Premium Essay

Case 1.9

In: Business and Management

Submitted By tdtagt
Words 918
Pages 4
Knapp Case 1.9- ZZZZ Best Company, Inc. 1. A review consists of an auditor performing analytical procedures and inquiries to provide a reasonable basis for obtaining limited assurance. In a review, the auditor does not give an opinion on the financial statements. He/she merely looks over the statements for any material misstatements or modifications that need to be made. Contrarily, in terms of the level of assurance, during an audit an auditor obtains a high level of assurance, expresses an opinion on accuracy and level of assurance, and tests for misstatements and the client’s internal controls. 2. The occurrence assertion is very important, especially in this case, to ensure that the financial statements of a company faithfully represent actual transactions, assets, and liabilities of the company. There were certain limitations of the evidence gathered by the procedures performed in the ZZZZ Best case with regard to the assertion of occurrence: a. Confirmations- The information obtained through George Greenspan’s confirmation seems invaluable to me based on the fact that the confirmation was only sent to Tom Padgett, especially since Tom Padgett was paid by Minkow to confirm contracts. Even though there was no way for Mr. Greenspan to know that Mr. Padgett was being paid off, I believe that he should have found more valuable information through his confirmations by sending them out to more than one person involved in the company. b. Analytical Procedures- According to the case, the analytical procedures Mr. Greenspan performed included: comparing ZZZZ Best’s key financial ratios with industry norms and inspecting key documents pertaining to the jobs contracted. Assuming that these are the only two procedures performed prior to audit planning, I do not think that there were enough analytical procedures performed to identify potential problem…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Zzzz Case 1.9

...ZZZZ Best Company, Inc Case Solutions:   1.  A review is performed to obtain a reasonable basis for providing limited assurance that the client's financial statements have been prepared in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles. An independent audit is designed to provide a reasonable basis for expressing an opinion concerning whether or not a client’s financial statements have been prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles.  There is also a major difference between a review and an audit in terms of the scope of work performed. When a review is done, the main evidence collection techniques are analytical procedures and inquiries of client personnel. Whereas, in an audit, the full range of evidence collection techniques available to an auditor is likely to be used. A review does not assess control risk, tests of accounting records and responses to inquiries by obtaining validating evidence through inspection, observation or any other audit procedure. It can point out significant matters of the financial statements but does not provide assurance of their accuracy. Because reviews are generally not as rigorous as audits, considerably less evidence is typically collected in a review than in a comparable audit engagement. The issue with ZZZZ Best case is that the auditors review was not sufficient enough to review any material misstatements on the financial statements.   2.  Third party confirmations should give consistent......

Words: 303 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Case

...THE ON OT C OP YO CASE STUDY HANDBOOK RP OS T ON OP YO RP OT C OS T THE ON OT C Write Persuasively About Cases OP CASE STUDY HANDBOOK How to Read, Discuss, and William Ellet Harvard Business School Press Boston, Massachusetts YO RP OS T Copyright 2007 William Ellet All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America 11 10 09 08 07 5 4 3 2 1 No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form, or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise), without the prior permission of the publisher. Requests for permission should be directed to permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu, or mailed to Permissions, Harvard Business School Publishing, 60 Harvard Way, Boston, Massachusetts 02163. The copyright on each case in this book unless otherwise noted is held by the President and Fellows of Harvard College and they are published herein by express permission. Permission requests to use individual Harvard copyrighted cases should be directed to permissions@hbsp.harvard.edu, or mailed to the Permissions Editor, Harvard Business School Publishing, 60 Harvard Way, Boston, MA 02163. ON OT C Case material of the Harvard Graduate School of Business Administration is made possible by the cooperation of business firms and other organizations which may wish to remain anonymous by having names, quantities, and......

Words: 96750 - Pages: 387

Premium Essay

Case

...CHAPTER 14 THE LOGISTICS PLANNING PROCESS 3 The MILES module within the LOGWARE software is used to solve this problem. It computes distance based on the great circle distance formula using longitude and latitude. (a) The estimated road distance is 1,380 miles. (b) The estimated road distance is 830 miles. (c) Since both latitudes are in the same hemisphere, no adjustments need to be made. The estimated distance is 244 miles, or 244×1.61 = 393 km. (d) In this case, one point is east and the other west of the Greenwich line. Therefore, we need to set a sign convention. Let's set west longitudes as + and east longitudes as −. Thus, 2.20o E longitude is entered into MILES as −2.20 o. The estimated distance is 250 miles, or 250×1.61 = 402.5 km. 4 Suppose that a certain linear grid coordinate system has been overlaid on a map of the United States. The grid numbers are calibrated in miles, and there is a road circuity factor of 1.21. Find the expected road distances between the following pairs of points: Equation 14-1 in the text is used to approximate distances from linear coordinates. The K factor in the equation is set at 1.21. (a) Lansing, MI to Lubbock, TX Location a. From To b. From To c. From To d. From To X Coordinate Lansing, MI Lubbock, TX El Paso, TX Atlanta, GA Boston, MA Los Angeles, CA Seattle, WA Portland, OR Y Coordinate 924.3 1488.6 1696.3 624.9 374.7 2365.4 2668.8 2674.2 1675.2 2579.4 2769.3 2318.7 1326.6 2763.9 1900.8 2039.7 D = 121 (924.3 − 1,488.6 ) 2 + (1...

Words: 4663 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Case

...Schwab's b.i"ng .or. than 60olo lower' a high water mark' However,2000 p;;;tJto be mid-2-003' share prices in Between March zo6o *a with the technology heavy the United sr"tt' tt'*Uitd' peak losi'rlfsby" of its value from assist-co.rporattons on th.i, for.ign currency needs; help individuals plan with mergerc u'a "qoi'itio"'; financial *i-"""*t"t their financid f'totJ u'-'d trade 'securities; research to indiffi iroffi detailed make more institutions so that they can rarse and bonds; help governm'ents to busines^ses ["'a issuesr give advice NASDAQ index to trough. Tht uol'''# ii o"ti"t trading at Schwab "ra"Jftl"a informed investment decisions' Washington Reprinted bY Permtssron' W' L' Hill' University of This case was prepared by Charles Case 20 Charles Schwab in 2008 czss { 1 \,., lndustry Background l:_i.?"%,T:._-*,.,:-r::over 5.000 broker_dealers u"it.g s.,t",,;;;; ;,"- \ -"*t .rr"oi#i.; il:? ,,::. ffi Bi%'oii,. assets uommtssions 16.s Ii:f*:,1)ySE) of all.broter-a.ui.r, -u,iJ';;;":;i{: or the n,,.r, commi rradinsGain ioe iit ;] lT^t^o tr.g.rt NysE firms ,...,,'['o,[1 accoun,i,,g ro; rsii.-",l"^,::"'*yrSConcentratedwithsome 195 firms rhat are ;;g;T.'itl",5 ffilT Brokers, Line or S:.T:*::or Revenres,;rb- n"rr, .r. Percentase =r, r.,],li"r"aj '"j;,"!:;';l;ru"*:rrl;***HIffir, n^ industrv which is discussed in yorg a.,U follrrirg.Broker-dealers make ,fr." ,r_b., ways. They earn commirr-"; i;;'i..rr Ing a......

Words: 10065 - Pages: 41

Free Essay

Case

...organizational changes we have announced, BlackBerry has established a clear roadmap that will allow it to target a return to improved financial performance in the coming year,” Chen said in the earnings announcement. “While our Enterprise Services, Messaging and QNX Embedded businesses are already well-positioned to compete in their markets, the most immediate challenge for the Company is how to transition the Devices operations to a more profitable business model.” BlackBerry did increase the amount of its cash, cash equivalents, short-term and long-term investments from $2.6 billion at the end of the second quarter to $3.2 billion at the end of Q3. "During the third quarter, the Company recognized hardware revenue on approximately 1.9 million BlackBerry smartphones compared to approximately 3.7 million BlackBerry smartphones in the previous quarter," BlackBerry reported. "Most of the units recognized were BlackBerry 7 devices. During the quarter, approximately 4.3 million BlackBerry smartphones were sold through to end customers, which included shipments made and recognized prior to the third quarter and which reduced the Company’s inventory in channel. Of the BlackBerry smartphones sold through to end customers in the third quarter, approximately 3.2 million were BlackBerry 7 devices." BlackBerry will continue to reduce operating expenses in Q4, the company said. As for its partnership with Foxconn, the five-year agreement means that "Foxconn will jointly develop......

Words: 1675 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Zzzz Best Case 1.9

...evidence that these procedures provide with regard to the management assertion of occurrence. Even though the procedures were performed in accordance with GAAS, they are still subject to certain limitations outside of the auditor’s control. In this case, the evidence gathered was insufficient to support management’s assertion of the occurrence of the events and transactions. Obtaining third-party confirmations, reviewing paperwork and performing analytical procedures based on information given to the auditor by the company’s management was not reliable enough to prove that the contracts actually occurred. Tom Padgett made the confirmations and management provided the paperwork, yet all the sources were involved in the fraud. 3. In testimony before Congress, George Greenspan reported that one means he used to audit the insurance restoration contracts was to verify that his client actually received payment on those jobs. How can such apparently reliable evidence lead an auditor to an improper conclusion? It is possible for an auditor to come to an improper conclusion because documents, like invoices, could be easily falsified if management originally handles them or if the auditor receives them from management, like in the case of ZZZZ Best and Minkow. The auditor must always confirm payments directly with the third party. 4. What is the purpose of predecessors-successor auditor communications? Which party, the predecessor or successor auditor, has the responsibility for......

Words: 587 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Case

...Case study notes This case has been updated to include the Apple iPad. Principally this is case explores the issue of licensing and how successful firms can become unsuccessful. It is not a case about Apple and why it has become successful. This case study explores the rise of the Apple Corporation. The Apple iPod is one of the most successful new product launches in recent years, transforming the way the public listens to music, with huge ramifications for major record labels. More than 50 million MP3 players are expected to be sold in 2005; over a third more than last year. Mobile phones have long been regarded as the most credible challengers to MP3 players and iPods. The launch of digital download services via mobile phones illustrates the dramatic speed of convergence between the telecom and media industries, which many observers expect to usher in a new era of growth for mobile phones. Users are willing to pay more for additional services and many analysts predict that mobile phone handsets will eventually emerge as the dominant technology of the age, combining personal organisers, digital music players and games consoles in a single device. Indeed, Microsoft founder Bill Gates has predicted that mobile phones will supersede the iPod as the favoured way of listening to digital music. The launch of the Apple ipad in 2010 makes this case even more topical. This should form the basis of supplementary questions at the end of the case: How will the iPhone succeed? What......

Words: 16512 - Pages: 67

Free Essay

Case Study

...http://www.homeworkmarket.com/content/case-ajay-bam http://www.homeworkmarket.com/content/case-ajay-bam INSTRUCTIONS: For your Midterm paper, you will review the case of Ajay Bam. This case contains a manageable amount of material but presents the opportunity to consolidate the material covered to date in the course. Entrepreneurial Attributes: Consider Ajay’s background and experience. Create a comprehensive list of attributes that you think Ajay possesses. Which three are the most important; why do you think so? How did these attributes help him succeed? Business Plan Outline: The case includes an executive summary; using the model on page 258, create a brief 10-slide PowerPoint presentation about his new venture. Bootstrapping: Why did Ajay pursue the bootstrapping method of getting his company off the ground; please describe at least six examples of his efforts in terms of financing, services, and people. Opportunity and Market Assessment: How did Ajay and Walter find this opportunity? How big is the market, do consumers and merchants have a need for the product, what does Ajay have to do to answer these questions? (Instructor Note: Ajay needs to gather initial sector market data and customer feedback to gauge attractiveness.) Funding and Team: Would you invest? What does Ajay have to do to get funding sources interested? Paper Length: Four to five pages—PowerPoint—Max 10 slides including cover. CASE STUDY: With the quiet click of the......

Words: 5966 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Case Study

...Harvard Business School 9 - 2 9 5 -029 Rev. November 21, 1994 Educational material supplied by The Case Centre Copyright encoded A76HM-JUJ9K-PJMN9I Order reference F261237 In late 1990, executives, engineers, and financial advisors working for Amoco Corporation and Apache Corporation began serious discussions about the sale to Apache of MW Petroleum Corporation, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Amoco Production Company. Amoco had transferred to MW certain of its own assets that it regarded as non-strategic. MW's size, location, and operations were all very attractive to Apache, which had grown nearly 30% per year since the mid-1980s, largely through acquisitions. The transaction being discussed with Amoco would be Apache's largest to date. It would more than double the size of Apache's current operations, as well as its reserves of oil and natural gas. By the end of January 1991, Apache's executives and advisors were sufficiently familiar with the properties in MW to begin refining their estimates of operating and financial performance in order to structure a formal offer. Apache's chief financial officer, Mr. Wayne Murdy, knew that financing would be a challenge, given the size of the proposed transaction. In fact, the availability of external financing, bank debt in particular, was likely to impose some practical limits on both the amount and form of consideration that Apache could offer to Amoco. It was essential that Apache carefully evaluate MW,......

Words: 10178 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Case

...In August 2000, following a successful arbitration against Andersen Worldwide and Arthur Andersen, Andersen Consulting was granted its independence. Now the firm faced a new challenge. As part of the ruling granting its independence, the license to use the Andersen Consulting name was to expire December 31, 2000. After spending an estimated $7 billion2 building the Andersen Consulting brand over a decade, the company now had to find, implement and introduce to the world a new name in a matter of months. Never before had a rebranding of such scope been implemented over so short a timeframe. Moreover, this rebranding also coincided with a new positioning that reflected the organization’s further growth and broadened set of capabilities. The case study that follows tells the evolution of Andersen Consulting to the newly rebranded and repositioned Accenture. COMPANY HISTORY In 1913, at the age of 28, Northwestern University economics professor Arthur Andersen founded the accounting firm Arthur Andersen & Co. Arthur Andersen envisioned an accounting firm that offered more than the standard certifications of corporate balance sheets. In his mind, a “thoroughly trained accountant [possessed] a sound understanding of the principles of economics, of finance and of organization.”3 Arthur Andersen & Co. created an early version of the consulting unit when it formed the Administrative Accounting group in 1942. The Administrative Accounting practice was charged with developing accounting......

Words: 13556 - Pages: 55

Free Essay

Case 1.9 Zzzz Best Company

...Case 1.9 ZZZZ Best Company, Inc. 1. A review is similar to an audit but is less in scope and only provides limited assurance in regards to the presentation of the financial statement. This differs with an audit that gives reasonable assurance that no material errors or illegal acts are detected. The objective of an audit is to provide a reasonable basis for expressing an opinion regarding the financial statements taken as a whole. A review does not provide a basis for the expression of such an opinion because a review does not involve obtaining an understanding of the internal control structure or assess control risk, tests of accounting records and of responses to inquiries by obtaining corroborating evidential matter through inspection, observation or confirmation, and certain other procedures ordinarily performed during an audit. A review mostly involves inquires of client personnel and analytical procedures. In a review an accountant does not give an opinion as to the fair presentation of the financial statements, reasonable assurance. Instead the accountant states that no material modification came to his/her attention in order for the statements to be in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles, limited assurance. 2. As it relates to the assertion of occurrence and existence, third-party confirmations are usually highly reliable and auditors normally seek these out for a complete audit. While these forms of evidence can be reliable this......

Words: 1010 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Case 1.9

...Case 1.9 Question 1: Ernst & Whinney never issued an audit opinion on financial statements of ZZZZ Best but did issue a review report on the company’s quarterly statements for the three months ended July 31, 1986. How does a review differ from an audit, particularly in terms of the level of assurance implied by the auditor’s report? Answer: A review report does not assess the control risk of a company, which means Ernst & Whinney could have not gotten the proper risk that a material misstatement could occur within a relevant assertion. The report could have pointed out problems in the financial statements but it would not give the audit teams assurance of their accuracy. Ernst & Whinney never investigated ZZZZ Best’s internal control either, if they had done so they may have caught onto some of the fraudulent acts that were being committed. The main difference between an audit opinion and a review is an audit opinion provides assurance on the financial statements that they are accurate. Question 2: SAS No. 106, “Audit Evidence,” indentifies the principal “management assertions” that underlie a set of financial statements. The occurrence assertion was particularly critical for ZZZZ Best’s insurance restoration contracts. ZZZZ Best’s auditors obtained third-party confirmations to support contracts, reviewed available documentation, performed analytical procedures to evaluate the reasonableness of the revenues recorded on the contracts, and visited selected...

Words: 733 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Case Solutions

...CHAPTER 1 ACCOUNTING: INFORMATION FOR DECISION MAKING OVERVIEW OF BRIEF EXERCISES, EXERCISES AND CRITICAL THINKING CASES Brief Exercises B. Ex. 1.1 B. Ex. 1.2 B. Ex. 1.3 B. Ex. 1.4 B. Ex. 1.5 B. Ex. 1.6 B. Ex. 1.7 B. Ex. 1.8 B. Ex. 1.9 B. Ex. 1.10 Learning Objectives 1, 3, 5 2,5 3,4 5,6 1, 3, 5, 6 5, 6 2, 5, 6 7, 8 5, 7 1 Topic Users of accounting information Components of internal control Inexact or approximate measures Standards for the preparation of accounting information FASB conceptual framework PCAOB COSO Professional certifications in accounting AICPA code of professional conduct Personal benefits of accounting skills Skills Analysis Analysis Analysis, judgment Analysis Analysis Analysis, research Analysis, ethics Analysis Analysis, ethics Analysis Exercises 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 Topic You as a user of accounting information Real World: Boeing Company, California Public Employees Retirement System, China Airlines Users of accounting information What is financial reporting? Generally accepted accounting principles Accounting organizations Investment return Accounting terminology Accounting organizations Financial and management accounting Management accounting information Accounting organizations Purpose of an audit Audits of financial statements Ethics and professional judgment Careers in accounting Home Depot, Inc. general information Learning Objectives Skills 1 Analysis, judgment 3, 4 Analysis,......

Words: 7422 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Zzzz Best Case 1.9

...Auditing Concepts ZZZZ Best Company, Inc Case Solutions: 1. A review is performed to obtain a reasonable basis for providing limited assurance that the client's financial statements have been prepared in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles. An independent audit is designed to provide a reasonable basis for expressing an opinion concerning whether or not a client’s financial statements have been prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. There is also a major difference between a review and an audit in terms of the scope of work performed. When a review is done, the main evidence collection techniques are analytical procedures and inquiries of client personnel. Whereas, in an audit, the full range of evidence collection techniques available to an auditor is likely to be used. A review does not assess control risk, tests of accounting records and responses to inquiries by obtaining validating evidence through inspection, observation or any other audit procedure. It can point out significant matters of the financial statements but does not provide assurance of their accuracy. Because reviews are generally not as rigorous as audits, considerably less evidence is typically collected in a review than in a comparable audit engagement. The issue with ZZZZ Best case is that the auditors review was not sufficient enough to review any material misstatements on the financial statements. 2. Third party confirmations......

Words: 1265 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Case

...that there would be demand for more than 1,500 super 5 jumbos over the next 20 years that would generate sales in excess of $350 billion. Given the fact that Airbus had booked more than half of the orders for new passenger aircraft for the first time in 1999, capturing more than half the very large aircraft (VLA) market with the A3XX would constitute an enormous financial success and would position Airbus as the commercial aviation industry leader. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Dean’s Research Fellow Michael Kane and Professor Benjamin Esty, with assistance from Research Associate Fuaad A. Qureshi, prepared this case. HBS cases are developed solely as the basis for class discussion. Cases are not intended to serve as endorsements, sources of primary data, or illustrations of effective or ineffective management. Copyright © 2000 President and Fellows of Harvard College. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, call 1-800-545-7685, write Harvard Business School Publishing, Boston, MA 02163, or go to http://www.hbsp.harvard.edu. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, used in a spreadsheet, or transmitted in any form or by any means—electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise—without the permission of Harvard Business School. 201-028 Airbus A3XX: Developing the World's Largest Commercial Jet......

Words: 7609 - Pages: 31