Korb Versus Raytheon: the Constitution and Wrongful Termination

In: Business and Management

Submitted By mitchedg1963
Words 2106
Pages 9
Korb Versus Raytheon: The Constitution and Wrongful Termination

Darryl Mitchell

Strayer University

PAD525- Constitutional and Administrative Law

August 13, 2012

Dr. Danette O’Neal

Abstract

This report reviews and analyzes individual rights afforded by the constitution and their applicability to the suit for wrongful termination in the case of Korb versus Raytheon. The specific constitutional rights under review are the freedom of speech, freedom of information and challenges associated with employment law. Lawrence Korb, a former Assistant Secretary of Defense and current employee of Raytheon, a large equipment manufacturing company for the U.S. military was terminated after making public statements criticizing defense spending and calling for a reduction of Navy’s fleet. Raytheon, a manufacturer of Navy ships terminated Korb because they viewed his comments as contrary to the success of their business operations. This report will explore the challenges presented by the freedom of speech, freedom of information and employment law and their impact on the outcome of the case.

Korb v. Raytheon Case Analysis In Korb V. Raytheon, the defendant (Raytheon) was a large equipment manufacturing company for the U.S. military. The Plaintiff, Lawrence Korb was employed by Raytheon as a Vice-President at corporate headquarters based in Washington, D.C. According to Masscases.com, in December 1985, Korb joined a non-profit organization called the Committee for National Security (CNS) in the capacity of an executive board member . Prior to this he was employed as an assistant Secretary of Defense for Manpower with the Department of Defense. In 1986 a press conference held by CNC to release the organization’s annual alternative defense budget, Korb expressed sentiments that criticized defense spending and requested a reduction of…...

Similar Documents

Termination

...| Termination | | One thing that I have been involved with before has been termination. I have found that over the years there have been many situations and many types of people who have had to be let go for so many different reasons. When handling these types of situations it can be of great difficulty to safely and ethically terminate a person without saying or doing something wrong. I would have to say that termination is one of my least favorite things to do simply because I believe strongly in employee development and when I see people go I feel as if I have fail them in some way. Here I will go over some examples of terminations I have experienced that include moral and ethical issues having to do with termination, the relationship between social issues and ethical responsibility, and laws that can cause a manager to make a decision to terminate a person. There are many times when we come to find out that someone we have worked with for quite some time has to be let go and the reason are endless. If an employee is stealing money from the company for example, a cashier, it can be heartbreaking and can conflict with many people’s ethical and moral values. One reason that would stop someone from telling on that person could be anything including fear, friendship, or just the simple wish to stay out of any situations such as that. If the person is a friend it can be extremely difficult to go to someone and say that there is someone stealing however in......

Words: 1059 - Pages: 5

The Developments of 'Wrongful Birth' and 'Wrongful Life' in the Uk and Australia

...This article is published in a peer-reviewed section of the Utrecht Law Review The Use and Influence of Comparative Law in ‘Wrongful Life’ Cases Ivo Giesen* 1. Introduction** 1.1. Comparable stories of great grief In 1993, a South African boy named Brian Stewart was born severely handicapped. He suffers from ‘spina bifida’, a congenital defect to the lower spine, which negatively affects the nerve supply to the lower limbs, bladder and bowel. He suffers from a brain defect as well.1 In 1994, a Dutch girl named Kelly Molenaar was also born severely handicapped. By the time she was two-and-half-years old she was diagnosed as being retarded, autistic, not fully grown, not able to walk or talk, suffering from heart disease, bad hearing and poor eyesight and she was not able, at that time, to recognize her parents. She had been admitted to hospital on nine occasions due to continuous crying, believed to be caused by pain.2 Comparable stories about severely handicapped children can be found in several other countries as well. Both Brian and Kelly were not supposed to have been born in the sense that their mothers would have chosen for an abortion had they known in time about the birth defects their children would suffer. Brian’s mother would have undergone a termination of her pregnancy had the obstetrician and gynaecologist she consulted detected any abnormalities in the foetus and advised her thereof. Kelly’s mother had asked the obstetrician she consulted to carry out......

Words: 18173 - Pages: 73

Employment Termination

...Employment Termination What Every Manager Should Know Introduction Termination is one of the most difficult tasks a manager will have to perform. A manager needs to have a good understand of everything that is involved in an employee exiting the company. This paper is designed to do just that by giving a broad overview of the topic and highlighting the most important parts. By reading this paper a manager should be much more prepared and less likely to commit a mistake during the termination of an employee. The manager should also be able to make the termination a smoother transition and therefore an easier task to complete. Definitions Definitions of some of the important terms are given to give a manager a better understanding of some of the main ideas involved in employment termination. There are basic ideas that go along with each definition to give a better idea of why the term is important to the topic. Termination from Employment Termination from employment occurs when an employee’s job ends. Termination can be voluntary or involuntary. Voluntary Termination Voluntary termination is when an employee voluntarily ends his or her employment at an organization. This would include resignation or retirement. Another common reason for voluntary termination is a new or better job, typically one that offers higher remuneration or improved career prospects [ (Heathfield, Termination) ]. Involuntary Termination Employment can also be involuntary, meaning that the......

Words: 2782 - Pages: 12

Raytheon Case

...information we are given in the case study Raytheon, several points seem illegals. Although the plaintiff and the members of the class were a non-union, Raytheon violated the rights of its employees including: ( Failed to have in place an immutable timekeeping system which allowed the class members to accurately record all the hours they worked. ( Failed to pay the wages for the hours workedin excess of 8 hours per day and 40 hours in a workweek. ( Failed to provide the itemized wages statement ( Failed to tender full payment and/or restitution of wages owed to the employees without valid justification or utility Moreover, Raytheon continued to act intentionnaly, oppressly and maliciously toward plaintiff and class members. At the end, the plaintiff and class members are suffered and will continue to suffer irreparable harms. Due to this points, Raytheon’s action are unfair and lawful business praticess because they deprived them of unvalable rights and benefits guaranteed by law and contract. Also this pratices were deceptives, immorale, unethical, oppresive, unscrupulous, and farudulent and they acted in an illegal attempt to avoid payment of earned wages, overtime compensation and other benefits. 2. Is it right ? Raytheon acted illegaly and gain from their action. It allows them to make profit and gain in comparaison with other companies. ( Because the companie worked against the people employed as a non-union.Moreover, Raytheon cheated them because......

Words: 621 - Pages: 3

Constitutional Rights

...Smith PAD 525 February 23, 2014 Korb v. Raytheon Korb the Vice President at Raytheon, a large corporation that build equipment for the military, was given permission to join by his employer to join the executive board of the Committee for National Security (CNS), a nonprofit organization dedicated to informing the public about issues of national security and the prevention of nuclear war. Remarks made by Korb at a CNS press conference angered military officials. As a direct result of Korb's statements, Raytheon promptly terminated Korb's employment as a lobbyist in Washington, DC. Korb sued Raytheon in a Massachusetts state court for wrongful termination, citing both the Massachusetts state civil rights statute and the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Raytheon removed the case to Federal District Court in Boston. Korb then amended his complaint to delete all references to the U.S. Constitution (Standler, 2000). Korb was hired to be the corporation's spokesperson, and he spoke against the interests of the corporation. The topic was one of acute concern to Raytheon. Regardless of whether Korb believed himself to be acting privately rather than as a Raytheon employee, and regardless of what Korb actually said, the public perception after the press conference was that a Raytheon lobbyist advocated a reduction in defense spending. Raytheon had a financial stake in not advocating that position. Therefore, the court determined that Korb had lost his effectiveness as a......

Words: 1845 - Pages: 8

Should “Wrongful Birth” or “Wrongful Life” Lawsuits Be Allowed?

... Student: Instructor: Class: Date: Should “Wrongful Birth” or “Wrongful Life” Lawsuits be Allowed? Introduction The field of biomedical science has technologically improved to make it possible for medics and the parents of the unborn child to know whether a child will be born with defects or having acquired diseases that are hereditary in nature. Through advancement of technology in the medical field and the legality associated with the practice of abortion, a new class of tort developed in the 1970s. This tort was named as the wrongful birth and wrongful life. As at now, various prenatal tests such as ultra sound and Down syndrome enable early detection of congenital ailments and disorders. This development therefore enables parents to undergo tests that determine if they are carriers of hereditary diseases that may affect the developments of their infants. For example, since the development of medical technology, women who suffered from German measles in their first twenty-eight weeks of their pregnancy were known to bear children with defects. Developments of these medical techniques deduce the likelihood of wrong and incompetent application. For example, if German measles is misdiagnosed and such testing yield false results, prospective parents who are in such a risky situation may not be warned. As such, they might not receive the warranted counseling to undergo such tests. While such negligence occurs, the possibility of giving birth to a defective child is......

Words: 2525 - Pages: 11

Ethical Issues with Termination

...with Termination At-will employment means that the employee or employer has the right "to end the employment relationship at any time with or without notice or cause." (FedEx Office: AllBusiness, 1999-2009) Involuntary termination is a touchy subject for employers and it can happen for numerous reasons: specific cause, such as stealing, poor performance, and layoffs due to lack of work. Even though most companies have an "at-will" relationship with their employees, it is still arguably illegal to terminate an employee for no reason. When it comes to termination, managers are faced with current moral and ethical issues. In a lot of companies, in addition to professional relationships, managers develop personal relationships with their employees. In most cases, employees spend a majority of their week (40+ hours) with their "work family." Co-workers learn about each other's families, extra-curricular activities, and personal problems. Even if managers try to separate themselves from their employees on a personal level, it is difficult to ignore new school pictures being displayed on their desks or avoid a discussion about a recent weekend vacation. When legitimate problems arise in a company which requires involuntary termination, the manager faces a dilemma. They must fire an employee because it is best for the company and ignore the thoughts of how it will affect their family and personal life. Often times, employees take the involuntary termination......

Words: 1329 - Pages: 6

Constitutional Rights

...Administrative Law Dr. Glenn L. Starks May 25, 2014 Abstract Traditionally, freedom of speech has been perceived as a fundamental right guaranteed under our federal constitution to express whatever we please, whenever we please and wherever we please. Nevertheless, we must be aware that some speech may be subjected to restrictions and that not all speech is protected. Moreover, the language of the first amendment specifically mentions the prohibition of state laws against abridging freedom of speech. Similarly, the U.S. Supreme Court has held that the government may limit and regulate its content when duly necessary. Constitutional Rights: Another Angle at Freedom of Speech Although the Supreme Court has historically dedicated efforts into chartering the boundaries of freedom of speech, the ones evolving from the First Amendment, its representational approach is still defective (Blocher, 2014). The free exchange of ideas does not seem to completely pass the test of common sense and keeps opening room for personal misinterpretation and misunderstanding over the privileges and limitations of private speech. First Amendment Special Protections The First Amendment special protections were designed to safeguard freedom of speech from state action, and do not concern itself with private expression. In the case of Korb v. Raytheon, the defendant proposed that a federal question should be raised and therefore motioned to remove the case from state court to a federal court. The U.......

Words: 1976 - Pages: 8

Wrongful

...blamed Legacy’s Center for Maternal-Fetal Medicine in North Portland and a Legacy lab for mistakenly taking a sample of maternal rather than fetal tissue for the test. The suit faults Dr. Thomas Jenkins and lab workers for not recognizing that the tissue was from the mother. The suit also faults Legacy for reassuring Deborah that her baby didn’t have an extra 21st chromosome, even though two ultrasounds allegedly raised red flags by showing traits of Down syndrome. The Levy’s suit requests that Legacy pay for the extra lifetime costs of caring for Kalanit, estimated by one medical expert at $3 million. Experts say such “wrongful birth” cases are extraordinarily rare nationwide because prenatal tests such as CVS are as much as 99.7 percent accurate. And when the tests fail, few parents are willing to endure the scrutiny of a legal challenge. But wrongful birth lawsuits may become more common as technology advances, more women in their late 30s or 40s give birth, and millions of expectant parents come to rely on genetic testing. Several studies show that more than 89 percent of women who learn they will give birth to a child with Down syndrome choose to terminate their pregnancies. The Levy’s say they worry about future medical problems, Kalanit’s ability to interact with others and whether she will receive the extra therapy and attention she will need in school. Kalanit speaks in two-word sentences, and few persons other than her mother and father understand. ......

Words: 688 - Pages: 3

Pad 525

...Lawrence Korb was employed by Raytheon Corporation in the year 1985 as deputy president in charge of Washington operations after having served as an assistant secretary of defense from the year 1981 to 1985. In this capacity, as the head of Raytheon Washington, Korb was accountable for congressional relations and in direct contact with the government departments especially department of Defense. Korb then brought a lawsuit against Raytheon Corporation that his employment contract was terminated wrongfully based on the evidence produced in court that he wrongly exercised his right of speech; however he claimed that his right of speech was protected by the first amendment to the United States constitution as well as article XVI of Massachusetts declaration of rights. Therefore in regard to his complaints of the Raytheon corporation, together with the ruling court, this paper will analyze and evaluate each case by providing , facts about each case, critical issues and the final ruling, besides an analysis and explanation of the challenges with freedom of speech, freedom of information, challenges with employment law; a discussion of the public perceptions of Raytheon and its influence with the Department of Defense and a discussion of any fraud or misrepresentation on either side of the case. According to the facts of the case Korb v. Raytheon, 707 F. Supp. 63 (D. Mass. 1989), Korb became part of the executive board of Raytheon in December 1985. In February 25 1986, during......

Words: 1809 - Pages: 8

Wrongful Discharge Case

...Ice Miller L.L.P. BEFORE: E.A. Gallagher, P.J., E.T. Gallagher, J., and Laster Mays, J. JOURNAL ENTRY AND OPINION EILEEN A. GALLAGHER, PRESIDING JUDGE {¶ 1} Plaintiff-appellant Carrie Rebello appeals from the trial court's judgment entering a directed verdict on her claim for wrongful discharge in violation of public policy against defendants-appellees Lender Processing Services, Inc., et al. (collectively, "LPS").[1] Rebello claims that she was wrongfully terminated in violation of public policy from her employment at LPS because she objected to, and threatened to, report LPS's practice of password sharing among LPS employees when accessing the nonpublic customer information of one of its largest clients, JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. ("Chase"). For the reasons that follow, we reverse the trial court's judgment. Procedural and Factual Background {¶ 2} LPS is in the business of providing processing, technology and field services to clients, including mortgage lenders and financial institutions. The services provided by LPS include inspections, property validation for repairs and services and loss mitigation in connection with defaulted assets. From August 2009 until her termination on April 11, 2012, Rebello was employed by LPS as a supervisor in its property preservation department. She worked in LPS's Solon, Ohio office. Rebello supervised a team of employees who provided field services for properties owned by customers of Chase that were in default......

Words: 9250 - Pages: 37

Contract Termination

...claim for a price increase. Rarely does anything but nonpayment justify termination by a contractor. The greatest risk of the contractor in terminating a contract is that the termination could be determined by a court or arbitration panel to be wrongful. If the termination is proved to be wrongful, then C terminating the contract not only fails to collect its additional funds spent to complete the project, but must also pay A its contract payments through the date of termination and potentially the loss of profit on the work not performed. 2. Termination for convenience clauses are intended to provide the owner with the option to terminate the remaining balance of the contracted for work for a reason other than the contractor’s default. The owner can terminate the balance of the work for convenience as long as there is a termination for convenience clause in the contract. However, if the contract does not contain a termination for convenience clause, and the owner terminates the contract before the work is complete, then the contractor would be entitled to the value of the work completed plus profit that he or she would have earned on the balance of the contract. The subcontractor will be entitled to recover the net benefit conferred on the prime contractor/owner. Also the subcontractor did waive its right to terminate the prime for non-payment as it continued to perform. 3. Typically, a termination for convenience clause states: “Owner may at any time and for any......

Words: 690 - Pages: 3

The Developments of 'Wrongful Birth' and 'Wrongful Life' in the Uk and Australia

...body to be clothed. The law relating to damages is concerned with reparation in money terms and this is what is needed for the maintenance of a baby.’ Peter Pain J (II) Introduction ‘Wrongful Birth’ and ‘Wrongful Life’ are issues caught in a ‘legal quagmire’, as they exist between realms of purist legal principles and heated public policy debate. Much like the social taboos of abortion and euthanasia, at their core, they raise questions as to the value placed on human life. Moreover, this ‘value’ is represented by two sides of the coin in addressing the intangible ‘blessing’ of conception and existence, against the real fiscal burdens involved in adequately raising a child. In recent years several major cases have come before English and Australian courts to address issues in this field; however decisions have been far from unanimous, leaving the law in a state of ambiguity. This paper attempts to provide a line of clarity in respect to the developments of legal principles and public policy on these issues, by closely examining relevant case progression and wider academic debate. (III) Development of the ‘Birth Torts’ Unfortunately, the labels of ‘Wrongful Birth’ and ‘Wrongful Life’ are contentious even in their very existence; however it is critical to establish that ‘what is ‘wrongful’ is the negligence, not the birth’. Both issues refer to cases of medical negligence and as such it is necessary to debunk the clear legal principles from the fraught moral aspects......

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Constitution Right and Challenges

...Constitutional Rights Constitutional Rights and Challenges for Freedom of Information and Speech Folorunso Eddo PAD 525 Constitutions and Administrative Law Professor Richard Freeman May 20, 2012 ABSRACT The First Amendment stated that all American citizens are entitled to the freedom of speech and association. However, the Supreme Court has ruled many times that that right is not completely guarantied. In the work place there are laws that protect us from workplace harassment. There is thin line between freedom of speech and sexual or other forms of harassment. The Freedom of Information Act empowered private citizens and organization to ability to request information from any government agency but sometime there may be a conflict in what the agency would want to allow for the public due to the national security. It is times like this that the Supreme Court is required to be involved. On February 1986, Lawrence Korb the vice president of Washington operation for Raytheon was invited to speak at a Washington policy group on Capitol Hill in Washington D.C. Before then, He was assistant secretary for defense in the Reagan’s administration. In his speech Korb advocated the need for the Reagan Administration to reduce its budget spending in line with the budget and reduce the budget deficit. In his speech, he listed some of the agencies that he believed that could be reduced and what programs. The next......

Words: 1799 - Pages: 8

Raytheon: an International Firm

...Raytheon: An International Firm Raymond C. Branham Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University Managerial Accounting for Decision Making (MBAA 517) Dr. Mark Bellnap December 1, 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract 3 Raytheon: An International Firm 4 Section I 4 Goods and Services, Market Share, Geographic Locations, and Major Competitors 4 Section II 5 Activity Based Costing at Raytheon 5 Section III 8 Standard Costs at Raytheon 8 Section IV 14 Relevant Costs at Raytheon 14 Section V 16 Summary, Conclusion, and Recommendations 16 References 18 Appendix 19 Abstract In today’s hectic economic environment, a company’s financial performance is becoming a highly focused upon part of successfully running a company in America and throughout the World. Equally important, is the ability to address accounting matters in this environment. At Raytheon, it is the task of each function within the company to consider each and every accounting aspect, because their customers are all over the world and each one of those customers approaches financial matters in unique ways. For Raytheon to maintain its success, it is imperative for each employee to understand how to manage these accounting aspects. The lack of accounting knowledge and specifically, each unique accounting approach, and how to execute each approach is why there is a huge problem with finances in corporate America today. Many organizations have altered their approach to this issue, but Raytheon has......

Words: 4451 - Pages: 18