Southern Homecare Cost of Capital Case 16

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ealexander4
Words 5558
Pages 23
Cases in Healthcare Finance Case 16 Solution Case 16 - 1 CASE 16 SOLUTION (11/17/10) Copyright  2010 by FACHE
SOUTHERN HOMECARE
Cost of Capital
Case Information
Type
This case is nondirected, in that it does not contain a specific list of questions that students must answer. Rather, the case contains general guidance or concerns expressed by various parties that students should consider when developing their solutions. If you, as the instructor, want to convert this case to a directed case, and hence provide your students with very specific guidance questions, you can make available the applicable questions for this case contained in the Case Questions section of the online material for instructors.
Purpose
This case focuses on the estimation of the cost of capital for a business. There is minimal quantitative analysis required, but there are a significant number of conceptual issues that are addressed in the case.
Complexity
The calculations are not complex, but many of the issues merit a great deal of discussion and require a sound understanding of cost of capital principles.
Model Description
The model takes much of the busywork out of the case, so it enables students to spend more time on interpretation and evaluation. Like most case models, the student and instructor versions differ only in regards to the input data. The instructor’s version contains the complete base case inputs, while these inputs are zeroed out in the student version of the model.
The model uses market data relevant to both the business’s debt and equity as inputs to estimate the costs of debt and equity. Both YTM and YTC costs of debt are estimated, while the cost of equity is estimated using the CAPM, DCF, and Debt cost + Risk premium methods. Note that students must use judgment regarding which component cost estimates should be used in the corporate cost of…...

Similar Documents

Case Analysis Cost of Capital at Ameritrade

...Case analysis "Cost of Capital at Ameritrade" Cost of capital refers to the maximum rate of return a company must earn from its investments, so that the market values of the company’s equity shares do not go down. The people at Ameritrade are not in agreement on the best estimate of the cost of capital. Research analyst put the cost of capital at 12%, while other members of the management estimate it to be at 9% and the CFO estimates it to be at 15%. The CEO of the company is optimistic that the rate of return is greater than the cost of investments. However, it will be difficult to continue with the project without agreeing on the estimate of the cost of capital. Determining the company’s cost of capital is essential for both capital budgeting and capital structured planning decision. Cost of capital can be classified as either implicit cost or explicit cost. Implicit cost is the rate of return associated with forgone opportunities attributed to investments on other projects. Explicit cost is the discount rate that equates to the present value the funds that the company receives from net underwriting costs. In order for the company to determine the average cost of capital, it is essential to consider the cost of each method of financing. This will be useful for the company since the profitability of the project will be judged on the basis of the cost of the sources for financing the project. This provides a composite cost of capital which is inclusive of all the......

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Cost of Capital

...Managerial Finance – Problem Review Set – Cost of Capital – with solutions 1) |If a firm's marginal tax rate is increased, this would, other things held constant, lower the cost of debt used to calculate its WACC. | | | | | | | | | | |b. |A Division B project with a 12% return. | |c. |A Division A project with an 11% return. | |d. |A Division A project with a 9% return. | |e. |A Division B project with an 11% return. | 5) |Vang Inc. estimates that its average-risk projects have a WACC of 10%, its......

Words: 842 - Pages: 4

Case Study Cost of Capital

...Case 8 Cost of Capital Nur Aishah Abdul Aziz and Supornthip Nutim @ Salmah Abdullah SYNOPSIS This case is about Maju Group Berhad (Inter-Pacific Industrial Group Berhad) which is also the owner of Maju Coffee Valley Company Sdn Bhd. The company plans to expand its retail outlet from 80 in 2011 to 88 outlets in the year 2013. According to the company’s year plan, Coffee Valley plans to open two outlets in Perak as a new potential area for the business expansion. To achieve this goal, the company needs to raise their cost of capital via long term investment to ensure their company has sufficient capital to set up the new upcoming outlets next year. INTRODUCTION Maju Coffee Valley Company Sdn Bhd recorded 30 percent increase in revenue generally attributed to the company’s aggressive marketing and expansion program as well as introduction of new and innovative products. Therefore the company wants to look into the area that might give them opportunity to expand their business. In order to expand its retail outlet, the top management held meetings to discuss important things that needed to be considered in making a decision. In the meeting, they selected the new rapid development area located in Manjung and Taiping, Perak for the next upcoming outlets to be opened this year. COMPANY BACKGROUND Coffee Valley has a simple and clear mission statement which is to establish Coffee Valley as the best coffees for drinking all the time. The following four Guiding Principles......

Words: 1564 - Pages: 7

Cost of Capital

...[pic] ILLUSTRATION 1 COMPUTE THE COST FOR THE FOLLOWING: a. A bond that has a Rs 1,000 par value (face value) and coupon interest rate of 12 percent. A new issue would have a flotation cost of 5 percent of the Rs 1,100 market value. The bonds mature in 10 years The firm's average tax rate is 25 percent and its marginal tax rate is 30 percent. b. A preferred stock paying a 9 percent dividend on a Rs 100 par value. If a new issue is offered, flotation costs will be 5 percent of the current price of Rs 125. c. Internal common equity where the current market price of the common stock is Rs 60 The expected dividend for coming year should be Rs 6, increasing thereafter at a 8 percent annual growth rate. The corporation's tax rate is 30 percent. d. A new common stock issue that paid a Rs 12 dividend last year. The par value of the stock is Rs 100, and earnings per share have grown at a rate of 6 percent per year. This growth rate is expected to continue into the foreseeable future. The company maintains a constant dividend-earnings ratio of 30 percent. The price of this stock is now Rs 110, but 5 percent flotation costs are anticipated. Solution A. GIVEN, Par value = Rs 1,000 Coupon interest = 12% Flotation cost = 5% of Rs 1100 = Rs 55 Maturity period (n) = 10 years Marginal tax rate = 30% Average tax rate = 25% ...

Words: 8307 - Pages: 34

Cost of Capital

...acquiring the Christmas Tree Shops and the Harmon Stores. In addition BBBY believes that their product offerings, customer service and advertising program have contributed to the company's financial success. Business risk in the case of BBBY is low if you only consider that the products they sell are produced by name brand companies, so any products needing repair could be sent directly to the name brand company. By passing BBBY and that BBBY has no control over the quality of the products they sell and that there are no significant switching costs. However, their degree of operating advantage is high at 2.93 (Exhibit 1) which would indicate high business risk. If management adds fixed operating costs to their business operations, without an increase in sales, the firm's profit declines and it becomes possible for total costs—variable plus fixed—to exceed sales and the firm to report a loss. Bed Bath and Beyond Cash and Debt-to-total Capital While BBBY's balance sheet is strong, there are risks of having too much cash. Namely the risk of not attracting or keeping investors, because of their desire to maximize their returns. When an investor sees to much cash on the balance sheet, they may question the company's ability to manage their capital structure efficiently, and therefore question their ability to maximize shareholder value. While BBBY uses their cash for store growth and small acquisitions, they should also be focusing on using their cash to increase shareholder...

Words: 861 - Pages: 4

Cost of Capital

...Case 12 “Best practices “in Estimating the Cost of Capital The Cost of Capital The purpose of this case is to present evidence on how some of the most financially sophisticated companies and financial advisers estimate capital costs. This evidence is valuable in several respects. First, it identifies the most important ambiguities in the application of cost-of-capital theory, setting the stage for productive debate and research on their resolution. Second, it helps interested companies benchmark their cost-of-capital estimation practices against best-practice peers. Third, the evidence sheds light on the accuracy with which capital costs can be reasonably estimated, enabling executives to use the estimates more wisely in their decision-making. Fourth, it enables teachers to answer the inevitable question, “How do companies really estimate their cost of capital?” Survey Findings The detailed survey results appear in Exhibit 2. The estimation approaches are broadly similar across the three samples in several dimensions. • Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) is the dominant investment-evaluation technique. • WACC is the dominant discount rate used in DCF analyses. • Weights are based on market not book value mixes of debt and equity.8 • The after-tax cost of debt is predominantly based on marginal pretax costs, and marginal or statutory tax rates. • The CAPM is the dominant model for estimating the cost of equity. Some firms mentioned other multi-factor asset-pricing......

Words: 2606 - Pages: 11

Cost of Capital

...REVIEW Vol. 79. No. 4 2004 pp. 967-1010 Costs of Equity and Earnings Attributes Jennifer Francis Duke University Ryan LaFond University of Wisconsin Per M. Olsson Duke University Katherine Schipper Financial Accounting Standards Board ABSTRACT: We examine the relation between the cost of equity capital and seven attributes of earnings: accrual quality, persistence, predictability, smoothness, value relevance, timeliness, and conservatism. We characterize the first four attributes as accounting-based because they are typically measured using accounting information only. We characterize the last three attributes as market-based because proxies for these constructs are typically based on relations between market data and accounting data. Based on theoretical models predicting a positive association between information quality and cost of equity, we test for and find that firms with the least favorable values of each attribute, considered individually, generally experience larger costs of equity than firms with the most favorable values. The largest cost of equity effects are observed for the accounting-based attributes, in particular, accrual quality. These findings are robust to controls for innate determinants of the earnings attributes (firm size, cash flow and sales volatility, incidence of loss, operating cycle, intangibles use/intensity, and capital intensity), as vi/ell as to alternative proxies for the cost of equity capital. W I. INTRODUCTION e investigate......

Words: 16715 - Pages: 67

Guidelines for the “Cost of Capital at Ameritrade” Case

...FIN 5439 – Capital Structure and Risk Management Nimlendran Guidelines for the “Cost of Capital at Ameritrade” Case This is a group assignment: * Each group will provide answers to the questions given below Note: You do NOT have to provide a full case report * Submit only one report per team. Submit a word document on Canvas course site. * The report should be well formatted and using 12 point font. Double spaced. All the tables should have their headings and all the units (% , million etc.) clearly indicated. A Word document should be submitted on the course website by one team member before the deadline: All calculations and estimates using Excel should be in formatted tables and inserted directly into the Word document. Note: From the Excel output, only include the important estimates and relevant statistics such as t-stats and standard errors. GRADIN RUBRIC Grade Item | Points out of 100 | Presentation including grammar and style, tables, follow instructions) | 20 | Q1 | 10 | Q2 | 10 | Q3 | 10 | Q4 | 20 | Q6 | 30 | Learning Objectives The case provides an opportunity to understand how capital market data and asset pricing model(s) can be used to estimate the cost of capital (or the required rate of return) for real investments. You do NOT have to write a formal report, but you should provide concise answers with all the assumptions stated clearly for the questions given below. * Estimate stock returns from prices by......

Words: 859 - Pages: 4

Cost of Capital

...POST-GRADUATE STUDENT RESEARCH PROJECT Estimating the Cost of Capital of CNX Nifty Prepared by Bhaswar Sarkar Student of PGDM Program of 2011-2013 Xavier Institute of Management, Bhubaneswar Supervised by Dr. Shridhar Kumar Dash Professor, Accounting and Finance Xavier Institute of Management, Bhubaneswar March 2013 Estimating the Cost of Capital of CNX Nifty Prepared by Bhaswar Sarkar1 Abstract This paper calculates the cost of capital of the CNX Nifty 50 Stock Index. It explores the possibility of establishing a new benchmark, the cost of capital of stock index, in the context of capital markets. The weighted average cost of capital (WaCC) of the Nifty 50 Stock Index is computed. The WaCC computed can form a new benchmark against which companies can compare their own cost of capital. Usually, companies raise a combination of debt and equity to finance their business. A new company can use this benchmark as a reference to choose the perfect combination of debt and equity to reduce its overall weighted average cost of capital. The methodology computes the cost of capital for the index by including each of the fifty companies of the Nifty index. An aggregate cost of capital is then calculated for all the companies, leading to a new benchmark called the cost of capital of the Nifty 50 stocks. 1 The author is currently a post-graduate student of business management (Batch 2011-2013) at Xavier Institute of Management, Bhubaneswar. The......

Words: 6011 - Pages: 25

Cost of Capital

...MANAGEMENT ADVISORY SERVICES COST OF CAPITAL THEORY 1. All of the following statements are correct except: a. The matching of asset and liability maturities is considered desirable because this strategy minimizes interest rate risk. b. Default risk refers to the inability of the firm to pay off its maturing obligations. c. The matching of assets and liability maturities lowers default risk. d. An increase in the payables deferral period will lead to a reduction in the need to non-spontaneous funding. 2. Which of the following would increase risk? a. Increase the level of working capital. b. Change the composition of working capital to include more liquid assets. c. Increase the amount of short-term borrowing. d. Increase the amount of equity financing. 3. A firm’s financial risk is a function of how it manages and maintains its debt. Which one of the following sets of ratios characterizes the firm with the greatest amount of financial risk? A. High debt-to-equity ratio, high interest coverage ratio, stable return on equity. B. Low debt-to-equity ratio, low interest coverage ratio, volatile return on equity. C. High debt-to-equity ratio, low interest coverage ratio, volatile return on equity. D. Low debt-to-equity ratio, high interest coverage ratio, stable return on equity. 4. Which of the following classes of securities are listed in order from lowest risk/opportunity for return to highest risk/opportunity......

Words: 5597 - Pages: 23

Cost of Capital

...US E RE VI PR EW O P ON E R LY T Y ± N OF OT C E NG FO A R GE SA LE LEA OR R N CL ING AS SR O Northern Forest Products OM Case 90 Cost of Capital Directed FO R Northern Forest Products (NFP) was established in the 1800s to log timber in the Great North Woods. In response to changing conditions, the company underwent radical changes in the way it operates and currently it is a large multidivisional corporation. The major focus of the company remains managing over one million acres of timber production and overseeing the manufacture of consumer paper products from pulp derived from its land holdings. Over the years the company has diversified into several other related businesses, such as a moderately sized mill that produces paneling and wood flooring. This operation has developed a consistent outlet for all of its output and therefore is stable. The company is also involved in real estate as a result of developing some of the prime lake front properties from its forestlands for residential and private recreational use. Successful property development during the 1970s resulted in expanded real estate holdings. However, residential development was particularly hard hit during a recent economic downturn, and the company struggles in this area. NFP is aware of the increasing international demand for wood products and is concerned about recent environmental pressures concerning logging. The company believes that diversification......

Words: 3896 - Pages: 16

Cost of Capital

...Quiz 11 Cost of Capital 1(11-2) NPV and IRR F I Answer: b EASY [i]. A basic rule in capital budgeting is that If a project's NPV exceeds its IRR, then the project should be accepted. a. True b. False 2(11-2) Mutually exclusive projects F I Answer: b EASY [ii]. Conflicts between two mutually exclusive projects occasionally occur, where the NPV method ranks one project higher but the IRR method puts the other one first. In theory, such conflicts should be resolved in favor of the project with the higher IRR. a. True b. False 3(11-3) IRR F I Answer: b EASY [iii]. Other things held constant, an increase in the cost of capital will result in a decrease in a project's IRR. a. True b. False 4(11-4) Multiple IRRs F I Answer: b EASY [iv]. The phenomenon called "multiple internal rates of return" arises when two or more mutually exclusive projects that have different lives are being compared. a. True b. False 5(11-5) Reinvestment rate assumption F I Answer: b EASY [v]. The IRR method is based on the assumption that projects' cash flows are reinvested at the project's risk-adjusted cost of capital. a. True b. False 6(11-6) Modified IRR F I Answer: b EASY [vi]. When evaluating mutually exclusive projects, the modified IRR (MIRR) always leads to the same capital budgeting decisions as the NPV method, regardless of the relative lives or sizes of the projects......

Words: 1417 - Pages: 6

Cost of Capital

...Cost of Capital FINANCING DECISION  In financing decision, it is totally concentrated on how to generate finance from long term sources  It is also considered the following points:  Cost of Finance  Time period  Purpose of Finance  Amount of Finance  Risk involvement SOURCES OF FINANCE Finance required for investing purpose may be from one or combination of the following sources: 1) From Debt Source 2) From Equity Source i. Ordinary Shares ii. Preference Shares iii. Retained Earning Why do we use different source of finance? COST OF FINANCE It is the minimum rate of return that a firm must earn on its investment for the market value of the firm to remain unchanged. WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL Capital is the combination of different components (sources) and the cost of each component is called specific cost. When these specific costs are combined to arrive at overall cost of capital, it is referred to as the weighted average cost of capital. Assumptions  Entity’s financial and business risks are unaffected by the acceptance and financing of projects.  Financial structure of the entity remains constant. It means that if the entity needs additional funds then are to be raised in accordance with the existing proportion. Components of Cost of Capital  Risk-free cost of particular type of financing (r)  Business risk premium (b)  Financial risk premium (f) k = r + b +f Explicit and Implicit Cost Explicit Cost From the desk of M.......

Words: 2762 - Pages: 12

Cost of Capital

...HOW DO CFOS MAKE CAPITAL BUDGETING AND CAPITAL STRUCTURE DECISIONS? by John Graham and Campbell Harvey, Duke University* e recently conducted a comprehensive survey that analyzed the current practice of corporate finance, with particular focus on the areas of capital budgeting and capital structure. The survey results enabled us to identify aspects of corporate practice that are consistent with finance theory, as well as aspects that are hard to reconcile with what we teach in our business schools today. In presenting these results, we hope that some practitioners will find it worthwhile to observe how other companies operate and perhaps modify their own practices. It may also be useful for finance academics to consider differences between theory and practice as a reason to revisit the theory. We solicited responses from approximately 4,440 companies and received 392 completed surveys, representing a wide variety of firms and industries.1 The survey contained nearly 100 questions and explored both capital budgeting and capital structure decisions in depth. The responses to these questions enabled us to explore whether and how these corporate policies are interrelated. For example, we investigated whether companies that made more aggressive use of debt financing also tended to use more sophisticated capital budgeting techniques, perhaps because of their greater need for discipline and precision in the corporate investment process. More generally, the design of our survey...

Words: 10903 - Pages: 44

Cost of Capital Ameritrade Case Solution

...201-046 Cost of Capital at Ameritrade Exhibit 1 Consolidated Annual Income Statements for the Fiscal Year Ending in September 1997 Net Revenues Transaction Income Net Interest Other Total Net Revenues Expenses Excluding Interest Employee Compensation Commissions and Clearance Communications Occupancy and Equipment Cost Advertising and Promotion Provision for Losses Amortization of Goodwill Other Total Expenses Excluding Interest Income Before Income Taxes Taxes Net Income EPS Shares Outstanding Source: Ameritrade Annual Report, 1997. $ $ 51.936.902,00 $ 18.193.946 7.107.492 77.238.340 1996 36.469.561,00 $ 11.477.878 6.391.314 54.338.753 1995 23.977.481,00 8.434.584 2.607.538 35.019.603 19.290.808 3.320.262 5.623.468 5.422.839 13.970.834 59.000 363.002 7.763.014 55.813.227 21.425.113 7.602.964 13.822.149 $ $1,00 13.768.889 14.049.642 2.530.642 3.685.535 2.889.654 7.537.265 148.014 363.002 4.717.406 35.921.160 18.417.593 7.259.248 11.158.345 $ $0,87 12.813.823 8.481.977 2.516.796 2.352.590 1.626.725 4.842.392 1.428.663 94.152 2.846.280 24.189.575 10.830.028 3.798.881 7.031.147 $0,55 12.813.823 t Ameritrade Cost of Capital at Ameritrade 201-046 Exhibit 2 Consolidated Annual Balance Sheets for the Fiscal Year Ending in September 1997 1996 ASSETS Cash & Gash Equivalents Cash & Investments Segregated in Compliance with Federal Regulations Receivable from Brokers, Dealers, & Clearing Organizations Receivable from Customers & Correspondents Furniture...

Words: 11029 - Pages: 45