Essay on Rand's Ideas

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By rickweews
Words 629
Pages 3
Activity 3.4 - Essay on Rand's Ideas
Using "The Ethics of Emergencies" by Ayn Rand (pp. 215-218), develop an essay between 2 to 3 pages discussing her ideas in today's moral environment. Provide one other reference in addition to our text.
The Ethics of Emergencies describes how some people base their ethical principles on emergency situations. The classic example is the lifeboat scenario. The scenario is that what if you are stuck on a lifeboat with some other people, and there's not enough water for everyone to survive the trip to shore. In order to live, you have to sacrifice someone else. The lesson of the scenario is that you have to choose between your life and the life of another person. There is a fundamental disharmony of interests, and it is to kill or be killed. Which means in life, you are either a murderer, you are a victim, or you can sacrifice your life for other people.
The problem is that these ethics-derived-from-emergencies are anti-contextual. It is not true that there is a disharmony of interests and we do not have to choose between killing and dying in day to day life. We do not have to choose between sacrificing ourselves to others or others to ourselves. So abstracting general principles from these situations is a really bad idea. By trying to use these situations as a representation of real life, it actually becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. If you accept that life is full of conflicts of interest, you will act accordingly and create conflicts where there are none. You will seek to sacrifice yourself where no sacrifice is necessary, or you will trample on the interests of others thinking it's either you or them.
Rand described an emergency as a kind of situation where human life is not possible. That is not to say you would not survive an emergency. It means that if life were like that normally, it would be impossible. You may survive…...

Similar Documents

Big Idea

...February 27th, 2012 INTRODUCTION The Big Idea Group (BIG) was created by Micheal Collins to help both inventors and corporations meet the innovation challenge. BIG partners with inventors and companies to identify, develop and bring to market innovative ideas. Before BIG Collins founded Kid Galaxy in 1994, a specialty toy company and became a producer of the award-winning Bendos line. Bendos, a line of Gumby-like figures eventually helped Kid Galaxy gross $5 million a year. But Collins, who held just a 4% stake in his company, says he felt there was little growth in store. Collin is exposed to Clayton M. Christensen, a Harvard Business school professor who posited a theory about why companies fail, even with great technology, in his book The Innovator's Dilemma. The professor gave him an endorsement and an undisclosed investment for an idea-hunting company. A year later Collins became a success with Tiny Totes, a set of mini-handbags girls could use to store collectibles. Tiny Totes was designed by an Indianapolis woman who had tried for a number of years to break into the toy business and Collins was able to give her the first break. Almost all of Collins' products are new ideas for toys and consumer products. Collins is now looking to diversify his company Big Idea Group (BIG) which has become successful in the toy industry MBA 621 Prof. H. Stucke “What’s the BIG Idea?” STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES • The process that BIG had......

Words: 3334 - Pages: 14

Locke's Argument on Innate Ideas

...Locke’s argument against innate ideas. In Locke’s ‘An Essay Concerning Human Understanding’, he argues for his view of empiricism, concerning the origin of ideas. A conflicting position for this subject is rationalism. According to rationalists, ideas are innate. However, Locke was an empiricist and believed that ideas came from experience. In this essay I aim to explore Locke’s position on the formation of ideas and consider how his arguments may be criticised or indeed supported. According to Locke, an idea is “the object of the understanding when a man thinks” (I.i.8). In his ‘Essay’, Locke argues against the notion that ideas are innate in humans. He argued that ideas were formed from sensory experience rather than being innate. By innate, we mean that we were born with the ideas. Locke mentions the argument for innate ideas being that there are universally accepted ideas, so they must be already present in people when they are born. In the ‘Essay’, Locke said that the existence of innate ideas could be disproved if another way was found in which all mankind could come to agree on a certain truth. I think there is a weakness in this argument. In order for his point to be relevant, he would need to find this truth that is universally accepted and prove that it was born from experience. Therefore, the argument that innate ideas are responsible for universal truths is the best explanation that can be given. Although Locke’s argument does not have a lot to justify......

Words: 1608 - Pages: 7

Essay on Political Economy of Work - Discussing Taylor's Ideas on Scientific Management

...Essay in Political Economy of Work Do Taylor’s ideas on scientific management have any application in the contemporary workplace? Discuss with reference to evidence and alternative insights. Why for example do so many banks, health providers, and other companies ask you to key in your account number “for faster service,” when you will be asked to repeat it twice more to the people who are serving you? That is a symptom of Taylorism run rampant, a misplaced faith in technology unjustified by human experience. (Weisbord 2011: 12) The nature of work and its organization has interested managers, economists and social scientists for as long as people have been employed by others to engage in productive activity. Indeed, managers have largely been interested in maximizing output from available resources. Economists and social scientists have raised questions about the organization of work in relation to issues of the individual and society in general. Historically, the emphasis was on finding the best way in which to manage the human resource through scientific and mechanical means. Frederick Taylor (“Taylorism”) and Henry Ford (“Fordism”) were both looking to make labour more efficient by fitting workers to jobs. To counteract the some of the worst features of Taylorism, the job redesign and human relations movements stressed the importance of an understanding of employees’ social, rather than simply economic, needs. ...

Words: 2872 - Pages: 12


...Running head: ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY Annotated Bibliography Leslie Susie Grand Canyon University: SPE 529N March 6, 2013 16 Annotated Bibliography Idea partnerships (2011) Retrieved from (“Idea Partnerships,” 2011) FAPE is the Family and Advocates Partnership for Education. FAPE was funded from 1997-2004. An organization called Pacer Center maintains the FAPE website to keep parents and professionals informed of IDEA, (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act) and other special education issues. FAPE.ORG offers parents, teachers, and contributors updated news and information to increase the learning for disabled children.FAPE.ORG links to news and articles concerning new updates about Special Education. FAPE.ORG links to more resources about IDEA. Herman, J. (2009). Voicenation: Special education resources. Retrieved from Jacob Herman created the website Voicenation to give parents and teachers a list of immediate resources after accessing the website. Resources are grouped by General Disabilities, Learning Disabilities, Speech Impairment, Hearing Impairment, Vision Impairment, Emotional Disabilities, Autism, Parent and Educator Resources, Special Need and Technology, Associations and National Organizations, and Special Education Discussion Forums. Teachers and Parents do not have to use search engines......

Words: 809 - Pages: 4

Idea Jumpstart

...IDEA JUMPSTART Assessment 1B: In-class (Individual) Bag Made-to-Order Task Sheet (20%) Instructions: This is a 20% individual assignment. It should be completed IN CLASS and submitted at the end of the lesson. Task: To apply the process of Divergent Thinking (Flexibility, Fluency, Originality and Elaboration) in designing ORIGINAL design ideas for customized bags, which is suitable to user needs. Assessment Criteria: * Able to state user needs clearly * Able to generate design ideas for bags which reflect varieties (not overly similar to one another) * Able to generate design ideas for bags that are relevant and suitable to user needs * Able to generate design ideas for bags which reflect originality * Able to elaborate on design ideas with sufficient description and details and clarify with sketches, where appropriate Part A- Scrutiny of Bag Examination of your friend’s bag Find a classmate to work with for this assignment. Allow your friend to scrutinise your bag and vice versa. Make as many notes as you can about what you see. Part B – Bag Talk Interview Your Classmate (Ask at least 4 questions) Interview your classmate to profile him/her. Look for needs and observe what they say and how they utilize their bag. The objective is to find out questions like: Who is this consumer? What does this bag mean to him/her? Some Suggested Questions: How many bags do you have? On what occasions do you use this bag?......

Words: 388 - Pages: 2

Ideas and Ontology

...nd Ontology aa e ysics of Ide etaph as M rn de o Id An Ess M Marc A. Hight ay i nE ar ly Idea and Ontology Idea and Ontology an essay in early modern metaphysics of ideas marc a. hight t h e p e n n s y l va n i a s t at e u n i v e r s i t y p r e s s u n i v e r s i t y p a r k , p e n n s y l va n i a Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Hight, Marc A., 1969– Idea and ontology : an essay in early modern metaphysics of ideas / Marc A. Hight. p. cm. Summary: ‘‘Provides an interpretation of the development of the ontology of ideas from Descartes to Hume that reaffirms the vital role metaphysical concerns played in early modern thinking’’—Provided by publisher. Includes bibliographical references and index. isbn 978–0-271–03383–9 (cloth : alk. paper) 1. Ontology. 2. Idea (Philosophy). 3. Metaphysics. I. Title. BD301.H54 2008 110.9—dc22 2008002466 2008 The Pennsylvania State University All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America Published by The Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park, PA 16802–1003 Copyright The Pennsylvania State University Press is a member of the Association of American University Presses. It is the policy of The Pennsylvania State University Press to use acid-free paper. This book is printed on Natures Natural, containing 50% post-consumer waste, and meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library......

Words: 122775 - Pages: 492

Idea of Essay

...Reflecting on Richard Rodriguez 1. Yes, I do agree that the problems of adaptation for minority immigrants are as difficult as those for Native Americans and African Americans. I believe that once you have grown in a place called home and move to a different place where you do not know the language nor the culture it could be difficult. When you are minor you have no choice but to follow your parents. In my personal experience I moved to this country because my dad is an engineer and he had prepared a better future for my brothers and I, even though I had spent my childhood in Mexico, it was where I wanted to be. Now I call this nation my home since I have lived more years here nevertheless my roots as a Mexican will always be present. 2. The historical connection between Puerto Ricans and Mexican Americans is that they became Americans by default as part of the goods in big time real estate deals or as some of the spoils of the war. I do not believe this is valid since there has always been immigrants who become citizens in different forms. I became a citizen because of my dad’s job I do not believe that every Mexican American or Puerto Ricans have that connection. It would be valid if he gave statistics or a deep research about this connection. 3. Yes it is typical that they could get confused with your identity or your language and I have experienced those comments where they ask where I am from when they hear my accent as I speak. When I am with friends we......

Words: 426 - Pages: 2


...Summary According to the article “Analyze a Subject by Breaking it Down and Building it Back Up”, the author explains that analyzing is to break the subject into small, ideas or detailed parts, and where, by looking closely at those parts you identify the purpose or process of discovery to reach a conclusion of the situation. 2. Critical Thinker In my opinion a critical thinker is a multi-dimensional person involved in the process of analyzing, processing and evaluating information. It is also an attitude that shows the ability to explore, probe, ask and search out answers and solution. 3. “Space Invaders” The method does Stengel uses in his introduction to generate reader interest is narrative ( a short story or anecdote). Furthermore, when i was reading the introduction the author spark my curiosity to continue reading the text. It was interesting to me because this is the way that people live today. Its very common looking around, and detect many space invaders. For example, in elevators, people are wedging themselves in just before the doors close or on the street, pedestrains are zigzagging through the human traffic. In short, the phenomenon of invading personal space has become more serious in the current society and this space varies across individuals according to factors such as culture, age, and gender. 4. According to the author, I understand “personal space” as the area around a person which they prefer not be occupied by another person. It is......

Words: 897 - Pages: 4

Essay on Rand's Ideas

...Essay on Rand’s Ideas Ayn Rand states in her essay that there is an alternative between being either an altruist, who will sacrifice their lives for complete strangers, and being cold egoist who would not lift a finger to help anyone. Ayn developed a theory which known as Objectivism, which means that those that follow that will only pursue their own happiness and will only sacrifice themselves for those they love or hold interest in. She states that just because one is not willing to sacrifice their life for a complete stranger, it does not mean that they are cold and self centered, only that they hold more respect for their own lives or those of the ones they love. Rand’s ideas on Objectivism may not have fit very well in to the moral world we live in today. For example, take our military service member’s, if they were not altruists, who would defend our country in these times of war. If everyone only fended for themselves and for their own happiness, who would join the military. Our service members risk their lives every day, especially during this war on terrorism, they are sacrificing themselves for perfect strangers. If they were not altruistic individuals, how else would our country stay safe. Ayn Rand and her followers believed that the military draft was not right and went against individual rights. In the “In the lecture, “The Wreckage of the Consensus,” Rand specifically argues against withdrawal from Vietnam, calling it an act of “appeasement”: To......

Words: 538 - Pages: 3

Basic Ideas to 40 Mark Essay

...How effective are back bench MP's? The idea that back bencher MP's are'nt effective has been widely debated. A back bencher MP is an Member of Parliament that doesn't have any status in the cabinet office but still can speak freely in Parliament. One reason that back bench MP's are effective is the power of Select Committees. Due to the 2010 reforms, back bencher's were able to be elected as a select committee chairman which enabled them to feel responsible and have status. It also gave them oppotunity to hold government to account. Now select comitties hold high reputation for scrutinizing government as their efforts have been widely recognised. An example of this is in 2012 George Osborne put forward a 'Pasty - Tax' in his annual budget. This would mean taxing all hot baked goods. The Treasury Select Comittie, led by Andrew Tyrie, scrutinised this tax and becasue of that, George Osborne scrapped the inital plan, which shows the effectivness of back bench MP's/ However one reason that select comitties are not effective for backbench MP's is that they do not hold any presitgious powers. Thy=ey cannot dismiss any ministers and they also cannot defy their whip given to them. So because currently 361 conservative MP's there is a higher chance that a Conservative MP will be chairman of a select comittie, therefore there will be less scrutinsing as an MP cannot defy the whip. Another reason back bench MP's are effective is the legasitive function of Parliament. This......

Words: 469 - Pages: 2


...Date: March 14, 2015 Subject: ACL versus IDEA When comparing ACL and IDEA it was hard to choose which was clearly better because they perform such similar tasks. While we think both would be effective at identifying fraud there were a few reasons why we decided that IDEA was the better software. First, ACL simply was not designed as well as IDEA in our eyes. The team member who was assigned to the ACL tutorial had to re-install the program multiple times to “fix” simple errors that should have never arose to begin with. To add to that, it was not very user friendly in general which made it difficult to navigate and look at. ACL was, however, easy to import into Excel due to its inherent similarities with it. On the other hand, the team member who worked with IDEA found the software extremely easy to learn, use and remember and did not run into any problems due to design flaws. It was very easy to import and export from Excel with very simple and easy applications. There was a way to manipulate the data whichever way needed and by the end of the tutorial the team member felt that they were very knowledgeable on the software and felt confident in using it. Although more expensive, we feel it is much more effective and an overall better program. IDEA Tutorial 1. Attached are the 4 random pages from the report. 2. a) Willspo Yip, customer #60300, had the highest balance. b) Andrew Sarabia, customer #20039, had the lowest balance. The median balance in the......

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

Idea of Suce

...Ideas of success can be defined as an individual’s perception of what success really is. Success is a measurable attainment of one’s goals and dreams. Consequently true success is measured by the impact or impression one leaves behind after departure from this earth. A significant contributor to success is time management; which can be defined as how effectively an individual manages their time. Time management plays an integral role in the idea of success as I believe this is the basis on which success emerge. Without effective time management skills, would tasks be able to be completed on time to meet required deadlines? If tasks are unable to be completed then a problem immediately stems which affects the accomplishment of both short term and long term goals thus impeding the attainment of success. Hence, time management is vital and mandatory to developing effective time management skills in order to meet one’s idea of success. There are numerous ideas of success that aids in effective time management skills all of which will be elaborated on throughout this essay they are; pushing oneself to utilize time wisely, mapping out activities and tasks for a week and month and practicing strategies to avoid procrastination. Firstly, providing the adequate push towards utilizing time wisely can contribute towards better time management skills. Often times we get comfortable doing activities that are not related or of contributing factor to our goals, this should not be the case...

Words: 623 - Pages: 3

Buisness Ideas

...101 Small Business Ideas for Under $5,000 Corey Sandler Janice Keefe John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 101 Small Business Ideas for Under $5,000 Corey Sandler Janice Keefe John Wiley & Sons, Inc. This book is printed on acid-free paper. ● ∞ Copyright © 2005 by Word Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey. Published simultaneously in Canada. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 646-8600, or on the web at Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular......

Words: 90587 - Pages: 363

No Idea

...said miserably, "You seen what they done to my dog tonight? They says he wasn't no good to himself nor nobody else. When they can me here I wisht somebody'd shoot me. But they won't do nothing like that. I won't have no place to go, an' I can't get no more jobs. I'll have thirty dollars more comin', time you guys is ready to quit." George stood up. "We'll do her," he said. "We'll fix up that little old place an' we'll go live there." He sat down again. They all sat still, all bemused by the beauty of the thing, each mind was popped into the future when this lovely thing should come about. George said wonderingly, "S'pose they was a carnival or a circus come to town, or a ball game, or any damn thing." Old Candy nodded in appreciation of the idea. "We'd just go to her," George said. "We wouldn't ask nobody if we could. Jus' say, 'We'll go to her,' an' we would. Jus' milk the cow and sling some grain to the chickens an' go to her." "An' put some grass to the rabbits," Lennie broke in. "I wouldn't never forget to feed them. When we gon'ta do it, George?" "In one month. Right squack in one month. Know what I'm gon'ta do? I'm gon'ta write to them old people that owns the place that we'll take it. An' Candy'll send a hunderd dollars to bind her." "Sure will," said Candy. "They got a good stove there?" "Sure, got a nice stove, burns coal or wood." "I'm gonna take my pup," said Lennie. "I bet by Christ he likes it there, by Jesus." Voices were approaching from outside. George said......

Words: 29829 - Pages: 120

Ideas for Structuring Your Essay Response.

...Ideas for structuring your essay response. In your opening paragraph: • Reveal your understanding of the key concepts in the question including how key words such as discuss or describe, frame what you are required to do. Are you being asked to discuss (identify issues and provide points for and/or against), describe (provide characteristics and features) or evaluate ( make a judgement based on criteria or determine the value of)?Ensure you understand the requirements of the key words and their implications for your response. • Acknowledge which area of content you are focusing on. • Outline who the artists/critics/historians are, that you will be writing about. Set the scene in your next paragraph: • Establish your stance or position • Address aspects of the content area in relation to the question. For example if the question relates to an artist practice, provide information about the artists world and experiences that may have contributed to their artmaking practice. The main body of your essay: • Elaborate and develop your position. • Present a well-reasoned and informed point of view. • Refer to artists, craftspeople, designers, architects, art historians or art critics that support your position. • Refer to significant artworks that support the focus requirements of the question • Use quotes to emphasise an important point you are making to support your position. Depending on the requirements of the question, you may include: • How the artworks evolved......

Words: 894 - Pages: 4