Scenario Analysis

In: Social Issues

Submitted By Brytneim
Words 466
Pages 2
Scenario Analysis

Lon L. Fuller, former Carter Professor of Jurisprudence at Harvard Law School, observed in The Morality of Law, “Even if a man is answerable only to his conscience, he will answer more responsibly if he is compelled to articulate principles on which he acts.”

Source: Lon L. Fuller. (1975). The Morality of Law. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. (p. 159)


In this Assignment you are required to apply Fuller’s Principle, as cited above, and respond to three real-life scenarios regarding ethical decision making within the field of criminal justice and policing.

In considering each of the three scenarios, you are asked to respond to the following four questions:

Is there a moral problem presented in the scenario? If so, what is it?

Does policy or law dictate an appropriate response, or does it require that professional discretion be applied?

What criteria (considerations), principles, and consequences should guide your decision?

What would you do? Articulate, justify, and defend your position.

First, read each scenario. Second, analyze the ethical dilemma within the context of the four questions specified above. Third, respond in writing to the each of the four questions.

The entire paper should be 2 – 4 pages in length. Each essay response should be brief, not more than one page. You may use references to support your responses, but the essay responses must be original.

Scenario 1 - Drugs at a Friend’s House

You are an off-duty police officer at a party at the house of an old high school friend. Everyone is still in the backyard drinking. You go into the house to use the restroom and observe several of your friend’s friends (whom you do not know) snorting cocaine. You do not know whether or not your friend has knowledge that people are using drugs in his house.

Scenario 2 -…...

Similar Documents

Scenario Analysis

...Porche Hamilton BSHS 321 Human Service Scenario Analysis Instructor: Julie Murphy ABSTRACT This analysis gives in detail the background, including age and gender of the patient in the evaluation. The details are that the treatment plan must be a clear and concise method to help the patient cope with her significant events. The underlying treatment and diagnosis for this patient are confirmed and may be requested for further treatment and examination. Diagnosis at this time is Major Depressive Disorder, Axis-IV as so stated in DSM-IV. Jennifer Diggs is a twenty six year old African American female soldier. She was raised in a single parent house hold along with her three siblings. Her parents divorced when she was about twelve years old. Jennifer was always pushed around as a child because she was the youngest daughter. She rarely got to go outside during the summer because she has chronic asthma. Her mother is an LPN at a nursing home and her father is a retired Army Veteran and he now lives in Jacksonville, Florida. She has a younger sister that lives with her father and step mother. She used to spend her summers and holidays with her father and step-mother.Her father would take her to Six Flags during her summer breaks and to Disney Land. She has three children, all whom are school age. Jennifer was married, but she is now divorced and is taking on full responsibility of her three children with the absence of their father. Prior to joining the U.S. Army, she had...

Words: 977 - Pages: 4

Analysis of Scenarios Relating to Workplace Professionalism

...Part A Issues in the workplace affecting staff behavior and patient care Radiographers bear a great deal of responsibility in supporting the forward progression of the field and maintaining the high standards expected by the professional bodies and by the public. The scenario given presents different situations that radiographers and radiography students may face in the workplace; the main issues are professionalism, continuing professional development and bullying at work. All these in turn have an effect on the level of patient care staff provide since staff attitudes and team-working do influence this. A profession can be described as ‘A vocation...esp. one requiring advanced knowledge or training’ (p2386, Brown, 1993, vol 2), linked to this is the definition of professionalism which is ‘The body of qualities or features, as competence, skill, etc., characteristic of a profession or professional’ (p2368, Brown, 1993, vol 2). There are instances within the scenario in which each character does not adhere to the Code of Conduct and Ethics presented by the Society and College of Radiographers (SCoR; SCoR, 2008). SCoR states that you should engage in the teaching and training of other members of staff, however both Rob and Asha fail to support staff within their team: Asha fails to support Rob, and Rob in turn fails to support the radiography student. SCoR specifically states that radiographers should develop the skills to be a good teacher and trainer which neither......

Words: 1411 - Pages: 6

Scenario Analysis

...1 PROBABILISTIC APPROACHES: SCENARIO ANALYSIS, DECISION TREES AND SIMULATIONS In the last chapter, we examined ways in which we can adjust the value of a risky asset for its risk. Notwithstanding their popularity, all of the approaches share a common theme. The riskiness of an asset is encapsulated in one number – a higher discount rate, lower cash flows or a discount to the value – and the computation almost always requires us to make assumptions (often unrealistic) about the nature of risk. In this chapter, we consider a different and potentially more informative way of assessing and presenting the risk in an investment. Rather than compute an expected value for an asset that that tries to reflect the different possible outcomes, we could provide information on what the value of the asset will be under each outcome or at least a subset of outcomes. We will begin this section by looking at the simplest version which is an analysis of an asset’s value under three scenarios – a best case, most likely case and worse case – and then extend the discussion to look at scenario analysis more generally. We will move on to examine the use of decision trees, a more complete approach to dealing with discrete risk. We will close the chapter by evaluating Monte Carlo simulations, the most complete approach of assessing risk across the spectrum. Scenario Analysis The expected cash flows that we use to value risky assets can be estimated in one or two ways. They can represent a......

Words: 17404 - Pages: 70

Finance Scenario Analysis and Treasury bill percentage returns between 2006 and 2010: Year Stock market return T-bill return 2006 17.27 6.3 10.97 7.1040 50 2007 7.41 6.06 1.35 -2.5160 6.33 2008 -38.83 1.8 -40.63 -44.4960 1980 2009 29.7 0.9 28.8 24.9340 622 2010 19.36 0.52 18.84 14.9740 224 2883 a. What was the risk premium on common stock in each year? Year Risk Premium 2006 10.97 2007 1.35 2008 -40.63 2009 28.80 2010 18.84 19.33 3.866 b. What was the average risk premium? Number of year 5 Avg risk prem 3.87 c. What was the standard deviation of the risk premium? 576.523224 24.01 Consider the following scenario analysis: Rate of return Scenario Probability Stock (X) Bonds (y) (p1*x) (p1*y) Standard Dev 0.00299822 Recession 0.2 -8% 16% -2% 3.20% 5% Count 3 Normal Economy 0.5 19% 9% 0.095 0.045 Var of return stock 0.014364 Boom 0.3 25% 6% 0.075 0.018 Var of return bonds 0.001225 a. Is it reasonable to assume that Treasury bonds will provide higher returns in recessions than in booms? Yes b. Expected rate of return stanard deviation Stock 15.40% 12% 0.054756 0.004225 Bonds 9.50% 3.50% 0.001296 0.000025 0.009216 0.001225 c. Stocks have both higher expected return and higher volatility. More risk-averse investors will......

Words: 464 - Pages: 2

Scenario Analysis Report

...CS25110 Mid Wales University Scenario Analysis Report – Recommendations for University ICT Strategy Written by Findlay Cruden Contents 1. Introduction 3 2. Custom Designed Server Room 3 3. Project Management 4 4. Computer Hardware 5 5. Computer Software 6 6. Security 7 7. Naming and Directory Services 8 8. Business Continuity 9 9. On-going Management 10 10. Overall Summary 11 11. Bibliography 12 1. Introduction The main focus of this report is to detail the necessary resources and preparations that would be necessary in order to create and manage the ICT systems for this University. By using information from outside sources, I will make observations as to the various aspects that will be necessary to create and manage our network in an efficient and efficient manner and in a way that allows the ease of use to the various users who will be using the network and its resources. These resources would include both the hardware that would be running and managing the network such as the mail and web servers in addition to the hardware that the users will be interacting with such as the desktop computers, printers amongst others. 2. Custom Designed Server Room As this room would function as the nerve centre for the entirety of our network, stringent security measures should be implemented to protect the room itself as well as the equipment stored within it. As detailed both in a further section of this report a high priority......

Words: 5666 - Pages: 23

Classroom Scenario Analysis

...Classroom Scenario Analysis Rachel Hammer ELL240: Linguistically & Culturally Diverse Learners (ACV1340A) Instructor: Jessica Vargas November 4, 2013 In today’s classrooms, throughout America, there are a number of students who speak another language other than English. In fact, a majority of our classrooms consists primarily of English language learner students. For these students, interacting and participating in daily tasks, socially and academically, can at times be challenging. This added pressure and stress can wreak havoc for ELLs and can result in feelings of not belonging or loss of identity, their culture, family, or friends. They may also feel they lack the ability to fully express themselves through their native language. As teachers we need to take extra time and effort to understand that these students originate from diverse backgrounds, and some ELL students will have the learning skills that will enable them to pick up the English language at a more rapid pace than others. The reason for this seldom coincides with the student’s intelligence or motivation levels. Instead, we need to consider all the various learning strategies that can potentially help shape ELLs in becoming more confident in learning and speaking English. Throughout this assignment, I will thoroughly identify the different strategies that are presented throughout the classroom scenario, explain whether or not they are effective, describe how instructional input and scaffolding are......

Words: 2751 - Pages: 12

Analysis 1.1 Windows 7 Edition Scenario

...WINDOWS 7 EDITION SCENARIO: ANALYSIS 1.1 As a private computer consultant I recommend the Windows 7 Enterprise edition. The Enterprise edition will provide productivity anywhere plus it will enhance the security and streamline PC management. This edition has the flexibility to work with 35 languages and has everything Windows 7 has to offer. This company may grow in the future and this operating system will let them expand with ease. In addition to the above mentioned features, the Enterprise edition also includes the following: • BitLocker and BitLocker To Go drive encryption and data protection on internal and external drives and storage devices. • DirectAccess, which helps give you a more secure connection to your corporate network over the Internet. • BranchCache, which helps provide faster access to content from remote file and Web servers at branch locations. • AppLocker, which helps prevent unauthorized software from running on workers’ PCs. • Search Scopes, which make it easy to discover and search content on intranet portals. Because the warehouse computers are sluggish there may be hardware issues, viruses, or lack of memory. I recommend to perform an inventory of all computers and upgrade hardware as necessary which may include purchasing new computers for the warehouse and for the main offices. If the computers are upgradeable by using the Upgrade Advisor......

Words: 284 - Pages: 2

Learning Potential Scenario Analysis

...Name: Danielle Sussman Student Number: 42852471 ECH113 Early Childhood Play and Inquiry Assignment 5: Learning Potential Scenario Analysis Play is linked to the intellectual development of children (Degotardi, 2014a). It provides an active construction of understanding in a variety of areas, nurturing creative, academic and social dispositions from its beginnings in the life of a child (Myck-Wayne, 2010, pp. 3). Play exists in many forms, and is assessed by a number of measures. The play scenario between four-year-olds Sophie, Isaac and Matthew will be examined in light of their narrative development and social play. An understanding of the importance of narrative development and the complexity of social play in early childhood will unmask the centrality of play in nurturing children’s cognitive and emotional development. It will also provide an insight into the potential methods for adult support and enhancement in play to maximize its benefits in early childhood. Narrative development in early childhood play is a result of creative thought and expression. Narrative development is rooted in symbolic thought, which refers to representational thinking (Degotardi, 2014a). Symbolic thought is a construct of abstraction, whereby something is transformed in the child’s mind into something else, creating meaning beyond its original context (Van Hoorn, Nourot, Scales, & Alward, 2013, pp. 213). Sophie and Isaac’s symbolic play begins by......

Words: 1913 - Pages: 8

It205 Smart Scenario – Clarifying Business Strategy Through Database Analysis

...IT205 Smart Scenario – Clarifying Business Strategy Through Database Analysis Get Tutorial by Clicking on the link below or Copy Paste Link in Your Browser For More Courses and Exams use this form ( ) Feel Free to Search your Class through Our Product Categories or From Our Search Bar ( ) TO DOWNLOAD COMPLETE TUTORIAL HIT PURCHASE BUTTON IT205 Smart Scenario – Clarifying Business Strategy Through Database Analysis Get Tutorial by Clicking on the link below or Copy Paste Link in Your Browser For More Courses and Exams use this form ( ) Feel Free to Search your Class through Our Product Categories or From Our Search Bar ( ) TO DOWNLOAD COMPLETE TUTORIAL HIT PURCHASE BUTTON IT205 Smart Scenario – Clarifying Business Strategy Through Database Analysis Get Tutorial by Clicking on the link below or Copy Paste Link in Your Browser For More Courses and Exams use this form ( ) Feel Free to Search your Class through Our Product Categories or From Our Search......

Words: 1596 - Pages: 7

Scenario Analysis

...Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt ut labore et dolore magna aliquyam erat, sed diam voluptua. At vero eos et accusam et justo duo dolores et ea rebum. Stet clita kasd gubergren, no sea takimata sanctus est Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet. Duis autem vel eum iriure dolor in hendrerit in vulputate velit esse molestie consequat, vel illum dolore eu feugiat nulla facilisis at vero eros et accumsan et iusto odio dignissim qui blandit praesent luptatum zzril delenit augue duis dolore te feugait nulla facilisi. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit, sed diam nonummy nibh euismod tincidunt ut laoreet dolore magna aliquam erat volutpat. Ut wisi enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exerci tation ullamcorper suscipit lobortis nisl ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis autem vel eum iriure dolor in hendrerit in......

Words: 2935 - Pages: 12

Cost Scenario Analysis

...Introduction This is a case of outsourcing where contribution analysis is carried out. Outsourcing is the ordering of goods or labour from the outside the vendors manufacturing plant. In this case the company is intending to outsource the production of 30,000 Alpha Phones from Original Equipment Manufacturers rather then producing in-house. Apart from the quantitative analysis’s qualitative factors will also be considered as necessary (Horngren, Datar and foster, 2003 p. 378). Alternative solution From the given information about Clear Hear, the following alterative solutions to meet the end state goals resulted; 1. To make 70,000 and switch production of 30,000 units from Beta model to Alpha. 2. To make 70,000 and purchase 30,000 units from Original equipment manufacturers 3. Outsourcing all the 100,000 units. Analyzing and evaluating the above alternative i) To make 70,000 and switch production of 30,000 units from Beta model to Alpha: - In this case the manager will use the excess capacity (idle capacity) of 70,000 and switch production of Alpha. To produce the product, only the variable overheads will change but the fixed overheads will remain the same. This is because the expected variable costs will vary with the number of unities produced and the idle capacity available for use will make the fixed costs not to change (Goldratt and Cox 2004, P. 60-61). Therefore the manager can only choose to produce the product if the cost of producing is less than......

Words: 889 - Pages: 4

Cj 499-01 Unit 3 Crime Scenario Analysis

...Unit Three Assignment James Norris Kaplan University CJ499-01 Professor Johnson January 26, 2016 Scenario: Police Officer Jones, in full uniform, was walking the midnight shift in a high-crime area at approximately 2:00 AM and is approached by a civilian who told Officer Jones she had been robbed and beaten by someone wearing a red shirt and white pants. The victim’s shirt was blood soaked from a severe laceration to her head and lip. She said the perpetrator was wearing a ski mask so she was unable to determine the gender/sex of the individual, as well as the race/ethnicity. However, she was able to inform Officer Jones that the perpetrator was approximately 5’8” tall and had a gun. The perpetrator stole her wallet and was holding it when he/she fled the scene, which was only a minute or two earlier. Officer Jones called for medical assistance and for backup as well. While waiting with the victim for medical personnel to arrive, Officer Jones spotted an individual that partially fit the description about a block away from the scene. Though it was very dark, Officer Jones observed the white pants and dark shirt. Officer Jones walked toward the individual, leaving the victim unattended. Medical and backup had not arrived. When Officer Jones was approximately 20 feet away, he identified himself as a police officer and told him in a loud, clear voice, “Stop, Police! However, the individual refused to comply with Officer Jones’s commands and continued to walk away......

Words: 1727 - Pages: 7

Brand and Product Management Scenario Analysis

...Brand and Product Management Scenario Analysis paper Kenneth Proctor BRM/353 February 8, 2016 Michael Ricco Brand and Product Management Scenario Analysis The marketed Brand which I have chosen is Apple and the way in which they are marketed in different countries is more of a one size fits all or standardized approach, this is something Apple uses both domestically and internationally. When apple brings out new devices, they do not customize their phone in terms of features and looks. Using Standardized sizes across all regions, the same range of products for all countries, and no visible customization, with the exception of the power source, pricing, and carrier specifics. Apple utilizing the standardized approach has certainly had its benefits. One in particular was establishing a global brand with a strong identity, which is something that has worked for Apple. However, this does not mean that apple understands the requirements for cultural understanding, and cultural understanding is a big advantage for any company to be involved in global branding. This is also part of a brand living up to the Ten Commandments of Global Branding. The ten commandments of global branding which consist of a brand being known around the world. The first step for a brand to obtain this goal is to research the global branding marketplace, which is made up of many countries and regions, while understanding similarities between them. Also understanding the importantance of......

Words: 677 - Pages: 3

Mgmt 570 Week 5 Homework Collabarative Case Analysis (2 Scenarios)

...MGMT 570 Week 5 Homework Collabarative Case Analysis (2 Scenarios) To Buy This material Click below link Collaborative Case Analysis Students will work in teams to prepare a collaborative case analysis on the Negotiations for Life case (text page 202). Each team will be assigned either Scenario 1 or Scenario 2 by the professor. Teams will discuss their assessments in their team Discussion areas and prepare an analysis and recommendation in a collaborative report in the form of a paper. See MGMT570: Guidelines for Case Analysis located in Doc Sharing. The length of paper should be three to four pages, not including the cover page and references. APA style is required for in-text citation and references. Due date: In order to have a meaningful discussion, one leader from each team will post the report in the Overcoming Barriers discussion by Wednesday of Week 5. In addition, you are required to submit in the Dropbox for grading. Some students initially find case analysis of conflict problems to be difficult and uncomfortable. This is due to the relative lack of structure of most dispute-oriented problems. No correctly answered list of prequestions or mechanical process will lead to the right resolution. In fact, there usually is no single, definitively right solution to most managerial problems. When analyzing a case, remember that there are often many possible solutions. The goal is......

Words: 981 - Pages: 4

Scenario Analysis

...Scenario Analysis Officers are faced with moral decisions everyday on and off duty. It is ultimately, up to the person who is faced to make the choice between right and wrong. “Even if a man is answerable only to his conscience, he will answer more responsibly if he is compelled to articulate principles on which he acts.” stated by Lon L. Fuller (1975). We were given a few scenarios to apply this saying to and the following are my opinions that I have regarding them. The Drugs at a Friend’s House scenario is a constant issue to most officers. Many officers want to go out with the same people or friends that they have had prior to the force. However, a lot has changed in the officer. Some will turn a blind eye and the others will do what they need to this is the moral issue that the officer has in front of him/her. I would say that policy dictates, different departments have different policies concerning the authority of off-duty officers, but in many places an off-duty police officer does have the legal right to detain an offender until an on-duty officer arrives to finish the process. The key factor in such an action is proper identification, however. An off-duty police officer who commits an illegal act has no more rights or legal protections than any other regular citizen. When placed in this kind of predicament, I would first tell talk to my friend and see if he has knowledge of the drug use. If he does, I would give him a chance to fix it and get rid of......

Words: 873 - Pages: 4