Free Essay

'Dead' Climber's Survival Impugns Mount Everest Ethics

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By bravens99
Words 880
Pages 4
The differences in actions of the potential “rescuers” could be explained by the differences in the two scenarios. In the scenario where the British climber was left to die, there are several reasons why this could have happened. First of all, he was only 1,000 feet below the summit, so the climbers that stumbled upon his dying body could have been more likely to pass by since they were extremely close to their goal and did not want to give up at the very end. It was noted that dozens of different climbers or groups of climbers saw him there and could have helped. This, in my opinion, was a major factor. Since so many climbers saw him, no one felt too much responsibility because they figured someone else would rescue the climber. Sure none of the healthy climbers wanted him to die, but they figured someone else would do the actual rescue. This “diffusion of responsibility” made it easy for each passing climber or group of climbers to not feel ultimately responsible for the man’s death. If asked, each would say “well there were 38 other people that saw him, so don’t blame me. This idea was also displayed in the case of Kitty Genovese being stabbed to death in front of her apartment. Many people saw this attack, but no one called the police probably because they figured someone else already had done so. In the case of the Australian man, Lincoln Hall, he was rescued from a similar situation and managed to survive. Aside from his own team leaving him for dead, I feel the main reason he was rescued was because he was in an isolated area and was lucky to be spotted by one group of climbers, as opposed to dozens of climbers like the British man. This group of climbers that spotted him had no chance to view their responsibility any less than 100% since no other groups were around and would be anytime soon. The entire final responsibility of whether or not this man would live fell on their shoulders. In my opinion, it’s the “diffusion of responsibility” and the ability to “pass the buck” that factors in to whether or not a person steps up and helps out a stranger or not. I feel most people are have good intentions and would not want the responsibility of someone dying or being hurt to be on their conscience. So if it is impossible to diffuse responsibility or pass the buck to someone else, then it seems most people will step up and help a stranger in distress. It seems when there is a possibility of taking the responsibility of something horrible happening to someone off of one’s shoulders, unfortunately it does happen because it easier to spread the guilt over many people, or pass it off to others completely. The story about the Sadhu was a better display of humanity than the case with the British man because, even though there was diffusion of responsibility and passing the buck involved, each team did his part to bring the Sadhu down the mountain as opposed to just watching him die in the snow. Each team felt they did their part as they passed the Sadhu down the hill to another team. They felt that if he died, it was not their fault. Another factor that could have affected the decision of whether or not to help a stranger was if a group was making the decision or if just one or two individuals were making the decision. If a large group was involved, just a couple people in the group could sway the rest of the group to agree with their line of thinking, since it is natural for people to conform to the mainstream line of thinking. In some cases, those that would normally help a stranger in these situations are swayed into not doing so by the rest of the group. On the other side of the coin, there could be one or two “bad-apples” in the group who exert their influence over the rest of the group, using their position of authority for instance, thus forcing the rest of the group into a decision they would not make on their own. Finally, different behavior can simply be explained by one’s values and upbringing. For instance in the Sadhu case, Bowen McCoy formerly of Morgan Stanley, notes that his partner wanted to do everything to help save the Sadhu in compliance with the Christian doctrines of compassion and valuing human life above anything else. McCoy on the other hand had a more utilitarian response: “Do the greatest good for the greatest number.” Basically he means only give enough help to pass the Sadhu on to the next person, and then continue on as previously planned. Overall, humans want to help others and do the right thing, but more so in my opinion they want to do just enough to avoid being pegged wholly responsible for something unfortunate or deadly happening to another person. Thus the phenomenon of diffusion of responsibility and giving just enough effort to pass the buck to another person are what allow humans to continue on without guilty consciences after encountering an ethical dilemma like this.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Lessons of Everest Michael Roberto

...about leadership and decision making from the unfortunate events that took place on Mount Everest several years ago. Survivors have offered many competing explanations for this tragedy. While they have focused on the tactical blunders, this research examines the underlying cognitive, interpersonal, and systemic forces that played a role in the incident. This conceptual analysis suggests that cognitive biases, team beliefs about interpersonal risk taking, and system complexity interacted to create a fatal disaster. Incredible achievement and great tragedy unfolded on the treacherous slopes of Everest on May 10, 1996. TVventy-three people reached the summit along the South Col route in Nepal on that day, including Rob Hall and Scott Fischer, two of the world's most skilled and experienced high-altitude climbers. Unfortunately, Hall, Fischer, and three members of their expeditions died as a storm enveloped the mountain during their descent. Others barely escaped with their lives after many hours wandering in the dark while braving subzero temperatures. Hall, the leader of the Adventure Consultants expedition, had established an impressive track record of Everest ascents, guiding thirty-nine climbers to the summit over the previous six years. Fischer, the leader of the Mountain Madness team, also had an impressive reputation as a high-altitude climber, though he had only reached the Everest summit once. Each expedition included the team I am grateful to David......

Words: 10894 - Pages: 44

Free Essay

Mount Everest Case Analysis

...Moritz Straube, Mario Pacheco, Alex Rutherford, Haitham Al Najjar Prof. Bresciani P & G Case Study Mount Everest Humans often feel the need to conquer Earth and explore it to the fullest. Among the biggest challenges the planet has for humans, stands the quest to climb Mount Everest. At almost 9,000 meters above sea level, in between Nepal and Tibet, the quest to climb Mount Everest has become the point of no return for some climbers and the ultimate conquest for other climbers. Since May 29, 1953 up to December 1996, 846 persons had conquered successfully Mount Everest Climbing Mount Everest became available to the public through entrepreneurs who were visionary enough to apply their passion to their profits in the year of 1996.  Such is the case of Hall, founder of Adventure Consultants and Fischer, founder of Mountain Madness; each one of them had a passion for climbing and a vision for profit from leading teams to the top of Mount Everest, the summit. Together they both lead the largest commercial expeditions. Their experiences of their journey, which began in May 6, 1996, can be used to discuss different aspects of international organizational behavior. Leadership, communication, organizational structure, and visualization are key aspects of organizational behavior for businesses worldwide which are also related to the quest of conquering Mount Everestf. Hall and Fischer began as leaders of their organizations. Their climbing experiences are......

Words: 926 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Commercialization of Mount Everest

...popular way for amateur climbers to conquer Mount Everest. Commercial guiding expeditions have led to many deaths and have led to pollution of the mountain. In this essay I will discuss a brief history of Mount Everest, what commercial guiding is, how commercial guiding started and how it is affecting Mount Everest. Sources say that Nepal and China should limit the number of guide companies on Everest and make efforts to clean the mountain and its surrounding ecosystems. Mount Everest is the world’s highest mountain and the fifth tallest mountain from the base to the summit. The altitude of Mount Everest is 8,848 meters or 29,029 feet. Everest is located in the Himalaya Mountain Range, which is located in Nepal, China, India and Pakistan. The Himalayas is the tallest mountain range in the world. Most of its peaks exceed 7,200 meters or 23,600 feet. Mount Everest is located in the Mahalangur section of the Himalayas. The south side of the mountain is in Nepal and the north side is in China. The peaks that neighbor Everest are Lotse (the 4th highest mountain in the world), Nuptse and Changste. There are two main routes that commercial expeditions use to reach the summit of Everest. The first route is called the South Col which is located in Nepal. Some of the challenges that climbers face with this route are dealing with the Khumbu icefall and traffic jams on the Lotse face and on the day when climbers try to reach the summit of Everest. The other route that expeditions use to......

Words: 2445 - Pages: 10

Free Essay


...Activism is nexessary for survival of democracy freedom after a long struggle and formed a great constitution for making the country a welfare state bringing liberty, equality, fraternity with a view to make its citizens feel free and safe. It has to be ensured that the said values are not dying and the necessity of their healthy growth is being monitored for the survival of a free and vibrant society. Law and practice are different Our constitution clearly mentions that every citizen- regardless of gender, caste, creed- shall be equal before law and no discrimination shall be made on such grounds. But the daunting realities have contradictory stories to unfold. India – with its thousands of sub-castes stands divided on the basis of social divisions at every nook and corner. People, children, women are suppressed. MBA Essay topics: Need of Activism The need of social uprising arises here. These are the activists who raise a voice against the atrocities and let the world know about the same. They educate the people, garner their support and try to get the wrong doings rectified.  This is the fear of activists that corruption and corrupt practices are catching the attention of people at large.  The irregularities committed are being highlighted. Those who are under the watchful eye of activists – which can be media, social networking, NGOs etc. will think twice to go for any corrupt practices. Activism in fact is the activity that awakens the sleeping people about......

Words: 511 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Mount Everest Case Study

...decision. It is impossible to determine if they decided not to wait, would they have had the same outcome. They were purely basing their decision on experience. Overconfidence - The overconfidence bias was clearly illustrated as impeding Hall and Fischer’s judgement. Hall had successfully guided 39 clients to the summit of Everest (Roberto and Carioggia 2003). He believed he could “get almost anyone reasonably fit to the summit” and his record proved it. He felt very confident in his abilities stating “with so many incompetent people on the mountain, I think it’s pretty unlikely that we’ll get through this season without something bad happening up high,” inferring it wouldn’t be him. (Roberto and Carioggia 2003). Therefore, he knew that risk was involved in this years excursion. Hall built his business on his expertise, advertising “100% Success!”(Roberto and Carioggia 2003). “Successful managers (in this case a leader) gain power by building a reputation of “experts” in certain matters” (Kotter 1997). Given his achievements and visibility of his achievements, he gained power and Fischer noted this. “An associate described Fischer’s motivation for guiding Everest, ‘I think that he looked at Rob Hall’s success and thought...’If he can do it, I can do it’” (Roberto and Carioggia 2003). Fischer himself was confident in his abilities stating “Experience is overrated. It’s not the altitude that’s important, it’s your attitude..We’ve got the big E figured out. I believe 100%......

Words: 1341 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Mount Everest

...After understanding and analyzing the tragedy of Mount Everest , May 1996 that took lives of eight climbers during summit attempts, we can conclude that the tragedy may occur due to several root causes whether it is by nature or human error. The major factor that leads to this tragedy is that all the climbers are lack of team work and communication. Even though they are in the same expedition but they have their own individual’s goal, eager to reach at the summit. For example, Jon Krakauer one of the clients of Adventure Consultant said that he felt disconnected from the climbers around him, they were a team in name only. Supposedly, during the acclimatization exercises, the climbers should take time to get to know each other, learn their responsibilities as a team build their confidence and trust to their teammates, instead they were doubting each other whether they could rely own their team member during difficult times. That also might cause this tragedy, which is lack of trust towards team member. One of the potential causes of the tragedy was overconfidence. Overconfidence occurs when leaders believe that their experience, abilities, skill, or maybe even luck, will allow them to overcome any challenge they face. Research has shown that such overconfidence can lead to poor decision making as leaders substitute their own personal skill for careful analysis of the situation and planning. Hall, in particular, may have been prone to overconfidence. He had reached the summit...

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Everest Report Mgmt1001

...MGMT1001: Everest Report Andrew Lau A critical and reflective self-evaluation of my experiences during the Everest team simulation in the contexts of ‘attitudes, personalities & perceptions’, ‘power & conflict’ and ‘groups & teams’. Executive Summary The Everest simulation is a team simulation designed to emulate real life group processes and the diverse range of intergroup interactions this entails. Developed by Harvard Business School, participants are grouped into teams of 5 (with an optional sixth member, the observer) that make a virtual climb up Mount Everest. Performance is assessed through both individual and team goals that are provided throughout the simulation. Members were allocated into groups randomly within tutorial groups and assigned roles within the simulation. I was assigned the role of environmentalist, but assumed the informal role as one of the team’s leaders. Our group as a whole managed to achieve a satisfactory 67% of team goals, and I managed to achieve 57% of my individual goals. The objective of this report is to critically analyse and reflect upon the intergroup interactions that lead to the successes and failings of our team. These successes and failings will be viewed through the lens of the theories and concepts developed in the course in order to gain insight into group processes and human behaviour. The report starts with analysing and breaking down human cognitive processes and social interactions through the......

Words: 3899 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Mount Everest Case Study Review diverge oneself from obvious rational decisions to something which might fetch them something they want. In simpler words, it is putting wants above needs. Their stubbornness was evident since the beginning. They were being bossy and bragged about their skills and abilities. They didn’t take the obvious decisions which a rational person would have in those critical situations they rather cared about their reputation, fame and money. 1. Dictatorial Behavior- They made clear this to everyone that they will not take “NO” for an answer and what they say, should be followed by one and all. They pushed people even when they had no energy left, took hasty decisions and thought about themselves and materials. All they could see was the Mt. Everest fetching them money and fame. Their bossy behavior was a satisfaction to their ego. Hall while instructing the clients said, “My word will be absolute law, beyond appeal.” Instead of being bossy they should have been cooperative and should have coordinated with everyone present there as unity was the foremost requirement of the climb. But their personal bias made them settle for irrational decision (Armstrong, 2012). 2. Overconfidence – Hall had got signals that weather is not good and might be really harmful if they continue with the expedition but he ignored the indications and kept moving forward. He didn’t do the right judgment because of the former events that he had been in. His overconfidence made him bias and refrained from......

Words: 638 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mt Everest Simulation

...Mt. Everest Simulation- Personal Reflection Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction to Mount Everest team and Leadership simulation 2 2.0 Our Team Process Efficacy 3 2.1 The role of the leader 3 2.2 Psychological Safety 5 2.3 Group Thinking 7 3.0 Conclusions 8 4.0 Reference 9 1.0 Introduction to Mount Everest team and Leadership simulation Climbing Mount Everest is a dangerous undertaking, a Herculean task fraught with difficulties, danger, complexities and volatile weather conditions. Disaster can strike without warning, leaving the most competent and experienced professional high altitude mountain climber gasping for breath, and desperately fighting to stay alive. Death is not uncommon to mountaineers who ascend Mt. Everest, a simple mistake, faulty judgments, miscommunication, wrong decisions or complacency can lead to disastrous consequences. Indeed, climbing Mt. Everest cannot be accomplished alone, individuals need to work together as a team, cooperate and collaborate with one another, and rely on one another's capabilities to ascend the mountain summit successfully. Everest leadership and team multimedia simulation is an attempt to help the participants experience and understand team dynamics and leadership. It requires participants to work as a unit, a cohesive entity, collaborating and communicating essential information in order to make effective decisions that will benefit individuals and the group in achieving their goals. The......

Words: 3700 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Survival and Sacrifice

...However, war doesn’t only tell that story, but rather looks at the survival and sacrifices that soldiers must face in order to survive – and uncovers the true reality of war. This can be seen in selected stories from Tim O’Brien’s novel the things they carried and Wilfred Owen’s WWI poem Dulce Est decorum. Through the individual stories the man I killed and the things they carried, we are able to explore how the author struggles to deal with the effects of war, surviving through the guilt and heartache of expected murder and sacrificing individual dreams in order to keep his team safe. Similarly, Owen’s poem explores how individuals have to survive through the ghastly environments associated with war at the cost of individual lives. Both texts reveal how men at war are forced to sacrifice their hopes and dreams in order to survive the demands of war. In Tim O’Brien’s novel, the things they carried, the composer gives us an insight into the mindset and the emotional depth of soldiers in war, and the difficult sacrifices needed to make in order to survive. The theme of sacrifice is most evident in the chapter the things they carried, as the main character Jimmy Cross faces a moral dilemma; to either sacrifice his dreams, or to sacrifice the safety of his team, after the death of Ted Lavender in which he felt responsible for. The quote “He had loved Martha more than his men, and as a consequence Lavender was now dead”, displays the intentions of Cross before Lavender’s death,......

Words: 1924 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Mount Everest Case

...[pic] Executive Summary: The Mount Everest case can be summed up as inefficient distribution of leadership, skills and resources in the face of imminent natural disaster. Teamwork consist of interdependency, mutual accountability and understanding common goals and working with respect to each other’s complementary skills. Effective team’s consist of understanding perceptions of others and help motivate each other to continually work towards the common goal. Working towards a goal in a team usually does not run a straight course. In order to offset these issues that can come into play one may need to optimistically receive suggestions, abstain from narrow perceptions and outlook and trust on the team. Trust helps to create path for communication, collaboration, competence, commitment and ideas. Problem Statement: The goal was to reach the summit of Mount Everest and return safely. However the teams were unable to accomplish the task and this failure eventually led to human casualties. Causes: In the case Mount Everest -1996, Roberto and Cardioggia, factors that contributed to failure would include 1. Ineffective leadership (overconfidence, ego, and personality issues) 2. Lack of planning, 3. Poor communication 4. Poor teamwork. Precisely in this case, one of the main cause of catastrophe was that both Mountain Madness and Adventure Consultants proved to be a group but not a team. The members of the team did not......

Words: 1432 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Mount Everest Simulation

... According to Kreitner and Kinicki, a group is defined as “two or more freely interacting individuals who share collective norms and goals and have a common identity” (Kreitner & Kinicki, 2013, p. 269). A team is defined as “a small number of people with complementary skills who are committed to a common purpose, performance goals, and approach for which they hold themselves mutually accountable” (Kreitner & Kinicki, 2013, p.300). The team exercise was a simulated climb of Mt. Everest, with each member having a unique role during the simulation. According to Psychologist Bruce Tuckman, there are five stages in group development including forming, storming, norming, performing, and a later added adjourning (Kreitner & Kinicki, 2013). Not only was the Harvard Publishing Leadership and Team Simulation: Everest V2  a simulation in climbing Mt Everest, it was a lesson in executing a group challenge. The formation of the team began with the team assignments from the professor. There was some confusion as to who was on what team but after a few days; one after the other was present for the forming processes. It took a few days for everyone to collaborate and get their schedules all to work out to complete this task. Communication between team members was initially challenging trying to figure out the best method of communication between group members. Some members communicated more than others in the discussion board. A slower method of communication was......

Words: 1966 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Mount Everest

...1 1 Mount Everest-1996 2 2 Executive Summary Background The case study describes a team ascending Mount Everest led by Scott Fischer and Rob Hall. The primary concept behind the case study is to distinguish qualities in the team’s plan, action, and most importantly leadership. The clients and the leaders in the report show lack of readiness to ascend the mountain. Fischer along with Hall led many people to their deaths because of bad leadership skills. The report outlines how the two leaders failed to communicate with their team. The expedition team needed a better action plan with clear and concise steps to follow in order to keep everyone alive. The breakdown and analysis of the case is reported here. Results Scott Fischer and Rob Hall were not prepared to be leaders. Their skills were lacking and they were only doing things for themselves. Fischer and Hall were clearly acting in the pre-conventional stage of development. They did not value any objections to ideas or procedures. The two leaders acted in a high power distance setting, neither were comfortable allowing inexperienced individuals have a voice. They failed to keep in mind they were running a business. Their actions were the primary reason many climbers lost their lives. The report outlines the communication errors and expresses potential solutions that could have saved lives. Conclusion Communication is a primary factor in the business environment. Leaders need to communicate their......

Words: 1615 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Everest Sim

...EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Everest group simulation was an exercise which encouraged five students to play a unique and vital role on a team of hikers, attempting to reach the summit of Mount Everest. The simulation powerfully encapsulated the concepts and theories learnt in this course, illustrating the power of groups. The purpose of this report is to reflect on the experiences encountered during the Everest team experience and identify how these experiences related to the course. It comprises of a description and analysis of the Everest Team experience, a critical analysis of the team’s performance and results and a critical analysis of the team’s communication interactions. Upon taking part in both the simulations, it was discovered that the team score was dramatically improved, from 46% to 83%. This improvement was attributed to the team’s enhanced performance, due to progressing through the team development stages, as our performance was superior in the ‘norming’ and ‘performing’ stages rather than the ‘forming’ and ‘storming’ stages. Another factor which enhanced the team’s performance and thus, team score was the alterations in group structure. By assigning roles to each team member, a defined structure was associated with a distinct change in direction. In addition, changing from directive decision-making to analytic as well as collaborating instead of forcing and accommodating to resolve conflict revealed improved team dynamics leading to an overall better result.......

Words: 3665 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Mount Fuji

... Employers, job seekers, and puzzle lovers everywhere delight in William Poundstone's HOW WOULD YOU MOVE MOUNT FUJI? "Combines how-to with be-smart for an audience of job seekers, interviewers, Wired-style cognitive science hobbyists, and the onlooking curious. . . . How Would You Move Mount Fuji? gallops down entertaining sidepaths about the history of intelligence testing, the origins of Silicon Valley, and the brain-jockey heroics of Microsoft culture." — Michael Erard, Austin Chronicle "A charming Trojan Horse of a book While this slim book is ostensibly a guide to cracking the cult of the puzzle in Microsoft's hiring practices, Poundstone manages to sneak in a wealth of material on the crucial issue of how to hire in today's knowledge-based economy. How Would You Move Mount Fuji? delivers on the promise of revealing the tricks to Microsoft's notorious hiring challenges. But, more important, Poundstone, an accomplished science journalist, shows how puzzles can — and cannot — identify the potential stars of a competitive company.... Poundstone gives smart advice to candidates on how to 'pass' the puzzle game.... Of course, let's not forget the real fun of the book: the puzzles themselves." — Tom Ehrenfeld, Boston Globe "A dead-serious book about recruiting practices and abstract reasoning — presented as a puzzle game.... Very, very valuable to some job applicants — the concepts being more important than the answers. It would have usefulness as well to interviewers......

Words: 78201 - Pages: 313