Free Essay


In: Historical Events

Submitted By suman008
Words 267
Pages 2
Embryonic harvesting and freezing is considered an ethical dilemma and morally unacceptable. Karen Capato reserved sperm for in-vitro fertilization posthumous and reared twins as a result. In this instance, technology was used after the death of a spouse to create life posthumous and the use of such is considered an act of God. “The Bible mentions in its parables that we should not to disrupt a life” (E. Horning, personal communication, January 31, 2013). Manipulating genetics interrupts the natural process of life in God-like actions, regardless of the term in pregnancy and shouldn’t be performed.
Research offers advancements in technology that takes ethics to a new level and can be seen as bothersome by some. Legality issues even arise from such dilemma’s, as in the case of the Capato’s, where the Supreme Court “struggled to align modern reproductive techniques to a federal law written in 1939” (Barnes, R. 2012).
Four interviews were conducted in relation to this ethical dilemma. The first was held with a health administrator, Suzie, who is the manager of an Operating Room, with nursing experience within this profession for the last 15 years. She is a practicing Orthodox Christian and her worldview about embryo freezing for future implantation is met with opposition. She believes it is ethically and morally wrong and all things happen in life according to God’s plan. Embryo’s, in her opinion, are considered a human being and concern is relayed upon the destruction of any unused embryos, with her belief being that this would be an intentional killing of an individual (Suzie, personal communication, January 30, 2013).…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Stem Cell Research

...when the method of obtaining stem cells from human embryos and growing them in a laboratory was discovered by scientists. These cells being grown were human embryonic stem cells, “…derived from embryos that develop from eggs that have been fertilized in vitro — in an in vitro fertalization clinic—and then donated for research purposes with informed consent of the donors,”(National Institutes of Health, 12, Nov. 2012).These embryos are created for reproductive purposes. Stem Cells have the remarkable potential to develop into many different cell types in the body, fundamentally being the source of all external/ internal organs and tissues. When a stem cell divides, this new cell can either remain a stem cell or become another specialized type of cell, such as: a brain cell, red blood cell, or a muscle cell Although stem cells are unspecialized cells, sometimes after a long period of inactivity, they’re able to renew themselves through cell division. Due to the limitless benefits to medicine and human health, many Americans support stem cell research, considering this treatment as a workable option to treat many injuries, diseases, and malfunctions. This research offers a great amount of hope for the advancement of medicine, because stem cells can grow into any kind of cell, that can replace damaged neural cells in the brain and spinal cord. Pro-choicers reject the care of a pre-embryo, and suppose that even though an embryo can develop into a person, it is not a person by......

Words: 786 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Human Embryonic Stem Cells

...that they represent the future relief or cure of a wide range of common disabilities; replacement of defective cells in a patient by transplantation of hES cell‐derived equivalents would restore normal function. On the other hand, the use of hES cells is highly controversial because they are derived from human pre‐implantation embryos. To date, most embryos used for the establishment of hES cell lines have been spare embryos from IVF, but the creation of embryos specifically for deriving hES cells is also under discussion. The most controversial variant of this is the transfer of a somatic cell‐nucleus from a patient to an enucleated oocyte (unfertilized egg) in order to produce hES cells genetically identical to that patient for ‘autologous’ transplantation (so‐called ‘therapeutic’ cloning); this may prevent tissue rejection. The question ‘Can these cells be isolated and used and, if so, under what conditions and restrictions’ is presently high on the political and ethical agenda, with policies and legislation being formulated in many countries to regulate their derivation. The UK has been the first to pass a law governing the use of human embryos for stem cell research. The European Science Foundation has established a committee to make an inventory of the positions taken by governments of countries within Europe on this issue (European Science Foundation, 2001). In order to discuss the moral aspects of the isolation and use of hES cells, which is the aim of the......

Words: 8387 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Re: Nrs 437 Embryo Harvesting , Part Ii

...Embryo Harvesting & Freezing/Genetic Manipulation, Part II We are living in a new era where technology can help women have babies in unconventional ways. Having children is a personal choice. In some people’s view, government should not be regulating when people should and should not start having a family. The ethical issue is when the parents start applying for governmental benefits after the baby is conceived via In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) and born posthumously. When practicing IVF, are we violating God’s will? This paper is to discuss the views of the four candidates interviewed in relation to posthumous conception and delivery, their views on benefits/inheritance entitlement to these babies, and ethical principles and theories in question. J.K. opinion is that every person should be free to exercise their autonomy and make decisions that are right for them without the influence of governmental regulations. J.K. follows the principles of respect for autonomy which is allowing for the capacity for self-determination (Ascension Health, 2013). She has firsthand knowledge and the experience of a person that was unable to conceive a child in her current relationship. She knows the pain and the emotional rollercoaster that can only be known by someone who has experienced infertility. She also believes that the time of conception should be a personal decision, not regulated by the government and that financial benefits should be provided to that child. R.L. has very......

Words: 1286 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Stem Cells

...kind of tissue depending on what the cells around them are. This ability to transform into any cell of the body makes them very interesting in medical research because they may have the ability to regenerate damaged human tissue. If adult stem cell research seems promising to cure some diseases, the research on embryonic stem cells seems unavoidable. That research is very controversial because those cells need to be taken from a live embryo; taking those cells will ultimately kill it. The embryonic stem cell research could lead the medical profession to find cures for diseases, giving hope to thousands of people, but is it worth killing a potential life for saving an existing one? Stem cells have a very high price (the lives of those embryos), but so many of those embryos may be destroyed anyway. Now, because the government does not want to take a real position on the problem, stem cell research is authorized as long as it does not use federal funds. Strict rules should be written encouraging research on stem cells but restricting the ways those embryos are collected, thereby allowing the United States to advance in modern medicine. Stem cells are cells that are undifferentiated. This means that they have no function yet; therefore, they have the potential to become almost any other kind of cell when placed around specialized cells. Those include skin cells, muscle cells, even the brain cells: neurons. By grafting those cells into the diseased area, the cell will reproduce......

Words: 1589 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Draft Embryo

...Layout/Presentation (3m): *correct length *title *coversheet *plagiarism statement Intro (4m0:*brief description of malformation *population frequency *Clearly written *uses references effectively * concise, accurate Normal development (20m): brief description of normal development *Clearly written *concise, accurate *uses diagrams effectively *Technical terms explained in clear manner at the correct level *uses references effectively *no references are weblinks Abnormal development (10m): brief description of cause of malformation *Clearly written *concise, accurate *uses diagrams effectively *Technical terms explained in clear manner at the correct level *uses references effectively * no references are web links Latest research (10m): brief description of underlying cause of malformation OR *brief description of recent experimental data *Clearly written *concise, accurate *Technical terms explained in clear manner at the correct level *clear understanding of concepts well explained * correct use of journal references Additional info (5m): parental diagnosis/prevention Interesting and informative *clearly written * concise, accurate * reliable websites are references Where to find help (3m): list Australian and international organisation websites Australian and at least one overseas organisation listed *all links are valid References (4m): Appropriate references *Cited in text *list correctly in reference list *Referenced diagrams No inappropriate use of......

Words: 299 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Development of Embryo

...THE DEVELOPMENT OF EMBRYO #WEEK 1 Day 1. Fertilization In the beginning is the egg. Inside the fallopian tube, a mature human egg waits in a state of arrested development. Just released from the ovary, it is the largest cell in the human body. The egg is packed with nutrients, growth factors, enzymes and proteins — nearly everything it needs to jump start the development of a human embryo. Except for one little thing — it needs a sperm. If a sperm doesn’t penetrate the egg’s tough outer membrane to activate it within the next 24 hours, the egg will die.¬¬ The sperm cells contain the male genetic contribution to the new genome that will be produced at the completion of fertilization. Sperm cells are produced during the process of meiosis, which occurs in the testis during spermatogenesis. At the completion of meiosis each sperm contains a haploid genome (one chromatid from each chromosome pair). During fertilization and the first stage of embryonic development, the egg runs the show. All a mature human egg really needs from a sperm is its DNA — the genetic code stored in 23 chromosomes inherited from the father. When combined with 23 chromosomes in the egg from the mother, the new embryo has the full complement of genetic material required to make a human being. The fertilization process commences with the sperm initiating the penetration of the zona pellucid. Firstly, the sperm squeezes through cells left over from the follicle. When it reaches the jelly coat, the......

Words: 2882 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Totipotential Stem Cells

...ethical issues are cells that strictly come from embryos. The potential property that these cells carry makes them unique in having the ability to grow and develop into every organ and tissue of the human body; therefore these types of embryonic stem cells can be the possible answer to the cure of tissues that have been severely deformed due to different types of disease they have encountered. The research has shown some progress, although nothing significant, but the fact that the age of this research is no more than 6 years makes it a hot and exciting topic to keep an eye on and follow the progress. This research may not show results anytime soon, but defiantly will in the future. Sadly the research of the embryonic stem cells in the US has very little support and no significant progress, simply because the research of “embryonic stem cell” is viewed as supporting abortion. As a result: in 2001 president Bush limited the federal funding for this research. Following the fact that embryonic stem cells are the center of concern and attention comes the question of: from where do researchers obtain these embryos? The first thing that might come to mind when thinking of the answer is the idea of “aborted fetuses”. The truth is: aborted fetuses have tissues and organs that have already been developed; therefore they are not a good source for embryonic stem cell research. In fact the best source of these cell for research are embryos that are in the blastocyst stage, which are......

Words: 1322 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Stem Cell Research

...undifferentiated cells of an Early human embryo to create any new, specialized type of cell (Brignier and Gewirtz S337). Embryonic stem cells are very useful for cell based therapies because they can Develop into more than 220 cell types that are found in an adult, and they have the ability To reproduce in large numbers. They are capable of almost unlimited cell divisions when Placed in culture. This makes embryonic stem cells very flexible and versatile. Using Stem cells to learn about the ways that these cells differentiate, grow, and renew will also Have profound results in the study and cure of cancers, birth defects, diabetes, and spinal cord Injuries, and other diseases caused by dysfunctional cell replication. Research on 3 Embryonic stem cells can also improve drug safety, as a drug can be tested on a stem cell Line before use in a patient (Louis 2009). The embryonic stem cells are extracted from The inner cell mass during the early blastocyst phase of embryonic development. After an Egg is fertilized, generally during in vitro in the laboratory, it begins dividing. The Blastocyst is a hollow ball of about 150 cells. The inner cell mass are the cells located in The inner part of the ball, and once extracted, the embryo is no longer viable or living (Monk 35). Hence, the controversy arises with destruction of the embryo. The use of the other type of stem cells, adult stem cells, in research and treatments Does not destroy an embryo. But adult stem cell applications......

Words: 3236 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay


...Inside the integument of the ovule was the embryo sac. The antipodals and synergids senesce and disintegrate. The central cell united with one sperm cell to make endosperm...a nutritive tissue that accumulates starch, protein, and fats to provide for the growth of the embryo. The egg cell of the embryo sac united with the other sperm cell to make a zygote. The zygote grows and becomes a true embryo inside the integument. We will recall that the seed developing in the carpel produces hormones that make the carpel develop into a fruit. The mother plant also produces abscisic acid to make the embryo inside the seed become dormant When you have a Dormant Embryo, a Storage Tissue, and a Seed Coat, then you have a SEED. In some seeds, the endosperm is retained as the storage tissue. In other seeds the endosperm is more or less used up to put storage chemicals into the embryo itself (commonly in the cotyledons). Below are diagrams and a photo of some seeds. This first example above, is a longitudinal section through a Capsella seed. You may observe several cell layers of seed coat (integument) on the outside. In the interior is an embryo. There is a root apex, a radicle that transitions into a hypocotyl terminating at the attachment node for two cotyledons between which we can see the shoot apex. The embryo may be bent, but it has all the parts of a typical embryo. Having two cotyledons means that Capsella is a dicot plant. Between the embryo and the seed coat is a layer of......

Words: 388 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cardiovascular Embryo

...LEVEL I BLOCK IV MODULE II | CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM CASE 1: LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT (TRIGGER 1) What is the embryonic origin and development of the heart and blood vessels? - The endocardium is derived from the hypoblast. - The myocardium is derived from the mesoblast. FORMATION OF THE HEART TUBE - Clusters of the cells arise in the mesenchyme at the cephalic end of the embryonic disc, cephalic to the site of the developing mouth and the nervous system. - These clusters of cells form a plexus of endothelial blood vessels that fuse to form the right and left endothelial heart tubes, and fuse to form single mesodian endocardial tube. - As the head fold of the embryo develops, the endocardial tube and the pericardial cavity rotate on a transverse axis through almost 180 degree, so that they come to lie to the esophagus and caudal to the developing mouth. - The heart tube starts to bulge into the pericardial cavity. - Meanwhile, the endocardial tube becomes surrounded by a thick layer of mesenchyme, which will differentiate into myocardium and the visceral layer of the serous pericardium. - The primitive heart has been established, and the cephalic end is the arterial end and the caudal end is the venous end. - The arterial end of the primitive heart is continuous beyond the pericardium with a large vessel, the aortic sac. - The heart begins to beat during the third week. FURTHER DEVELOPMENT OF THE HEART TUBE - The heart then undergoes differential expansion......

Words: 1193 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Embryonic Stem Cell Research

...devastated by disease have asked or hoped for a cure. What everyone should know is that a cure is possible, but some beliefs are stopping cures from being found. Embryonic stem cell research could provide solutions to medical illnesses that scientists and doctors have been searching for for years. However, certain belief systems argue that an embryo is a person, and destroying an embryo for research is murder. The essential question concerning stem cell research is summed up by this quote from President Bush, “"As I thought through this issue I kept returning to two fundamental questions," Bush stated in an address to the nation. "First, are these frozen embryos human life and therefore something precious to be protected? And second, if they're going to be destroyed anyway, shouldn't they be used for a greater good, for research that has the potential to save and improve other lives?"” (Update: Stem Cell Research). Embryonic stem cell research is a valid, ethical form of medical research that the United States should fund because it has the potential to cure many diseases, an embryo is not equivalent to a human being, the embryos used will be destroyed even without the research, and the United States will fall behind other nations in biomedical research progress. There are many medical problems that can be solved through stem cell research. The medical troubles that the research has potential to cure include, “heart disease, diabetes, cancer, strokes, breast cancer,......

Words: 2739 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Project Management

...evaluated is the use of stem cell ethical. In 1973, Supreme Court decision in Roe v. Wade rules that decisions about abortion are private, between a woman and her doctor. Some States may not forbid abortion in first two trimesters. This decision sparks a large, politically active anti-abortion movement that opposes research on embryos. Members of Congress become concerned about research exploitation of embryos and fetuses that will be aborted. (Wertz, 2002) In 1974,Congress applies its own temporary moratorium on federally funded clinical research on embryos and embryonic tissue, including research on IVF, infertility, and prenatal diagnosis, until national guidelines can be established. A de facto moratorium continues until the present. Basic, non-therapeutic, research using embryonic cells continues, out of public view. Congress establishes National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. The National Commission’s first mandate is ethical guidelines for fetal and embryo research (Wertz, 2002). The National Commission’s specifies that societal protection of human subjects should be extended to embryos and fetuses, even in the context of abortion, and recommends establishment of a national Ethics Advisory Board (EAB) to review (Wertz, 2002) In 1990, Congress voted to override the moratorium on government funding of embryonic stem cell research, which was vetoed by President George Bush. President Clinton lifted the ban,......

Words: 2715 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay


...successful cloning of human embryos. It was the discovery of in- vitro fertilization in the 1940’s that began the pursuit to ease the suffering of infertile couples. After years of research, scientists learned that "in a typical in-vitro procedure, doctors will insert three to five embryos in hopes that, at most, one or two will implant" (Elmer-Dewitt 38). And that "a woman with only one embryo has about a 10% to 20% chance of getting pregnant through in-vitro fertilization. If that embryo could be cloned and turned into three or four, thechances of a successful pregnancy would increase significantly"(Elmer- Dewitt 38). The experiment the scientists performed is the equivalent of a mother producing twins. The process has been practiced and almost perfected in livestock for the past ten years, and some scientists believe that it seems only logical that it would be the next step in in-vitro fertilization. The procedure was remarkably simple. Hall and Stillman "selected embryos that were abnormal because they came from eggs that had been fertilized by more than one sperm" (Elmer-Dewitt 38), because the embryos were defective, it would have been impossible for the scientist to actually clone another person. They did however, split the embryos into separate cells, as a result creating separate and identical clones. They began experimenting on seventeen of the defective embryos and "when......

Words: 805 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Is Stem Cell Research Ethical

...stem cells research arises because human embryos are destroyed in the process. I believe that the benefits outweigh the negatives and that a greater good can come out of using embryonic stem cells. The treatment of diseases and illnesses continually grows and improves. Embryonic stem cells have the potential to help rectify or even cure disease and illnesses that are thought to be incurable. However, the ethical battle over the sanctity of life rages on. Stem cells can be compared to the building blocks of the human body. Embryonic stem cells are pluripotent, they can develop into any other type of cell in the body. They are extracted from a cell before they differentiate. They have the capacity to make any of the 200 different cells in the body and can also self-renew or reproduce themselves. Currently, there are 89 stem cell lines, a family of constantly dividing cells, registered with the National Institute of Health (NIH). The first line was discovered in 1998. In 1996 Congress passed the Dickey-Wicker Amendment, which put restrictions on federally funding embryonic stem cell research if the embryo was created to be destroyed. In 2001, President Bush implemented guidelines to receive federal money which President Obama recently overturned. The new process no longer considers when stem was created but makes sure that strict guidelines were followed on how the embryo was obtained, who consented and payment was not given for the embryo. This is where the possibility......

Words: 2537 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Ivf Critical Analysis

...Critical Analysis In Vitro Fertilization August 19, 2009 Marriages can offer new exciting experiences especially when couples want to start developing a family. For some couples pregnancy is simple and their family begins. For others it isn’t so easy, having children becomes a medical challenge and alternative solutions need to be sought out. One such solution for conception involves using the medical advancement of In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) techniques. However, for many this raises a whole batch of ethical dilemmas. IVF brings up dilemmas such as the process itself, when does “life” begin, how many eggs to fertilize, and cryopreservation of embryos. It is an especially difficult decision for those of Christian beliefs as IVF is not widely received within the Christian community and not clearly addressed in the Bible. I first want to take a look at the process itself and what leads a couple, or individual, to this decision. Before we start, we need to define what infertility is. According to The Fertility Center (2009), infertility is the “inability for a couple to conceive after one year of normal intercourse with no contraception”. Facing infertility is not as uncommon as one might believe, according to the Center for Disease Control, “approximately 1.2 million women made infertility related appointments in 2002”. In simpler terms, one in six couples faces infertility related issues at some point during their......

Words: 2551 - Pages: 11