Re-Examining the Cause-and-Effect Principle of the Balanced Scorecard

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ryantengzi
Words 12575
Pages 51
January 2005

Re-examining the cause-and-effect principle of the Balanced Scorecard*
Per Nikolaj Bukh,, Aarhus School of Business Teemu Malmi,, University of Technology, Sydney & Helsinki School of Economics

Abstract There seems to be a wide variety of methods in how organizations apply the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) concept in practice and how it is interpreted in the literature. Consequently, it is not quite clear what the core features of BSC, or its variants, are and if all its variants are equally effective in producing expected outcomes. Moreover, the usefulness of BSC as a practical theory has been questioned by referring to some of its assumptions, especially the cause-and-effect relationship (Norreklit, 2000, 2003). In this paper we re-examine the cause-and-effect principle, which can be seen as one of the corner-stones of the BSC. Further, we outline alternative ways to apply cause-and-effect in practice, both analytically and organizationally. To facilitate research on BSC, we discuss some of the contingencies that may limit or support the usefulness of the causeand-effect concept. These include strategy, organization, environment and communication related issues. Key Words: Balanced scorecard, cause-and-effect, non-financial measurement, performance management, strategy, strategy map.

* We wish to thank the editors, Sten Jönsson and Jan Mouritsen, for their guidance in the process of writing the paper. Further, we thank Fredrik Nilsson and Nils-Göran Olve for their encouraging and helpful comments. All remaining errors are of course the responsibility of the authors. The authors are listed in alphabetic order.

1 Introduction
Since the mid 1980’s accounting has attempted to turn strategic. In the area of strategically oriented performance measurement Balanced Scorecard (BSC) has been one of the most debated…...

Similar Documents

Balanced Scorecard

...Volume 17, Number 1, July Anand, Manoj, B. S. Sahay and Subhashish Saha (2005): Balanced Scorecard in Indian Companies, Vikalpa, Volume 30, Number 2, April – June. Batra, R. (2006): The Balanced Scorecard: An Indian Perspective, ICFAI Journal of Management Research, Volume 5, Number 8. Baldwin, C and Clark, K (1992). “Capabilities and Capital Investment: New Perspectives on Capital Budgeting,” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 5(2), 67-82. Emmanuel, C and Otley, D (1995). Readings in Accountingfor Management Control, London: Chapman and Hall. Ittner, C.D., Larcker, D.F., 1998. Innovations in performance measurement: trends and research implications. J. Manage. Acc. Res. 10, 205–239. Jeans, M and Morrow, M (1990). “Performance Measurement in the UK Industry,” Journal of Cost Management for the Manufacturing Industry, 3(1), 51-54. Joshi, P L (2001). “The International Diffusion of New Management Accounting Practices: The Case of India,” Journal of International Accounting, Auditing, and Taxation, 10(1), 85-109. Kaplan, Robert S and Norton, David P (1992). “The Balanced Scorecard: Measures that drive Performance,” Harvard Business Review, 70(1), January-February, 71-79. Kaplan, Robert S and Norton, David P (1996a). The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action, Boston: Harvard Business School Press. Kaplan, Robert S and Norton, David P (1996b). “Using the Balanced Scorecard as a Strategic Management System,” Harvard Business Review, 74(1),......

Words: 307 - Pages: 2

Balanced Scorecard According to the Balanced Scorecard Collaborative, there are four barriers to strategic implementation: 1. Vision Barrier – No one in the organization understands the strategies of the organization. 2. People Barrier – Most people have objectives that are not linked to the strategy of the organization. 3. Resource Barrier – Time, energy, and money are not allocated to those things that are critical to the organization. For example, budgets are not linked to strategy, resulting in wasted resources. 4. Management Barrier – Management spends too little time on strategy and too much time on short-term tactical decision-making. Only 5% of the workforce understands their company strategy. Only 25% of managers have incentives linked to strategy. 60% of organizations don’t link budgets to strategy. 86% of executive teams spend less than one hour per month discussing strategy. – Balanced Scorecard Collaborative Therefore, we need a new way of communicating strategy to the end-user. Enter the Balanced Scorecard. At long last, strategic planners now have a crisp and clear way of communicating strategy. With balanced scorecards, strategy reaches everyone in a language that makes sense. When strategy is expressed in terms of measurements and targets, the employee can relate to what must happen. This leads to much better execution of strategy. Not only does the Balanced Scorecard transform how the......

Words: 650 - Pages: 3

Balanced Scorecard

... A Balanced Scorecard for Small Business C. W. Von Bergen Southeastern Oklahoma State University Management and Marketing Department Durant, OK 74701-0609 Phone: 580-745-2430; Fax: 580-745-7485; e-mail: Daniel C. Benco Southeastern Oklahoma State University Department of Accounting and Finance Durant, OK 74701-0609 Phone: 580-745-2498; Fax: 580-745-7485; e-mail: Abstract The balanced scorecard is a performance management system that enables businesses to drive strategies based on measurement and follow-up. Since the early 1990s the balanced scorecard has been applied in numerous large organizations resulting in many positive results that have been chronicled in the management literature. However, there are few studies addressing the use of a balanced scorecard within small companies. Hence, this paper presents a discussion of the key elements of the balanced scorecard and its applicability to small business. Executive Summary The balanced scorecard (BSC) approach helps organizations manage the implementation of their strategies. The BSC measures an organization’s performance from four key perspectives: financial, customer, internal business processes, and learning and growth. The BSC approach logically links these four perspectives. Improvements in employee learning and growth result in improved internal business processes, which create better products and services and, therefore, higher customer satisfaction and higher...

Words: 4975 - Pages: 20

Balanced Scorecard

...A Dissertation Report On “Putting HR on Balanced Scorecard” (A Case Study of Verizon) (SUBMITTED TOWARDS PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF POST GRADUATE DIPLOMA IN MANAGEMENT) (Approved by AICTE, Govt. of India) ACADEMIC SESSION (2008-10) Under the guidance of: Submitted by: Supervisor Name Your Name Lecturer (college name) Roll: - PGDM-08/012 College Address PREFACE There is a famous saying “The theory without practical is lame and practical without theory is blind.” Alignment of the Human Resource with the overall strategy of the company is a very big and toughest challenge for the company. Human resource is an important part of any business and managing them is an important task. Our institution has come forward with the opportunity to bridge the gap by imparting modern scientific management principle underlying the concept of the future prospective managers. To the emphasis on practical aspect of management education the faculty of College Name has with a modern system of practical training of repute and following management technique to the student as integral part of PGDM. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT “It is not possible to prepare a project report without the assistance & encouragement of other people. This one is certainly no exception.” On the very outset of this report, I would like to extend my sincere & heartfelt obligation towards all the......

Words: 17507 - Pages: 71

Balanced Scorecard

...Implementing a Sustainability Balanced Scorecard „Dashboard‟ Approach to Assess Organisational Legitimacy. Kevin Huang, University of Wollongong, Wollongong, New South Wale Matthew Pepper, University of Wollongong, Wollongong, New South Wale Graham Bowrey, University of Wollongong, Wollongong, New South Wales Abstract Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to identify and determine the contributing factors which influence the contents of a firm‟s sustainability reporting through combined social and environmental accounting and management perspectives. Design/methodology/approach: This paper analyzes the disclosed sustainability indicators of a major Australian financial institution, Westpac, through the application of the research method content analysis. The theoretical framework will be shaped by the consideration of legitimacy theory and the Balanced Scorecard approach. Findings: The results indicate that the four perspectives of a traditional Balanced Scorecard are related to the main sources of influential inputs to Westpac‟s sustainability reporting – existing frameworks, stakeholder engagement mechanism, employee involvement and traditional shareholders‟ financial information needs. It also reinforced the argument that the focus of organisational legitimacy is a key resource of organisation survival. Originality/value: This research contributes to the literature on social and environmental disclosures including the research of Do, Tilt and......

Words: 9462 - Pages: 38

Balanced Scorecard

...Executive Summary According to Bento, “the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) has been proposed as an integrated framework for the implementation of financial and nonfinancial performance measures that helps organizations align their initiatives with the organization’s strategy” (2013). The Balanced Scorecard offers management a system to use in plotting strategic objectives through four perspectives. The financial perspective is determined by the outcome of management’s implementation of the internal processes perspective, customer perspective, and learning and growth perspective. Aon Corporation is the “leading provider of risk management, insurance and reinsurance brokerage” (Aon, 2014). Using the Balanced Scorecard my operating segment, Benefit Marketing Solutions, can examine an implement each of the four perspectives by obtaining information on how we can achieve Aon standards in the operation of our business segment. Implementing the Balanced Scorecard, I will assess how our financials can improve by achieving the objectives of maximizing company profits, increasing our gross profit margin per client, and decreasing our accounts payable days. The first factor I will investigate is our customer perspective and how increasing customer loyalty, customer exposure, and customer education will improve upon our financials. The second factor I will investigate is the internal perspective and how effective company alliances, effective customer service, and effective payment of...

Words: 2028 - Pages: 9

Balanced Scorecard

...Sat&Company JSC b. Eurasian Bank c. Alfa-bank SB JSC d. TetraPack 3. Conclusion 4. References The organizations mentioned by the creators of Balanced Scorecard are from the future - only because they have a system that allows to create actual numerical results from the strategic initiatives and to turn a strategy into action Philip H. Knight, CEO and founder of Nike Introduction Balanced Scorecard (BSC) is one of the current world's top-ten effective strategic performance management tools. BSC is a system of measuring the effectiveness of the entire company, based on a vision and strategy that reflects the most important aspects of the business. It supports strategic planning, implementation, and further adjustments to the strategy by combining the efforts of all departments. It was first introduced in 1990s and became a very popular worldwide. Despite this popularity, little is known about which organizations use Balanced Scorecard, what they use it for, and how useful it is in practice. BSC implementation in Kazakhstan is under a big concern of local top managers. In this report we are trying to answer the practical questions of BSC’s usage by Kazakhstani companies, its limitations as well as opportunities for its successful maintenance in Kazakhstan. Benefits and limitations of Balanced Scorecard Throughout the report we will pay attention to the BSC’s benefits and the opportunities it bring to the companies. In fact, the BSC approach makes......

Words: 6301 - Pages: 26

Balanced Scorecard

...BALANCED SCORECARD APPLICATION IN LENDING/MICROFINANCING INSTITUTIONS: A STRATEGIC MAP IMPLEMENTATION IN THE PHILIPPINES CONTEXT This paper studies the application of Balanced Scorecard (BSC) as a powerful measurement and assessment system, in lending/micro financing institutions. Adopting the balanced scorecard (BSC) model, this exploratory study investigates the critical performance measures that lending/micro-financing institutions in the Philippines need to emphasize in their performance reporting to drive high performance. The proposed model can assist the lending institutions in assessing organizational performance, making it highly applicable for managers. Reviewing the existing literature, the paper also provides an implementation guide for BSC in the Philippines perspective. Eventually, the performance indicators for measurement purposes of the introduced case study are proposed. Keywords: Lending/ Micro financing Institutions, MFIs, Financial Services, Balanced Scorecard, BSC, Organizational Performance Assessment, performance reporting, Philippines. 1. Introduction In many developing countries, microfinance plays a vital role in providing the poor (i.e. micro-entrepreneurs, small farmers, fishermen) with access to credit and helping them improve their lives by encouraging entrepreneurial activity (Arch, 2005; Bhatt & Tang, 2011; Khandker, 1996; Llanto, 2004). It has also proven to be “a potent tool for poverty reduction by helping the......

Words: 4203 - Pages: 17

Balanced Scorecard

...Balanced Scorecard Key Concept Explanation The balanced scorecard, first introduced by Harvard business professor Robert Kaplan and business consultant David Norton, is a performance measurement system (Peters, 2014). In the early 90s, as the concept of the balanced scorecard was introduced, companies largely used financial standards to measure performance. The financial evaluations were highly focused and lacked an evaluation of strategic objective (Janes, 2014). The balanced scorecard provides performance measurement that includes four main perspectives including financial, customer, internal business processes and learning and growth. Key performance indicators (KPIs) are chosen for each section based upon strategic objectives. Once established the KPIs can be laid out into a strategy map that creates an easy visual aid. The strategy maps allows for easy dissemination from management to employees with clear understanding. In determining the KPIs, the objective is to look at the strategy at hand and determine the causal relationship, answering the “if” and “then” questions (Janes, 2014). The cause and effect relationship is advantageous due to its ability to allow qualitative questions to be determined. The balanced scorecard is a commonly accepted performance measurement tool. The evaluation of performance can often be a difficult task. Particularly in the non-profit sector where the financial outlook may not paint a full picture, a balanced scorecard can......

Words: 1958 - Pages: 8

Balanced Scorecard

...Name: Course number: Professor’s name: Date: Balanced Scorecard The use of the balanced scorecard (BSC) is quite common management tool for most organizations. Some organizations has found certain drawbacks that have made them not to adopt this management tool. The use of this instrument requires proper training and understanding of it thus making it time-consuming. The process of using it also requires accuracy as any slight mistake leads to undesired results. Due to the complexities of this management tool, many employees do not favor its implementation and may cause resistance. The most notable factor that drives away most organizations from using this tool is the high costs involved (Kathy & McKay, 2013). It requires higher costs to install as well as other maintenance costs. However, despite these costs, it is important for organizations to adopt this management tool due to its unmatched benefits. It offers instant results on the balanced view of a company’s performance something that is not achievable by any other method. The use of sensitivity analysis is very crucial during capital budgeting for a project. The sensitivity analysis helps in relaying the scenarios that will occur in case the assumptions made during the capital budgeting process do not materialize. Managers can determine the extent of the effects that might occur if a project does not deliver. It makes sensitivity analysis a very crucial process during any capital budgeting process. It helps in......

Words: 337 - Pages: 2

Balanced Scorecard

...WHAT IS A BALANCED SCORECARD? According to Robert Kaplan and David Norton, the founders of the Balanced Scorecard, "The balanced scorecard retains traditional financial measures. But financial measures tell the story of past events, an adequate story for industrial age companies for which investments in long-term capabilities and customer relationships were not critical for success. These financial measures are inadequate, however, for guiding and evaluating the journey that information age companies must make to create future value through investment in customers, suppliers, employees, processes, technology, and innovation. (4)" In essence, the Balanced Scorecard is a performance management system used in multitude of organizations throughout the world. It is used to develop an organization’s goals and mission that will enhance the success it has with its customers and employees. HISTORY Although first developed in the early 1990’s by Robert Kaplan and David Norton of the Harvard Business School and coined “Balanced Scorecard” in the early 1990’s, Kaplan and Norton’s method originally stemmed from the pioneering work of General Electric on performance measurement reporting in the 1950’s and the dashboard performance measures from French process engineers in the early 20th century (4) The idea behind this performance measurement tool developed from the fact that traditional performance measurement systems, mostly financial performance indicators, were insufficient......

Words: 1589 - Pages: 7

Using Balanced Scorecards

...Communications of the Association for Information Systems Volume 17 Article 8 2-23-2006 Using the Balanced Scorecard to Achieve Sustained IT-Business Alignment: A Case Study Qing Hu Florida Atlantic University, qhu@fau C. Derrick Huang Florida Atlantic University, dhuang@fau Follow this and additional works at: Recommended Citation Hu, Qing and Huang, C. Derrick (2006) "Using the Balanced Scorecard to Achieve Sustained IT-Business Alignment: A Case Study," Communications of the Association for Information Systems: Vol. 17, Article 8. Available at: This material is brought to you by the Journals at AIS Electronic Library (AISeL). It has been accepted for inclusion in Communications of the Association for Information Systems by an authorized administrator of AIS Electronic Library (AISeL). For more information, please contact Communications of the Association for Information Systems (Volume 17 2006) 181- 204 181 USING THE BALANCED SCORECARD TO ACHIEVE SUSTAINED IT-BUSINESS ALIGNMENT: A CASE STUDY Qing Hu C. Derrick Huang Department of Information Technology & Operations Management Florida Atlantic University ABSTRACT High levels of investments in IT and related products and services by firms over the last several decades produced only mixed results. Research shows that one of the most significant determinants of successful IT......

Words: 12986 - Pages: 52

Balanced Scorecard

...Balanced Scorecard The BSC is a planning & management system which can be widely applied to organizations and companies regardless of size or type of business. The technique, extensively used in business and industry, government, and non-profit organizations worldwide, provides a method of aligning business activities to the vision & strategy of the organization, integrating internal & external communications, & keeping a watch on organization performance against strategic goals. It was developed by Robert Kaplan and David Norton of Harvard University in 1990. The line of the balanced scorecard runs deep, and include the revolutionary and path breaking work of General Electric on performance measurement coverage in the late 1950’s and the work of French engineers in the early part of the 20th century in France. Due to the fact that balanced scorecard term is a generic, it is interpreted differently by different people, and in practice, there are wide variations in both understanding and implementation. To some, the balanced scorecard is just a simple control panel indicating performance measures, while to others it is a inclusive planning and management system encompassing the whole organization and planned to focus efforts on business strategy and more significantly on performance and results. The balanced scorecard has steadily developed from its early use as a simple performance measurement framework for non-financial performance measures to a full strategic planning......

Words: 2310 - Pages: 10

Balanced Scorecard

...The Balanced Scorecard - Measures that Drive Performance Robert Kaplan and David Norton Harvard Business Review OnPoint 2000 Jennifer Oberly Oklahoma Wesleyan University Advanced Managerial Accounting BUSI 5243 Bill Elliott October 04, 2011 The Balanced Scorecard - Measures that Drive Performance The purpose of this article was to look at what information companies are using to rate themselves and determine what areas need improvement. This article focuses on the concept that companies should be taking in a number of factors when determining how they are doing in a market. The authors set to show how using more than just financial information is vital to obtaining the complete picture of how a company is performing. They feel that using four to five key areas provides more accurate information and can show how improvement in one area could be at the cost of another area. The authors spent over a year looking in depth at twelve companies and implementing their balanced scorecard to show that by using a wider array of data elements can provide a better overall evaluation of a companies performance. The target audience for this article is any business or company that is looking to improve their performance. The authors focus on one company and show how applying their balanced scorecard method can help a company plan...

Words: 982 - Pages: 4

Balanced Scorecard

... Analysis The Balanced Scorecard (BSC) was an idea that was developed in the early nineties by Kaplan and Norton as an approach towards performance evaluation. The scorecard has four perspectives; the financial perspective, the customer perspective, the internal business processes perspective and the learning, growth and innovation perspective. The financial aspect requires that for an organization to succeed financially there is need to improve on the shareholder value, realize return on capital and also to utilize efficiently the available assets. The Zoogle Company benefitted financially because they registered improved market share value in the stock exchange for three consecutive years after inception of the scorecard. The customer perspective tends to answer the question,’ to realize our vision, how should we present to our customers?’ This would be through ensuring better products and services for customer satisfaction, enabling good customer relationships and making sure the company reputation is jealously protected. Zoogle noted some improved customer interest in their software business through a customer feedback program. Some even suggested what they would prefer to continue getting and what should be changed. This obviously impacted positively on the company’s revenue. The internal business processes perspective tends to identify the processes that can be altered so that both the shareholders and the customers are impressed. This would be......

Words: 1657 - Pages: 7