the Spirit in traditional theologies and the seemingly excesses of the “Spirit movement.” He seeks to revitalize the people of God with a new Scriptural understanding of the Trinity, recognizing once again the role played by the Spirit in the teaching and living of the church communities under Paul’s ministry as well as Paul, himself. The author’s excellence in scholarship as well as his consistent exegesis as he considers each of the supporting Pauline texts concerning the Spirit allows the reader to feel that he is not being led through an academic exercise or a diverse display of opinions and prejudices, but through the New Testament itself in a plain and often frank discussion of truths. By the author’s intention, the book is exegetically thorough......

Words: 1650 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Share Jesus Without Fear Book Critique

...Book Critique of Share Jesus Without Fear by William Fay In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For The Course EVAN 525 Liberty Baptist Theological seminary Lynchburg, Virginia Sunday, November 17 , 2013 Biographical Entry Fay, William. Share Jesus Without Fear. Nashville, TN: B and H Publishing Group, 1999. Author Information The author, William Fay, before giving his heart to God was a gambler, ran a house of prostitution, and was involved in the mafia. After having everything that success could offer, Fay began to feel as if something were missing. Eventually, his establishments were raided and he was faced with the threat of jail time. Faced with the possibility of spending his life in jail and losing everything he had, he made the commitment to believe in Jesus. Fay is currently a Chaplain with the Federal Drug Enforcement Agency and a host of the radio show, “Let’s Go”. He evangelizes by sharing his testimony and loving people with simple, basic methods of sharing the gospel. Content Summary Fay begins his book by describing the state of evangelism in churches today. In the brief first two chapters, Fay explains that Christians can not fail if they will just share their faith. It is the sharing itself that is our success, not the expected outcome (Fay, 3). Fay describes the vast majority of Christians that are guilty of committing what he calls the sin of silence. He expresses the need for Christians to be excited......

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Advancement Book Critique

...The Advancement Book Critique Liberty University BOOK SUMMARY L. Russ Bush, a dean and professor at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. His book entitled, The Advancement (2003), is an apologetic approach to naturalism. He came up with the term “advancement” to explain philosophical revolution because it was portray newness to modernism. He felt like the name “modern” seem outdated and old-fashion. Modern tends to provoke an attitude of staleness, rather than revolving and advancing. Bush’s book (2003) is divided into eight chapters. It starts with Chapter 1, entitled “The Worldview of the Advancement”. This chapter discusses the fundamental of compare and contrast of modern view and earlier view of God, nature, history and mankind. The second chapter of Bush’s book, The Rise in the Advancement of Science, pays particular attention the development of modern science. The rise of uniformitarian thought in evolution. “The human body is related to nature, and it is similar in many respects to the body of animals” (34). This thought does not include that the Christian view that a human body is different than animals. We have a soul, whereas, animals do not. Sigmund Freud’s The Future of an Illusion, argued that religion base on wishful illusion, rather than reality. Bush’s third chapter (2003), The Advancement and the Theory of Knowledge, concentrate on how science effects and outcomes with the absence of God. The Bible promotes the idea...

Words: 705 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Book Critique

...Consequently the Pure Act creates existents not abstract essences. Becoming is simply part of the nature of created beings. There are no irreconcilable dichotomies within being. Eckhart, in his quest for unity and oneness would say that in being opposition has no permanence. "The second thing that acts as a hindrance for us is when anything has an opposition within itself. What is meant by opposition? Love and sorrow, white and black-these are in opposition to one another, and opposition has no permanency in being." [39] The celebration of that metaphysical mystery is at least part of our intellectual response to life. As Victor Frankl, the modern existential logotherapist observed "What is the meaning of life? I made this inversion in my first book Arztliche Seelsorge, when I contended that man is not he who poses the question, for it is life itself that poses it to him." [40] There is a unity and relationship between our individual life and Life itself.. Eckhart will fully digest Aquinas and continue to resonate more with Aquinas' metaphysical position as opposed to Siger's and the other Aristotelian Christians of the period. For Eckhart, it is the connection of being in God not from God and that is the source of joy. Ekchart radically states this when he says in one sermon "All creatures are a pure nothingness. I do not say that they are of little value or that they are something at all - they are a pure nothingness. Whatever has no being is nothing. All creatures lack......

Words: 8164 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

John Dickson Book Critique

...Liberty Theological Seminary John Dickson Book Critique Humilitas: A Lost Key to Life, Love, AND Leadership A paper Submitted to Dr. Donald Hicks In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Course Preventing Ministry Failure Lead 625 By Dwight Chavis February 22, 2014 Table of Contents Summary…………..……………..……………………………………………………page 1 Critique …………...…………………………………………………………………...page 2 Evaluation……………………………………………………………………………...page 4 Conclusion ………………………………………………………………………..........page 4 Bibliography ……………………………………………………………………….......page 5 SUMMARY Author John Dickson has written a book on a word that is often misunderstood and misused. In his book Humilitas: A Lost Key to Life, Love, AND Leadership, He takes a multi-dimensional look at the subject of humility. He is very aware that writing a book on this subject can give the appearance that he himself has been able to achieve the goal of being known as a humble person. However, the opposite is true, Dickson writes, “Humility stands alone among the virtues in that as soon as you think that you have, you probably don’t.” This statement shows that in no way he thinks that he has been able to achieve this lofty goal. Dickson means for this book to be a practical one and hopes to achieve his thesis statement in which he writes, “My thesis is simple: The most influential and inspiring people are often marked by humility.” With that in mind, he sets the reader on a chapter by chapter tour......

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Book Critique

...Book Critique Tuesdays with Morrie Tuesdays with Morrie is a book about a middle-aged sports writer who has a very busy life and the realizations he comes to as an old friend reminds him what is truly important. At the beginning of the book Mitch Albom is very focused on success and his career as a newspaper sports columnist. As the book progresses, the reader watches Mitch’s priorities change. One night while Mitch was watching television he saw Ted Kopel interviewing Morrie on Night Line. Morrie was Mitch’s favorite college professor. Morrie served as a mentor for Mitch and the two spent many hours together taking about life. Morrie was the type of professor that truly loved to teach. He and Mitch developed a strong friendship and after Mitch finished school they promised to stay in touch. As time passed, Mitch worried about his career and focused solely on being successful. He lost contact with Morrie and soon forgot about his promise to keep in touch. The night that Mitch saw Morrie on Night Line he was surprised to see his old college professor and remembered his failed promise to keep in touch. Morrie was now retired and was dying with amyotrphic lateral sclerosis (ALS or Lou Gehrig’s disease). Mitch decided to visit Morrie. Once Mitch made contact with his old friend and college professor he started to see Morrie once a week on Tuesdays. On Mitch’s Tuesday visits, he and Morrie began to work on “Morrie’s final project”. During......

Words: 1036 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Critique

...foundation for what is to be the focal point of his book, the argument and defense of the fact that Jesus Christ is the only Savior. Along with this Nash shines a light on the three views that are central to the debate. They are Christian exclusivism, pluralism, and inclusivism. This paper will focus on the difference between Christian exlusivism and pluralism. The bulk of the first chapter is spent focusing on Christian exclusivism. By way of evidences found in scripture and the stance of biblical authority Nash establishes its definition. He places such a strong emphasis on this view that the reader is put in a place of analyzing the other views against the view of Christian exclusivism, and does so in a way that it is understood the other views will more than likely come up short with regard to proving their case. Nash makes this clear with the statement, ““The major question I will seek to answer in the rest of this book is whether pluralists or inclusivists have produced arguments strong enough to justify the repudiation of exclusivism, which is the position of historic Christianity.” It is important to note that a key element when it comes to what is known as Christian exlusivism is its view of Theology. The book states, theology “has been replaced by personal encounter, religious feeling, trust, or obedience.” These thoughts are evident throughout Nash’s expressed views on pluralism through the first six chapters of his book. He doesn’t hide this as he......

Words: 2285 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Share Jesus Without Fear Book Critique

...A BOOK CRITIQUE OF SHARE JESUS WITHOUT FEAR Angela Douglas Submitted to Professor David Wheeler In partial fulfillment Of the requirements for the course EVAN 525 Contemporary Evangelism July 14, 2014 Liberty Theological Seminary Lynchburg, VA   A Book Critique of Share Jesus Without Fear Bibliographical Entry Fay, William and Shepherd, Linda E. Share Jesus Without Fear (Nashville, TN: B&H Publishing Group, 1999). Abstract Share Jesus Without Fear is a comprehension guide to boldly sharing the gospel of Jesus Christ, with practical guidelines and scriptures to aid the apologist in defending their hope in Christ. Additionally, a practical guide to personal preparation, planning, and professing Christ to the unsaved. First and foremost comprehending the evangelist is the vessel being used and the Holy Spirit will do the work. “God has called each of us to share our faith, in obedience. He has called each of us to evangelize.” As the body of Christ all have been silent and avoided the command to share Jesus with all we meet. Silence is a sin as it is disobedience to God. “We should be excited about sharing our faith. We are living in a time when biblical prophesies are being fulfilled right and left. Yet most of us remain silent.” Throughout this book, Fay presents practical and friendly questions to share in an effort to offer Christ and His redemptive love. The Share Jesus plan is implemented through......

Words: 1311 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

A Book Critique How Markets Fail – the Logic of Economic Calamities John Cassidy

...A Book Critique How Markets Fail – The Logic of Economic Calamities John Cassidy BMBA 9202NB Professor Salvatore F. Cordo February 16, 2011 Samir Hadzic Professor Salvatore F. Cordo BMBA 9202NB February 16, 2011 How Markets Fail: The Logic of Economic Calamities In 2009, John Cassidy, noted journalist at The New Yorker published the book, How Markets Fail: The Logic of Economic Calamities. In How Markets Fail, John Cassidy describes what he calls utopian economics and how the utopian thinking has led to economic crisis such as job losses, bank bailouts, and corporate greed. Cassidy attempts to convince that utopian economics does not capture the true behaviors of humanity collectively leading to unanticipated and adverse economic outcomes. He presents the history of economics and contrasts the idea of utopian economics with reality based economics. Reality based economics encompass people’s behaviors and thinking identifying irrational self-interests (Cassidy, 9). Cassidy then explains in detail how economic theory and practice influenced the “Great Crunch” (i.e. collapse in sub-prime mortgage lending during last decade). The timeliness of Cassidy’s publication of a book to address how markets fail is certainly ideal in light of the recent crash in sub-prime mortgages. The financial impact of this economic crisis continues to dictate the pace of the current economy. Not only is the topic stimulating to a graduate MBA student, but has value......

Words: 2844 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Book Critique

...Liberty University Why not Advancement: a critique of The Advancement by L. Ross Bush A paper submitted to Dr. Bruce Forrest in partial fulfillment of the requirements for Christian Apologetics APOL 500 Bobby Barnett 11/24/2013 Contents Section Page Introduction……………………………………………………………………………3 Summary……………………………………………………………………………….3 Critique…………………………………………………………………………………6 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………...10 Bibliography…………………………………………………………………………….11 Introduction The society of today has come a long way in many disciplines such as technology. While the human race basks in the advancements of these many disciplines, a real danger that once was an unthinkable travesty has become an unfortunate reality. The reality is that as society enjoys the advances in science and knowledge, these advances are not progress at all but a hollow attempt of a society that has willingly begun to extinguish the light of faith in order to live in darkness spiritually. This is the domain of The Advancement by L. Russ Bush. Bush coins the term “advancement” and defines this term as the age into which society has now begun to descend on the vehicle of postmodern thought. The danger that Bush presents as inherent in the change to advancement thinking is that regression both physically and spiritually is interpreted as progression within the previous modern and postmodern paradigm. Summary The Advancement by L. Russ Bush is a presentation. Bush presents the...

Words: 2478 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Book Critique

...LIBERTY UNIVERSITY BAPTIST THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY Book Critique Fee, Gordon D. and Douglas Stuart, How to Read the Bible for all it’s Worth, 4th ed. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2014. 304 pp. USD $18.99 Submitted to Dr. Roy Lucas in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the completion of NSBT 610-D03 Hermeneutics by David P. Velez March 12, 2015 Contents Introduction....……………………………………………………………………………………..1 Brief Summary…..………………………………………………………………………………...1 Critical Evaluation...………………………………………………………………………………2 Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………………...5 Bibliography………………………………………………………………………………………6 Introduction In the rise of the early Orthodox Church, the early church fathers were among the few privileged ones exposed to the Scriptures, thus, the Scriptures, not available for the common person to read, created a problem in understanding God’s written Word. But times have changed. Now that the believer has access to the Bible, the problem is not the lack of understanding, but the inability to obey the Word of God. According to Fee and Stuart: “In fact we are convinced that the single most serious problem people have with the Bible is not a lack of understanding but with the fact that they understand many things too well!... the problem is not understanding it, but obeying it.” Today there a more Bible translations than we can keep up with. While revising the third...

Words: 1614 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Book Critique

...DATING AND THE SINGLE PARENT: A Critique Shemika Peoples Liberty University COUN 603 Summary Basically this text serves as a guide to single parents who are thinking about dating. This book details the struggles and expectations single parents may face in the dating field. Deal places a huge focus on the single parent and the individual dating the single parent. Deal addresses every stage of the dating process in throughout the text. Although the text places a huge focus on dating and the single parent the author recognizes the challenges a single parents paramour may be facing during this transition. For a single parenting dating can be extremely nerve working and challenging at times as well. Making the decision to date as a single parent is a major decision. Single parents should take in account their readiness to their children before they start to date. The author also explains the vast difference between "coupleness" and "familyness" and that often blended families will fail because the two adults involved made a great couple, but with the kids involved they do not make a great family. This book helps you to look past the "coupleness" of your relationship and evaluate whether or not you and your love interest also have good "familyness" together with the children involved. Deal discusses the importance of patience. "Wise adults patiently let time be their friend as coupleness and familyness develop" (Deal, pg. 105). Deal encourages adults to make wide......

Words: 1743 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Critique

...titillate  and  amuse  citizens,  rather  than  inform  and  mobilize  them  for  reform.  The  constant  barrage  of  media  exposés  reinforces  the  “politics  of  permanent scandal,” where there is unending controversy and frenzy on the political stage but not  much  substantial  reform.  Instead,  scandals––just  like  elections––become  an  arena  for  political  struggle among elites, rather than a venue for mobilizing the public to push for change. 9 The danger,  as a Hungarian scholar writing about the Balkans put it, is that “when everyone cries wolf, the public  loses all interest in accusations of corruption and normalizes it. The very high level of government  corruption becomes a normal fact of life.” 10  More radical critiques of the media, on the other hand, say the opposite: that the media, far  from being hypercritical, actually rarely perform their watchdog role or question the existing social  order. Thus, they wonder whether the media’s purpose and organizing principle ought to be based  on what they do NOT do most of the time.11 The watchdog doctrine, after all, dates back to an era  when  the  “media”  consisted  largely  of  small‐circulation  and  largely  polemical  newsletters  and  the  state  was  dominated  by  a  landed  aristocracy.  The  argument  then  was  that  private  ownership  4  protected  the  press  against  state  intervention.  But  private  ownership  has  not  shielded  the  press  from  market  pressures, ......

Words: 11805 - Pages: 48