Elements of a Good Legal System

In: Social Issues

Submitted By ILLUNGA
Words 95027
Pages 381
An Introduction to the Theory of Legal System SECOND EDITION
JOSEPH RAZ CLARENDON PRESS · OXFORD -iiiOxford University Press, Great Clarendon Street, Oxford ox2 6DP Oxford New York Athens Auckland Bangkok Bogota Bombay Buenos Aires Calcutta Cape Town Dar es Salaam Delhi Florence Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madras Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi Paris Singapore Taipei Tokyo Toronto Warsaw and associated companies in Berlin Ibadan Oxfordis a trade mark of Oxford University Press Published in the United Statesby Oxford University Press Inc., New York © Oxford University Press 1970, 1980 First published 1970 Second edition 1980 Reprinted 1990, 1997 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press. Within the UK, exceptions are allowed in respect of any fair dealing for the purpose of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of the licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside these terms and in other countries should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above This book is sold subject to the condition that it shall not, by way of trade or otherwise, be lent, re-sold, hired out or otherwise circulated without the publisher's prior consent in any form of binding or cover other than that in which it is published and without a similar condition including this condition being imposed on the subsequent purchaser British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Raz, Joseph The concept of a legal system.-2nd ed. 1. Jurisprudence I. Titleeem 340.1…...

Similar Documents

Legal System

...In our legal system, the lawyers are using all kinds of defenses to repsent their clients. And there are many types of them. Sometimes they are used to help with a client the defense lawyer knows is guilty, and is trying to get a lesser sentence. We all see the television shows where the defense attorney and his client meet with the DA and work out a deal, and we say wow what an easy job that is. If we look at it more in the real light it is not so easy. First the defense must find any potential violations to his defendants legal rights. He must also, “ determine the best stratery for arguring on the defendants behalf”. (Meyer and Grant 2003) When the defense looks at the charges agenst their client they then need to look at many factors such as, is there any evidence that can prove the mental state of the defenant. If there is then they might be able to go with a defense of either temperary insaniey or even insaniey. There needs to be an guily act that was voluntary which is actus reus. If there was no voluntay act then it could fit in this defense of insaniey. The next defense could be selfdefense. Was this a crime where the person need to protect themselves, from harm. The defense lawyer needs to look at all the circumstances in the case. The next one is along the same lines as selfdefense, but it is was the defendant provocated by either being abused for a long period of time in there life. Was the defendant being abused at that point and lost control. ......

Words: 491 - Pages: 2

Elements of a Good Legal System

...For ages, human societies have always sought for means of ensuring social harmony and peaceful coexistence, and this has been done through the formation of laws. In our societies today, laws are useful as they act as deterrents and also for problem-solving. The objective of these laws, which form the legal system of a society, is to serve the best interests of the people and reflect their highest aspirations. Legal systems, like all other human creations, may or may not be useful, but they always produce unintended side effects. The parameters used to measure the side effects of laws are the human rights, living standards, and quality of life standards of the people, any or all of which may be unintentionally degraded when a law is enforced. This essay will therefore discuss the nature of a legal system and the elements found in a good legal system. According to the Zambia Association of Social Sciences Teachers [ZASST] (2011, p.15) legal system, “Refers to the processes of dealing with offences and also the institutions (courts police prison) that enforces and enact these laws.” Summers (2001) says a legal system is a legal regimen of a country consisting of a constitution, written or oral; primary legislation, statutes, and laws; authorized by constitutionally authorized legislative body; primary legislation authorized body enacts subsidiary legislation or bylaws; traditional practices upheld by the courts; Civil, common, Roman, or other code of law as source of such......

Words: 1801 - Pages: 8

Legal System

...Topic 1: The Legal System TABLE OF CONTENTS | | | |Introduction |1 | | | | |The Local Court |2 | | | | |The District Court |4 | | | | |The Supreme Court |6 | | | | |Alternative Dispute Resolutions |7 | | | ...

Words: 3873 - Pages: 16

Legal System

...A court is a Parliamentary institution and one of the main sources of English law which has the authority to resolve legal disputes between parties and carry out justice in both civil and criminal divisions in accordance with the rule of law. The courts have a function that gives the public the chance to bring their claims before a court and those accused of a crime have the right to present a defense before a court. The courts is part of the law making process and it is clear that the judges make law in two ways by interpreting and applying the law and by developing the common law which forms parts of the judiciary. On the purpose of my court observation I visited two courts. Firstly, On Tuesday 26th of October the Supreme Court in Parliament Square. The Supreme Court is the last court of appeal for both civil and criminal cases from England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. The court hears appeals on arguable points of law of the general public and is bound by its own decisions. The Supreme Court was established by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 and now undertakes the work previously carried out by the House of Lords. These changes took place in order to emphasise the separation of powers in our constitution, and for more independence between the senior judges from the United Kingdom’s law makers. However, the previous decisions of House of Lords are still binding on future courts even after being abolished. It’s also important to note that the Supreme Court’s......

Words: 834 - Pages: 4

Legal System in Aghanistan

...with the detailed analysis of the Russian legal system and also a critical analysis of the textual and contextual part of laws of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan According to the Constitution, Afghanistan is an Islamic Republic, independent, unitary and indivisible state. It aims at consolidating national unity, safeguarding independence, national sovereignty, and territorial integrity of the country, for establishing a government based on people's will and democracy. Also for the first time, any constitution of this state has recognized and given place to human rights and fundamental rights. The government comprises of a Council of Ministers and a National Assembly. The President is the head of the state and the Commander-in-chief of the army. The country has been through many political upheavals and the current constitution was adopted post withdrawal of American NATO forces and an executive president was elected. The National Assembly is composed of the House of People(Woleshi Jirga) and the House of Elders (Meshrana Jirga). The first legislature was elected in 2005 and then re-elected in 2010. The current parliamentary members mostly comprise of former mujahedeen, Islamic fundamentalists, reformists, communists and several Taliban members. The current Afghanistan government system consists of three branches of power- executive, legislature and judiciary overseen by a system of checks and balances. The Afghanistan legal system is mostly a mixture of civil,......

Words: 5584 - Pages: 23

Legal System

...The legal system of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (HKSAR) is based on the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary. The constitutional framework for the legal system is provided by the Basic Law sanctioned by the National People’s Congress of the PRC. Under the principle of ‘one country, two systems’, the HKSAR legal system, which is different from that of Mainland China, is based on the common law, supplemented by local legislation. All legislation in force in the HKSAR is accessible on the internet at www.legislation.gov.hk. Law in the HKSAR: The laws in force in the HKSAR include: (1) the Basic Law; (2) national laws listed in Annex III to the Basic Law; (3) the laws, including the common law and the rules of equity, in force before July 1, 1997, apart from a small number of statutory provisions which were declared by the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress to contravene the Basic Law; and (4) laws enacted by the legislature of the HKSAR. National laws relating to defence, foreign affairs and other matters outside the limits of the autonomy of the HKSAR may be listed in Annex III to the Basic Law for application in the HKSAR by way of promulgation or legislation by the HKSAR. Currently, 12 national laws are included in Annex III to the Basic Law. The Judiciary: It is fundamental to Hong Kong’s legal system that members of the judiciary are independent of the executive and legislative branches of......

Words: 2594 - Pages: 11

The Fluid Landscape of Legal Systems

...The Fluid Landscape of Legal Systems Question 2 Roger Cotterrell has written the following: “What all of these indications add up to is the recognition that neither legal systems nor societies can be thought of as unified and integrated in the way that western thought has often assumed. A comparative legal perspective is no more than the systematic recognition that law is always fluid, pluralistic, contested and subject to often contradictory pressures from both inside and outside its jurisdiction; that it reflects an always unstable diversity of traditions, interests, allegiances, and ultimate values and beliefs. If the comparative perspective on law was once a view of the exotic ‘legal other’ or of the ‘external relations’ of one’s own law with the law of other peoples in other lands, now it is a view of transnational legal patterns and of the cultural complexities of law at home. We live in conditions where the law of the nation-state must respond to a great plurality of demands from different population groups within its jurisdiction. At the same time, it must respond to powerful external pressures. Legal thought in national contexts is being fragmented from within in a new ‘jurisprudence of difference’…and globalized from without in demands for transnational harmonization or uniformity. (“Culture, Comparison, Community” by Roger Cotterrell) Kindly react to this statement, supporting your personal views and conclusions with research, analysis, examples and well-reasoned...

Words: 4279 - Pages: 18

Legal System

...Its legal, ethical and global environment, one way that the U.S. legal system affects this country, particularly businesses, is the fact that it maintains order. Import laws limit how much of certain products (if any) from a given country can come into the US, regulates who/what/where can receive US goods via export, and even controls the ability to process payments and collect debts. Beyond that, laws such as the Foreign Corrupt Practice Act (FCPA) and anti-boycott laws limit the way in which US companies can do business abroad, even through agents & subsidiaries. The overarching aspect about the US legal system that influences business is "accountability." if you enter into a contract with a US company and they breach it, they can be held legally accountable to you, and you can effectively assert your rights in court - whether you are a US citizen or a foreign company. While there are numerous examples of large companies abusing the legal system at the expense of smaller ones. In addition to getting your day in court, and being treated fairly, accountability means that any court decision in your favor should be enforceable. Unenforceable judgments are impotent and unjust. Knowledge of this accountability gives companies, both US and foreign, a degree of comfort that allows them to more freely enter into agreements with US companies. Absent the accountability that is afforded by a fair, accessible, and effective court system, companies may be more hesitant to......

Words: 254 - Pages: 2

Legal Systems

...Directory / Get Legal Forms / Legal Encyclopedia / Help Out • • Wex • all pages • articles • español • Inbox Project • search • FAQ Legal systems Introduction: profusion and variety There are hundreds of legal systems in the world. At the global level, international law is of great importance, whether created by the practice of sovereign states or by agreement among them in the form of treaties and other accords. Some transnational entities such as the European Union have created their own legal structures. At the national level there are over 180 sovereign states in the United Nations Organization. Many of these are federal or confederal, and their constituent parts may well have their own law. But, despite this great variety, it is important to begin by emphasizing one great division: that into religious and secular legal systems. Each side of this split holds quite different views as to law, in its source, scope, sanctions, and function. The source of religious law is the deity, legislating through the prophets. Secular law is made by human beings, and one of its most famous examples begins with the words 'We, the people'. It follows from this difference in their source that religious laws are perceived to be eternal and immutable, while secular rules can be changed by their makers. Religious law tells people what to believe as well as how to behave, whereas secular law deals with our external actions as they affect others. In a religious legal system......

Words: 8159 - Pages: 33

Six Elements of a Good Legal System

...Culture is seen as a system of social control, wherein people shape their standards and behavior. The cultural values form the founding principles of one's life. They influence one's principles and philosophies of life. They influence one's way of living and thus impact social life. The importance of culture lies in the fact that it is a link between people and their value systems. Culture shapes personality. No child can develop human qualities in the absence of cultural environment. Culture prepares man for group life. It is culture that provides opportunities for the development of personality and sets limits on its growth thereby keeping social relationship intact. Culture’s importance is not only for men but also for the group. Culture prepares man for group life. Group life would have been poor, nasty, and short if there had been no cultural regulations. Group solidarity rests on the foundation of culture. Culture also creates new needs and drives, for example, thirst for knowledge and arranges for their satisfaction. It satisfies the moral and religious interests of the members of the group (Stephen, 1996). During the colonial period, the process of industrialization and urbanization saw ethnically different people brought together by economic interests. This as well as the very definite influence of western standards generated a new culture without conscious effort of politically determined guidelines. The colonial powers introduced efficient system of......

Words: 2717 - Pages: 11

Australian Legal System in Context

...AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM IN CONTEXT BLB1101 Semester 1 2014 Table of contents Topic Page number Unit rationale and learning outcomes 3 Calendars – lectures and tutorial workshops 4 Tutorial workshop exercises 5-11 Assessment information 12-23 Assessment tasks 12 Part 1 – VCAT and Applied law 12 Part 2 – VCAT and Contextual analysis 13 Hypothetical Case Studies 15 • Residential Tenancies List 15 • Planning and Environment List 18 • Anti-Discrimination list 20 Assessment criteria 22 Reading guide 24-28 Su Robertson, Unit Coordinator su.robertson@vu.edu.au 9919 1823 Unit rationale BLB1101 Australian Legal System in Context: • Provides you with a working foundation in the technical structure of Australian legal systems, using applied practical teaching and learning methods; • Exposes you to ways of making sense of Australian legal systems in a legal academic way using the themes of economics, sustainability, race and gender; • Inducts you in the ways of the lawyer, including appropriate language use and structure, ethics and legal professional behaviour, using reflective, applied and theory-based teaching and learning methods. Learning outcomes Upon successful completion of BLB1101, you will: • Be able to identify and understand the components of Australian legal systems, how these components intersect and interact, and how lawyers use these systems; • Be able to identify and use the......

Words: 9050 - Pages: 37

Elements of a Contract - Bus670 Legal Environment

...Elements of a Contract Nicole Castro BUS670 Legal Environment Prof. Robert Tocker September 2, 2013 A contract of employment is a type of a contract used in labor law to attribute rights and responsibilities between parties to a contract (Blum, 2007). On the one end stands an "employee" who is "employed" by an "employer". A written employment contract is a document that someone and their employee sign which sets forth the terms and conditions of the employment relationship (Tepper, 2011). Many rules, exceptions and considerations apply when dealing with employment contracts. Suppose that the Fabulous Hotel hires you as head chef under a two-year employment contract. After two years, another hotel wants to hire you. However, in the original employment contract you signed with the fabulous Hotel, the following paragraph appears: “The below-signed agrees not to work as a chef for another hotel in the same metropolitan area for a period of two years after leaving our employ.” First, it is crucial to know and understand which law governs the employment contract. According to Seaquist, contract law is governed by the common law or the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) (Seaquist, 2012). If the contract handles the sales of goods, it is governed by the UCC (Seaquist, 2012). If the contract handles anything besides the sale of goods (such as real estate, insurance, personal services like employment, etc.) then it is governed by the common law (Seaquist, 2012). ...

Words: 2052 - Pages: 9

Unmanned Aircraft System Elements

...UVSC 2750 X1 Unmanned aircraft system elements Throughout history there have been a wide variety of unmanned aerial operations. These range from kites used in Asia to measure distances to commands using kites to send signals in battle. Others used aerial balloons to drop bombs on the enemy during the American Civil War. In modern times the most familiar to us are the aerial drones being used around the world. These are both fixed wing as well as rotary aircraft that allow for a variety roles depending the on situation at hand. The purpose of Ground Control Stations is for the operation of the unmanned aircraft. This is an over simplification of a complex arrangement of communications and equipment that the operator uses to control the aircraft with out being in the aircraft. Typically this is divided into two parts: on for the operator and the second for the payload operator. Further this ground control stations can be located in or around the battlefield or halfway around the world depending on the needs of the operation. Again the ground control station is the location on the ground that the operator is flying the vehicle from and that all depends on the type of mission that is being carried out. Explain the purpose of Ground Control Stations The data links between line-of-sight and beyond line-of-sight come down to the operator being able to control the unmanned vehicle. In the line-of-sight data link there must be a clear line, no mountains to the...

Words: 556 - Pages: 3

Legal System

...gangs hurt the communities as well because when gangs emerge in different cities the value of these cities decline.             There are several factors as to why our youth are so attracted to gang activity today. For many young people they join gangs because of the feeling of being accepted. The economic opportunities for them are more appealing to them then a low-wage job. Youth who feel rejected in their families, school or even at church join gangs to fill the need for a support system, for a sense of belonging. For some, the appeal is that a friend or family member are already a part of a gang.             Because of such an increase in gang activity today amongst our youth something has to be done. I truly believe, that each point of contact, in our children’s lives have to play their roles whether it be as parents, school teachers, family members, law enforcement, etc. As adults in the lives of our youth we need to be able to reach out to them and let them know they have a great support system. We need to prepare our youth for proven success. Educate them on the consequences of being in a gang.             There is impact on gang membership and the burden it places on our health, law enforcement, schools, as well families are very substantial. By preventing our youth from joining gangs in the first place, we considerably progress their chances for a safe and productive life. By working together to focus on the prevention of gang memberships in our communities we......

Words: 603 - Pages: 3

Legal Elements of Fraud

...CJUS360-1104A-01: Legal Elements of Fraud Instructor: Jeffrey Beck Phase 2 DB 1: Legal Sources for Fraud Nina A. Lugo October 12, 2011 In Madrid Spain, Escala, a Connecticut based business with a global network of companies and parent company Afinsa Bienes Tangibles, a Spanish company involved in commercial and trading activities were caught in a fraudulent scheme which allowed them to increase their revenues to over eighty million in 2004 and 2005. These transactions allowed them to meet their earnings forecast for 2004 and first quarter in 2005. As a result of these transactions, Escala’s share prices rose from 1.47 per share to 32.00 per share, when merged with Afinsa. Both companies were able to get these results by committing fraudulent acts which included the manipulation of collectable stamp values and their appraisals. Escala and Afinsa failed to disclose their involvement with Barrett & Warren, a small publishing company in which they initially gained control of the stamp collection. Escala was guilty of selling Afinsa’s investors the stamps at arm’s length prices. Escala also was guilty of selling back inventory to Afinsa which is considered a round trip transaction. They were also guilty of falsely reporting a payment for business combination related expense as the sale of certain antiques. Escala violated the antifraud and reporting provisions of the federal securities law according the SEC complaints. The SEC charged Escala with......

Words: 578 - Pages: 3