The Difference and Similarities Between Contingency Theories of Leadership

In: Business and Management

Submitted By kubra123
Words 407
Pages 2
THE DIFFERENCE AND SIMILARITIES BETWEEN CONTINGENCY THEORIES OF LEADERSHIP
Contingency and Path Theories are methods of inspecting management. Contingency theories emphasize the numerous variables that may range in any given hindrance that make one context exceptional from an additional. Direction theories stress description, motivation and charisma. One of the crucial principal variations between the 2 tactics is that path theories emphasize the character of the chief, even as contingency theories stress the nature of surrounding instances.
Situational management models are situated on the work of institution of Washington professor Fred Fiedler and leadership experts Paul Hersey and Kenneth H. Blanchard. Fiedler suggests that management is determined by situational causes, reminiscent of favored management patterns and worker motivation. The factors that have an effect on leaders incorporate leader-member members’ family, which is the boldness staff have in their managers; assignment constitution, which is the character of the work; and position vigor, which is the formal authority and impact of leaders.
Hersey and Blanchard advise 4 leadership styles depending on employee traits. Leaders can adopt the directing sort for unskilled and unmotivated employees, the teaching variety for motivated however unskilled employees, the supporting style for skilled however unmotivated staff and the observing sort for encouraged and expert employees. The path-goal concept means that leaders keep in mind their employees' advantage earlier than assigning tasks, persuade workers of their expertise to participate in the assigned tasks and reward individuals who exceed expectations. Vroom and Yetton’s decision participation CT or the Normative choice concept: in keeping with this mannequin, the effectiveness of a determination approach depends upon a number of points of the…...

Similar Documents

Similarities and Differences Between Virtue Theory, Utilitarianism, and Deontological Ethics

...Similarities and Differences Between Virtue Theory According to Boylan (2009), “ethics is the science concerning the right and wrong of human behavior.” It is a method that allows us to organize our values and go after them. It helps us answer questions like: do I seek my own happiness, or do I sacrifice myself for a greater cause? According to "Ethics - Definition And More From The Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary" (2012), ethics is “the discipline dealing with what is good and bad and with moral duty and obligation.” Because we are beings living together in society, we all go through tough moral decisions like a father deciding whether his son’s end-of-the-year school concert is more important than his business meeting, or accepting gifts from vendors when a contract bid is under evaluation. Moral decisions require moral reasoning and deliberation, which takes place within certain perspectives three of which are virtue ethics, utilitarianism, and deontologism. Virtue ethics focuses on how to be; studies what makes the character traits of people. A person who has these traits will act by habit in certain ways not because of its consequences but because it is what a virtuous person would do. The Boy Scout pledge is an example of virtue ethics because he pledges to be a certain person. Utilitarianism is the view that says “if an act will produce more happiness than will alternatives, it is the right thing to do, and if it will produce less happiness, it would be wrong to do......

Words: 640 - Pages: 3

Similarities and Differences Between Nyse and Nasdaq

...the flow of trading going. On the NYSE, the exchange traffic controller is known as the specialist, who is in charge of matching buyers and sellers together. A few of the similarities are that during trades, both exchanges use an electronic screen because of the fact they the screen based electronic stock exchanges. The Stock Exchange Commission synchronizes these two exchanges and joins in the activity of trading stock equities. As you can see, there are a number of similarities between the two exchanges however; there are also a number of differences between the two as well. One difference is that the NASDAQ is considered a high tech trading market because most of their components are electronics, technology and internet based companies whereas, the NYSE encompasses more established and bigger companies from different industries. In part this also plays a way in the difference how the two exchanges trade. The NYSE conducts their transactions on the root of physical trading, and the NASDAQ trades there stock on the root of a telecommunication network. What this means is that the NYSE is a typical market where people trade on behalf of their companies, and the NASDAQ uses a direct contact system, in order for communication of the sellers and buyers. Another significant difference between the two exchanges is the cost needed to list your stocks on the market. The highest cost of investment for a listing on NASDAQ is $150,000. There is also an annual......

Words: 699 - Pages: 3

Compare the Similarities and Differences Between Virtue Theory, Utilitarianism, and Deontological Ethics.

...the similarities and differences between the three major approaches in normative ethics; virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. I will do this by analyzing these ethical theories and by describing them along with presenting the facts on how each theory relates to ethics and morality. It will also include a personal experience to explain the relationship between virtue, values, and moral concepts as they relate to one of the three theories. We have all been faced with the circumstances that have pushed our moral boundaries. Virtue ethics refers more specifically to one character embodying for determining or evaluating ethical behavior. In other words virtue ethics emphasizes one moral character.  According to Boylan (2009), virtue ethics is also sometimes called agent-based or character ethics. It takes the viewpoint that in living your life you should try to cultivate excellence in all that you do and all that others do. (Chapter 11, It’s All About Your Character: Virtue Ethics). For example, finding a wallet with money in it, and returning it to the rightful owner is an act of virtue. One of my proudest moments growing up as a 15years old was to find a wallet and returning it to the owner. To this day, I remember being proud when the owner thanked me. As we mature we are, as humans, programmed to understand the difference between right and wrong. However, we sometimes choose the wrong path, and lean toward the immoral behaviors. Utilitarianism theory of......

Words: 665 - Pages: 3

Similarities & Differences of Ethical Theories

...The similarities and differences between utilitarianism, Deontology and the virtue theory are very interesting to discuss. Before starting these readings and this class I was very aware of the role that ethics, morals and values played in our daily lives but I was very unaware the specific names that identify the different types of ethics. According to our electronic readings for this week we can all agree that ethics in general are a basic set of rules or ideals of right and wrong conduct in daily life (Boylan, 2009). Unfortunately to me that is where the similarities end considering each type of ethics/ theories. Utilitarianism ethics for example basically states that there could possibly be a set of ethical rules that is universally compatible which will eventually make a “paradise society”. Since we all know that this is a farce to have everyone live by the same set of ethical beliefs I do not believe that this kind of ethics would be feasible (Boylan, 2009). This ethical belief is a far cry from deontological ethics in that this system tries to cater to everyone instead of being duty bound to a strict set of ideals. Deontological ethics refers to the idea of the means does justify end and the consequences of said actions makes up the ethical consideration of good or bad. (BBC Ethics Guide, 2013) This theory on ethics is duty based and is not as concerned with the consequences. People that follow the deontological ethics are more concerned with a...

Words: 719 - Pages: 3

Contingency Theories of Leadership

...Contingency Theories of Leadership Name Class Affiliation Instructor Date Leadership is considered by psychologists and organizational researchers as one of the most multifaceted and complex phenomena (Field & Seters, 1990). As a result of its complexity, leadership is one of the most misconceived phenomenon in the whole world. This prompted the researchers to come up with various foundational theories which helped to shed more light about leadership (Burns, 1978). Thus, it is impossible to analyze and evaluate leadership theories without going back to their origins (Field&Seters, 1990) There are several leadership theories that have been researched, developed and discussed by various researchers. They include; personality, influence, behavior, situational, transactional, anti-leadership, culture, transformational and contingency theories. The sole objective of this essay is to critically evaluate a group of contingency theories of leadership. The most notable contingency theories of leadership include Fried Fiedler’s, Path-Goal and Vroom-Jago (Field&Seters, 1990). This essay will start by evaluating Fiedler’s theory, followed by Path-Goal theory and the last three theories will be evaluated as a single group. According to (Bryman, 2011), contingency theories are advanced on the platform that dictates that there is no single best method that can be used alone to make a decision or lead an organization. These theories seek to offer and explain the...

Words: 1609 - Pages: 7

Differences Between Leadership and Management

...According to many scholars, management is a basically the implementation of already established processes such as planning, staffing, measuring performance and budgeting thereby enabling an organization to do well. On the other hand, leadership is entirely different. It can be described as taking an organization to the future, exploring and successfully exploiting opportunities that come up. Leadership is about having vision, empowerment and most importantly providing useful change in the organization. The main differences between leaders and managers are: the relationship between the followers and managers and leaders, how leaders and managers solve problems, and the difference in emotional intelligence between leaders and managers. Leaders and managers have a difference in emotional intelligence. A leader is an individual who strategizes a visionary and most importantly someone who inspires other people to greatness. In order to achieve this, while leading one must share their vision with the staff or people brought together to solve a problem or create a strategy. Leaders serve as role models, motivate their staff, inspire cooperation and create a community both inside and outside of the organization. They mostly follow their intuition which in most cases benefits the company and in most cases they gain followers who become loyal to them and the organization. This is a direct contradiction to managers who carry out their instructions by the book and follow the......

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5

Contingency Theory of Leadership

...Contingency Theory of Leadership |Description of work environment | | | |The work environment I intend to review for this assignment would be the Logistic Department. | | |Logistics is considered to be the complete process involving planning, managing and controlling | | |the flow of goods and services, information, real-time data and human resources from the point of| | |origin to the point of destination. | In the table below, categorize different leadership approaches that could be used in the work environment you have described. Provide different suggestions for each of the four approaches to leadership. |Directive approach |Supportive approach | | | | | ...

Words: 340 - Pages: 2

Leadership Differences Between Men and Women

...the road? On differences between women and men in leadership behaviour 428 Jon Aarum Andersen Received May 2010 Revised October 2010 Accepted November 2010 Faculty of Social Sciences, Lillehammer University College, Lillehammer, Norway, and Per H. Hansson Department of Education, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden Abstract Purpose – This study aims to explore behavioural differences between women and men in managerial positions and suggest explanations for differences and similarities. Design/methodology/approach – In order to eliminate any effects of organizational differences on leadership behaviour, this study had public managers responding to questionnaires that measured their leadership style, decision-making style, and motivation profile. Findings – Statistical analyses of data from three groups of Swedish public managers (n ¼ 385) revealed virtually no significant differences in behaviour between female and male managers. Regardless of whether there is a female or male majority of employees or a female or male majority of managers, no effect on leadership behaviour occurs. Originality/value – A number of studies indicate that managers’ behaviour is different in different types of organizations. This study suggests, therefore, that, independent of gender, organizational and demographic characteristics modify leadership behaviours, thus explaining similarities in leadership behaviour. Keywords Women, Men, Gender, Leadership behaviour,......

Words: 6374 - Pages: 26

Week 5 Chapter 4 Contingency Leadership Theories

...the difference between a theory and a model? I suppose this question is asking is the difference between a leadership theory and a leadership model. A leadership theory is an explanation of some aspect of leadership; explanation of the variables and leadership styles to be used in a given contingency situation. A leadership model is a short summary of the theory to be used when selecting the appropriate leadership style for a given situation. What contingency leadership variables are common to all of the theories? For Followers, capability and motivation, for leaders, personality traits, behavior and experience, for situation, task structure, and environment. I have no idea what this means but the chart in the book stated that exhibit 4.1 was the framework for contingency leadership variables. How does the global economy relate to contingency leadership? Contingency leadership style is based on the leader, follower and the situation. Taking someone from a country such as the United States, have him/her try to lead in China the way they would in the United States, could be disastrous. In Contingency leadership it is best to match the leader to the follower or situation. What are the two contingency leadership theory leadership styles? Task and Relationship are the two leadership styles under the contingency leadership theory. Task relates to the job and relationship relates to the employee. Do the three situational favorableness factors of the contingency leadership......

Words: 699 - Pages: 3

Similarities and Differences Between Bsn and Msn

...level leadership skills for improving health outcomes. (http://www.aacn.nche.edu/education-resources/MastersEssentials11.pdf) The similarities of both degrees seem to be the fact that they can both practice in the profession of nursing with some limitations for the Baccalaureate degree graduate, but the biggest difference is the Master’s education prepared graduate acquires skills to initiate change, promote health and elevate care in various roles and setting. Master’s program usually focuses on a particular area such as administration, nurse practitioner, clinic nurse leader or educator. (http://www.villanovau.com/resources/nursing/difference-between-bsn-vs-msn/#.VeJLQPlVhBc) Therefore, the development of new skills and practice expectations can be facilitated through the use of creative learning opportunities in diverse settings. In addition, the extraordinary explosion of knowledge in the healthcare field requires the master’s-prepared nurse to have an increased emphasis on lifelong learning and professional development The Baccalaureate degree takes 4 years and the Master’s is an additional 2 years of education. It is imperative to note that the Baccalaureate degree serves as the building block and foundation to elevate to the Master’s......

Words: 500 - Pages: 2

Differences Between Leadership and Management

...Differences between leadership and management Steve Garthe LDR/300 September 21, 2015 Earl Levith Leadership and management is a strong need for any company worldwide to become successful in their categories of business. Although there are vast similarities between the two, there are also some differences that have been known to separate the two completely. Defining Leadership has been given to us by Merriam as “a position as a leader of a group, organization, etc.” Additionally, Merriam states that leadership is “the time when a person holds the position of a leader” and “the power or ability to lead other people.” This definition allows us to think about the simplistic ways of a supervisor or team lead in which they go about their day in tasking others beneath the. Merriam also defines management as “the act or skill of controlling and making decisions about a business, department, sports team, etc.” If a company hires a manager who has a high level of skill providing production flow and profitability to their company, this will filter down through the ranks and provide those beneath the manager the tools for success. From personal experience, spending many years both a leadership role and the managerial role has provided a new level of understanding of what responsibilities each one of these positions held for the companies that I was employed with. Many of the leadership roles that were held have been basic led of operations style positions within a scan......

Words: 762 - Pages: 4

Contingency Theory of Leadership

...CheckPoint: Contingency Theory of Leadership Resource: Ch. 6 of Introduction to Business Complete Appendix D by using figures 6.3 & 6.4 on pp. 182–183 as a guide. Base your answers on a real or hypothetical work environment. Describe the components of the contingency theory of leadership as it applies to the work environment you selected. Conclude with your recommendation for the best leadership approach. Post Appendix D as an attachment. • Your paper must be done in a Microsoft Word document and saved as your First Initial, Last Initial, Last 4 of IRN (DM1234). All of the information should match the name of your individual forum. • Format your paper as shown in Appendix D, an example is provided below. The Description of Environment should be no more than one paragraph in length. A paragraph should be 3-4 sentences. Each of the four approaches sections need only be long enough to fully explain your actions in each role. You can organize through bullet comments or complete sentences. • Use your own words and ideas. For this project, I am not interested in seeing textbook definitions or quotes. Explain to me your understanding of the material through your descriptions. However, if you quote or paraphrase from any source, including the textbook, you must cite these properly and provide a reference list. Use the Axia Style Writing Handbook and the Center for Writing Excellence to ensure you are formatting properly. If you take a......

Words: 833 - Pages: 4

Similarities and Differences Between Germany Nazism and Italy Fascism

...Similarities and Differences between Germany Nazism and Italy Fascism {Author’s name} {Institution Affiliation} {Due date} Similarities and Differences between Germany Nazism and Italy Fascism Introduction Fascism defined, implies an organization or acceptable rule of administration characterized by a government system led by a dictator who exercises harsh and strict control over the citizens, and the commons are mandated to comply with the government rule without resistance. Most authoritarian regimes rely on nationality or race to garner influence and support for a centralized autocratic government. The main aim of a fascist government is to enhance national unity and maintain a stable order in the society by exercising the element of fear among the citizens. Totalitarianism was able to exercise influence, by garnering devotion from regime loyalist. Its prominent execution was purported to collectively influence the success of a country. Supporters of the regime were rewarded by significant posts and incentives while non-loyalists were expected to remain silent without questioning the administrations motives. Use of violence was supported by the administration system to neutralize any emergent form of oppression. Fascism was a prominent governing system that was established during the early twentieth century, based on the need to respond to western influence and assert dictatorial states as new......

Words: 2882 - Pages: 12

Bus210 Contingency Theory of Leadership

...Axia College Material Appendix D Contingency Theory of Leadership |Description of work environment | | | | | | |A clothing store that sells new and gently used brand name clothes at a cost most | | |consumers can afford. | | | | In the table below, categorize different leadership approaches that could be used in the work environment you have described. Provide different suggestions for each of the four approaches to leadership. |Directive approach |Supportive approach | |Have a meeting with each employee on his or her first day of work|Being supportive in this clothing business will allow for better | |and go over the company procedures and handbook. I will be sure |working conditions which in return will allow for better sales of| |to explain the company’s schedule and when employees should |the clothes. Employees will be treated with respect and ......

Words: 535 - Pages: 3

Contingency Theory of Leadership

...Contingency Theory of Leadership Description of work environment Describe the work environment you intend to review for this assignment. The work environment I am going to review is an environment where young adults, adults, and veterans with disabilities, work on a military base, serving the military their meals, and cleaning the dining facility. In the table below, categorize different leadership approaches that could be used in the work environment you have described. Provide different suggestions for each of the four approaches to leadership. Directive approach Supportive approach The direct approach used in this work environment is policy and procedures to maintain a safe work environment and discipline. A weekly work schedule is posted at the same time, each week, so each employee knows their schedule a week ahead of time. Employee incentives like employee of the month, and year, awards are used, along with the possibility of career advancement. Daily, monthly, and annual training or coaching to ensure each employee knows their job task and what is expected of them. A binder is kept in different areas of the dining facility so the employees can refer to them for reminders of job duties, policies, regulations, and procedures. Employees are evaluated annually and given a pay increase depending on the evaluation score. The supportive approach used is to show an interest in each employee and how they are doing. To know each......

Words: 729 - Pages: 3