Diagnosing Stigma Labels

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By laurenrohe
Words 1218
Pages 5
Lauren Rohe
October 22, 2010
Author: Ruscio, John
Article: “Diagnosis and Behaviors They Denote”
Stigmatization is a big issue then psychology profession faces every day. The theory of labeling can cause an effect on the individual and the society together. The author of this article, John Ruscio is a psychologist who examined a few cases to show how labeling is a challenge for others. Do the mentally ill suffer from social rejection from stigmatization? These case studies give a few examples on the few from both perspectives. He makes good points from his examples, and then in the end shows his perceptions and his advice on how to change this social problem.
Pseudo patients and Pseudoscience
There were eight mentally stable patients that pretended to act insane and fake their symptoms to be checked into a mental hospital. After diagnosed with schizophrenia, the patients stopped faking their symptoms. When the hospital staff could see the patients “sanity”, they were discharged after a 19 day stay from the mental hospital. The observations from inside of the hospital showed that the labels from the psychologist will remain with the patient for the rest of their life. The “insane are not always insane”, and occasional behavior, will still receive a label of illness in mental hospitals.
Patients, Job Applications, and Psychological Disturbance
A group of psychologists were asked to watch a muted video tape of an interview occurring. One group was told that the interviewee was a mental illness patient, as the other group was told that the interviewee was a job applicant. When the interview was done, the group with the patient had much more negative responses, then the group with the job applicant. With the beginning label information being told to the psychologists it gave them a bigger window to judge the interview from their…...

Similar Documents


...It is important that we look at a broader aspect of how the stigmas affect us as a whole when we are considering the effects of our education and team effort in combating suicide. Now we can focus on the aspects of what are indicators for suicide and how to intentionally seek out the behaviors associated with it but we need to broaden and encompass a variety of stigmas associated with the work force that in face discourage seeking help and put a strain on an already decayed system. We have made headway in deterring many different ill effects of such things as poor choices in ASAP program measures and in our programs widely for domestic violence. In the historic nature of suicide we focus entirely on the pony at hand with out encompassing a variety of stigmas associated with the causation and effects that bring someone to even erupt with an already pre notioned idea. Best put a permanent solution for a temporary problem. If we fail to recognize these stigmas and their effects as well we turn our heads from the underlying things as leaders we can do to bring it around. I am not saying coddle the Soldier I am saying with education there must be presented realistic goals and options to the stigmas we have created. Physical Birth Profile Recovery A person told that the promise of their getting out of the military on information that is a stigma and is not based on the validity of fact causes the continued degrading of trust and confidence that the Soldier......

Words: 273 - Pages: 2

The Stigma of Mental Illness and Its Effects

...The Stigma of Mental Illness and its Effects It appears that negative views of mental illness are common with in the public. According to Overton & Medina people suffering from mental illness are often portrayed as weird, defensive, and sometimes hard to talk to. According to Merriam-Webster Dictionary (1990), mental illness is defined as, “mentally distorted, mad, or crazy” (Russel, 1990). Generally, concepts about mental illness tend to be subjective, leading to difficulties in defining mental illness. Johnstone (2001) gives a broader definition of mental illness, believing that mental illness relates to the individuals spectrum of cognitions, emotions, and behaviors that damper relationships required for work, home, and in the learning facilities (Johnstone, 2001). This definition is also referenced in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th ed; DSM-IV; American Psychiatric Association, 1994), which categorizes the symptoms that are used to diagnose mental illness (American Psychiatric Association, 1994). Stigmatizing individuals with mental illness are causing these individuals to suffer loss of employment, housing, and stereotyping, and prejudice. There have been many different thoughts this is not research on the topic of stigma due to mental illness. This study discusses the true definitions of stigma, causes, effects, impact of the programs all ready in place, and what can be done to change the perception of the general public .......

Words: 2549 - Pages: 11


...Nathan Letourneau 25 Jan, 2013 MWF 2:00pm Abnormal Psychology Reflection Paper #1: Stigma Isaac Newton, Abraham Lincoln, Beethoven, these are all extraordinary men that played a major role in history, but what most people don’t seem to know about many of these men, is that they all lived with a mental illness. These men that people would call “Abnormal” for their mental illness today, all set an example and showed that people with mental illnesses can accomplish just as much and even more than let’s say “normal” people. Yet there is still a stigma today were people think that people with mental illnesses are weak minded or even dangerous. The fact of the matter is, that people living with a mental illness are no more violent then someone without one, and are often the victims of a crime. There have been so many people in the world that have done so many great things and have even learned to control their illness. Someone close to me in my life battled bulimia for over a year, and I shared the same house as them yet still had no idea, that she had this mental illness! We started noticing how thin she was getting, but didn’t really think very much of it until one day we found out what she was doing. I didn’t know what to think and I would never have guessed that I was living with someone with this problem. We tried for months and worked together to help her get through it but she always seemed to go back to doing it, when we thought she was fine again. It......

Words: 597 - Pages: 3


...stigma and mental illness It appears that negative views of mental illness are common with in the public. According to Overton & Medina people suffering from mental illness are often portrayed as weird, defensive, and sometimes hard to talk to. According to Merriam-Webster Dictionary (1990), mental illness is defined as, “mentally distorted, mad, or crazy” (Russel, 1990). Generally, concepts about mental illness tend to be subjective, leading to difficulties in defining mental illness. Johnstone (2001) gives a broader definition of mental illness, believing that mental illness relates to the individuals spectrum of cognitions, emotions, and behaviours that damper relationships required for work, home, and in the learning facilities (Johnstone, 2001). This definition is also referenced in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders which categorizes the symptoms that are used to diagnose mental illness. 8 out of 10 people in Australia who experiences mental disorder will more like will experience stigma, stigma is a the behaviour of people toward people with mental disorders, stigma has been seen on many people, Stigma refers to negative, unfavorable attitudes and the behavior they produce. There are many people who experience mental disorders and when they newly get depression they don't go and ask for professional treatment because they don't want to be labeled and they don't want people calling them names, that is why a lot of people who get......

Words: 1045 - Pages: 5

Hrm-587 Diagnosing the Change

...Disney: Diagnosing the Change HRM-587 Managing Organizational Change August 3rd, 2014 Introduction: Choosing a Diagnostic Model The diagnostic model I have chosen to discuss to analyze Disney and several of the companies acquired throughout the years such as Pixar, Marvel, and LucasFilm’s LTD for this assignment is the 7-S Framework model. I will also briefly discuss the many changes that Disney has implemented to improve the customer viewing as well as interactive experiences at their many new, current theme parks, and vacation destinations throughout the world. The 7-S model developed by McKinsey and Company consultants Robert Waterman Jr., Tom Peters, and Julien Phillips (Palmer, Dunford, Akin, 2009). The 7-S model may be used in a variety of situations where an alignment perspective is useful, for example, to help 1) improve the performance of the company, 2) examine the likely effects of future changes within a company, 3) align departments and processes during a merger or acquisition, 4) determine how best to implement a proposed strategy (Manktelow, J. 2014). The 7-S model is characterized by seven categories: Structure, strategy, systems, style, staff, skills, and superordinate goals (Palmer et al., 2009). The structure of the company was set and solidified by Walt Disney himself. He wanted to create something brilliant and diversified. This idea would be able to change through the years and remain a competitive force in the industry. Throughout Walt......

Words: 2029 - Pages: 9

Social Stigmas

...Social Stigmas Andre Dunham Strayer University What are Stigmas? Stigma is defined as: 1. a mark of disgrace or infamy; a stain or reproach, as on one’s reputation (www.dictionary.com). I’ve chosen the Article Social Stigmas by Heidi Goar to help understand what Social Stagmas are and, how to identify the different types of Social Stigmas that are out there. The information obtained in the Article for the most part is a review of existing research. The author used studies from other Scientist such as Erving Goffman (1922-1982) and Emile Durkhein to support her claims. What I’ve learned about Social Stigmas is that you don’t want to be placed in one. Once you are placed in one, the stigmatized person could be labeled as inferior and could suffer a loss in status in the community. One could have a stigma placed on them because of something they have done, such as the criminally deviant. Stigmas can also be placed on someone who has certain health conditions, such as Leprosy or AIDS. I also learned from Erving Goffmans’ Stigma: Notes on the Management of a Spoiled Identity that there are two types of stigmatized members: discreditable and discredited. A discreditable person has yet to be found out. A discredited person has either already revealed his/her position, been exposed, or cannot conceal the stigma. Goffman also says that there are Six Dimensions of Stigma that match the discreditable and discredited stigma. They are listed below: 1. Concealable...

Words: 481 - Pages: 2

Phyical Stigmas

...Baker University 9/15/14 Stigma: a mental or physical mark that is characteristic of a defect or disease (www.dictary.com). Or a mark or mental issue that sets you apart from others in society. No stigma is a fun thing to deal with but I believe that visible stigmas are a better thing to have, because some of them heal, and if even a certain visible stigma doesn’t heal people have already judged you when they see you so you have nothing to hide. And nonvisible stigmas can cause people to not participate in class, be afraid to try to make friends, and try so hard to hide it they may not even be acting like their true selves. There are two different types of stigmas. There is a visible stigma, which is mark, scare, or maybe even a deformity on the exterior of your body. Some visible stigmas heal, like smaller scares, red marks, and some cuts. So it may be embarrassing at the time but in time it will up, and you won’t have to deal with it anymore. Other things like deformities or any in normality can sometimes be covered up. But even if they can’t be covered up then people already see them so you may be embarrassed people have already judged you, so you can at least wear it with attitude. Then there are nonvisible stigmas. These are the stigmas that aren’t visible, such as ADD, dyslexia, autism, multi-personality disorder, and other learning disabilities or mental health issues. Yeah people may not be able to tell that you have a stigma when you’re walking down......

Words: 842 - Pages: 4

Diagnosing Change

...Diagnosing the Change Dr. Jay Galbraith is an established expert and consultant in organizational design. What is interesting is that Galbraith identifies Information Technology as having an integral role in what shapes an organization, as well its design. In equating how Blockbuster and Netflix each chose to respond to the emerging presence of the Internet, the relevant factors Galbraith associated with I.T. here are: Buyer Power – buyers are becoming more aware and demanding Variety/Solutions – buyers aware that they are in control want more options/better solutions Speed – buyers expect this variety of options/solutions as quickly as possible Change – the business landscape is rapidly evolving, as are the demand for variety/solutions, as well as an increase in the pressure to bring them faster These factors once realized, can be used in conjunction with Galbraith’s Star model to evaluate an organization, provide a structure for organizational form, this from which a company can align its design. According to Galbraith Management Consultants, the Star Model framework “…consists of a series of design policies that are controllable by management and can influence employee behavior.” The basic premise of the Star Model is that there are five points, each being an organizational design category. These groupings are Strategy, Structure, Processes, Rewards, and People. Following the design of the star, all five classifications must be......

Words: 1554 - Pages: 7

Diagnosing the Change

...Diagnosing the Change Natalie Howard DeVry University HRM/587 Jay Egger June 1, 2014 Diagnosing the Change This paper will discuss the use of a diagnostic model identifying the performance aspects of the two organizations that I chose. Chevron/Texaco and Coca-Cola are the two companies that I will be looking into to get an understanding of some critical cultural issues and to see what strategies were being used to correct the companies’ complaints about racial discrimination. Nadler Congruence Model I chose to use the Nadler congruence model to identify cultural problems within both organizations’ environment. Nadler uses a model that is based on the principle that an organization’s performance is derived from tasks, culture, structure, and people. It’s a systematic way to use the root elements to drive a force to an organization’s performance. In the case of Chevron/Texaco and Coca-Cola, we will be looking at managerial and the social aspects of both organizations (Nadler’s Congruence Model, 2013). It’s a useful model because it provides an effective checklist to those who are involved in creating change in the workplace. I consider it to be more of a problem-focused model to troubleshoot any problems that could cause an organization’s vision not to be achieved. Chevron/Texaco The problem identified with Chevron/Texaco is racial comments being made toward African Americans and complaints of being paid low wages and not being considered for......

Words: 650 - Pages: 3

Diagnosing Change

...Diagnosing Change Student’s Name Institutional Affiliation Congruence Diagnostic Model The important thing that was not initially is that Sony and Microsoft were not performing as they would have expected. It was realized that something should have been done and that certain changes needed to be implemented through the reorganization of the corporate structure. It is a question that would disturb many as why some firm would thrive on a certain corporate structure while others struggle on the same structure (Burke, 2009). It is important that we understand the forces or drivers that dictate performance and what relationship exists between the forces. This can only be done through the help of the congruence model. It determines what is happening the wrong way and then looking at means of fixing them (Burke, 2009). The model is based on the fact that in order for the organization to perform, there are four important elements which are; people, culture, work and structure. The performance of the organization will improve only the above factors are showing congruence. It is understandable that one may have the best team of people working for the organization but once the culture, the structure and the type of work is wrong, then the firm will still struggle. The companies, Sony and Microsoft had the best of technology, and the best team of experts, but they still could not perform as it had been......

Words: 917 - Pages: 4


...What is stigma? Three out of four people with a mental illness report that they have experienced stigma. Stigma is a mark of disgrace that sets a person apart. When a person is labelled by their illness they are seen as part of astereotyped group. Negative attitudes create prejudice which leads to negative actions and discrimination. Stigma brings experiences and feelings of: * shame * blame * hopelessness * distress * misrepresentation in the media * reluctance to seek and/or accept necessary help Families are also affected by stigma, leading to a lack of support. For mental health professionals, stigma means that they themselves are seen as abnormal, corrupt or evil, and psychiatric treatments are often viewed with suspicion and horror. A 2006 Australian study found that * nearly 1 in 4 of people felt depression was a sign of personal weakness and would not employ a person with depression * around a third would not vote for a politician with depression * 42% thought people with depression were unpredictable * one in 5 said that if they had depression they would not tell anyone * nearly 2 in 3 people surveyed thought people with schizophrenia were unpredictable and a quarter felt that they were dangerous Some groups are subjected to multiple types of stigma and discrimination at the same time, such as people with an intellectual disability or those from a cultural or ethnic minority. How can we challenge stigma? We all have......

Words: 636 - Pages: 3

About the Stigma

...About the Stigma In essence, stigma is a kind of negative label on some individuals or groups, which has a serious impact on them that stigmatized people always suffered unfair treatment and were marked as unworthy. As is known to us, stigma is always connected with the lower social situation, poverty, disability, homosexuality and some other situation, and it jumps into professionals’ sigh since last decade, which means stigma has been considered as a serious social problem finally, and there is an upward tendency of people pay more attention on it. What is stigma? “The term stigma comes from ancient Greece, where it meant a ‘bodily sign designed to expose something unusual and bad about the moral status of [an individual].’” (Rosenblum & Travis, Framwork , 2012)This is the origin of stigma, and it is like an old penalty in ancient China that criminals were forced to be painted a tattoo on their face before they were exiled. It seems that ancient people were using similar ways to distinguish and mark people who were “bad”. And then, Goffman brought the word stigma into sociology to define the situation that some people are judged and classified into a group as unworthy because of their disability, race, sex, sexual orientation or some other social categories else. The first step of stigma is to classify the so-called unusual people to another group and naming them to show the difference, such as “gay”, “lesbian”, “black” and so on. And then, stigmatized people or group is......

Words: 1734 - Pages: 7

Diagnosing Change

...Diagnosing the Change: A Study of Procter & Gamble and Johnson & Johnson Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG) and Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ) are both iconic, legacy American businesses that are customer-centric and manufacture consumer household products. Today, both are lead by two exemplary strategic-thinkers, A.G. Lafley, CEO of PG and Alex Gorsky, CEO of JNJ. This paper examines the history of each company and which change images each CEO applies to implement change in their business and practices through applicable examples. Company History Procter & Gamble. In 1837, William Procter and brother-in-law, James Gamble found Procter & Gamble in Cincinnati, OH to provide consumer household products, particularly soap and candles (Procter & Gamble, 2014). PG quickly grew by leveraging its operating environment to drive innovation and design in regard to consumer products. Today, 177 years later, PG is the world’s largest multinational consumer goods company, located in more than 70 countries with over 180 product brands (Procter & Gamble, 2014). Due to its expansive portfolio of products PG is divided up into the following sectors: Baby, Feminine and Family Care, Beauty, Fabric and Home Care, and Health and Grooming (Procter & Gamble, 2014). Johnson & Johnson. In 1886, the Johnson Family found Johnson & Johnson in New Brunswick, NJ to provide consumer pharmaceutical products (Johnson & Johnson, 2013). JNJ is a pioneer in global strategy......

Words: 985 - Pages: 4


...I am a crip. From the navy blue bandana on my head, to the crispy Chuck Taylors on my feet. This is the life that I live by night. My family’s reputation gives me no choice. Either the truth about me is revealed and I am discredited(pg. 4), or I live a life of hypocrisy. My father is a deacon in the church, my mother -- a Sunday school teacher, my sister, the youth president, and my brother an usher. As for me, well, I’m in the choir. I can’t sing extremely well, but well enough to receive a courtesy stigma by members of my church because every other member of my family played an impactful role, and the church itself was founded in our living room. They feel indebted so of course I was “a young anointed boy with the potential to “lead” many people to Christ.” At least, that’s what they say. My gangster family and my biological family could never learn of each other, so I had no choice but to become a master of information control. Back on the West Side, on 2nd Ave & 48th street I’m breaking down weed in my brand new grinder at 7: 15 am. The big yellow school bus should be here by 7:30, that gives me enough time to break it down and put it in the baggies to make sales throughout the school day. I go to Palisades Charter High school, in other words one of the predominantly white schools in Los Angeles County. Its no question, my parents want me out the hood, little did they know they couldn’t take the hood out of me. I put a glob of hair grease in my hair and spray a......

Words: 2268 - Pages: 10

Stigma on Obesity

...Stigma on obesity Stigma is often unfair. It does not consider the feelings of the people involved. It is a collection of various negative principals that people have about something. Stigma of obesity is causing psychological problems to the people that are obese. These people are disadvantaged when it comes to various issues just because they are obese. Adults as well as children face this stigmatization. Most of them are viewed as lazy, weak-willed and less intelligent as compared to the non-obese people. People see them as sick people who are not willing to do anything about their bodies. When it comes to issues such as; marriage, employment and educational issues, the obese face serious discrimination. Such discrimination has adverse effects on the physical health of the obese (Puhl and Heuer p1). Stigmatization may cause emotional problems when obesity is assumed to be easily prevented by self-control. Thus, the obese person is viewed as a failure. At work obese people are seen as lazy, less competent and lack self-discipline (Puhl and Heuer p2). They are rarely promoted and more often paid less as compared to others are also they more prone to layoffs. In school obese students are bullied or teased by their peers. The teachers also have biased attitudes towards them. Stigmatization causes physical health, psychological and social consequences to the people involved. It can result in depression, low self-esteem, excessive dieting, and anorexia among other......

Words: 769 - Pages: 4