Tnk-Bp Case Study

In: Business and Management

Submitted By saty88
Words 2106
Pages 9
BP in Russia

Executive Summary
This case study “BP in Russia: Settling the Joint Venture Dispute” goes into the major world energy companies and the formation of joint ventures. This case delves into the 50/50 international joint venture (IJV) formed between British Petroleum (BP) and a group of Russian investors, Alfa Group, Access Industries, and Renova known as AAR. This IJV was formed in September 2003 and was known as TNK-BP.1

TNK-BP’s CEO was Robert Dudley in May 2008. This is when the dispute between the British and Russian shareholders started to escalate. AAR thought that BP was treating TNK-BP as a subsidiary and not a JV. The escalation of the conflict got to the point where BP was seriously considering whether they should walk away from the IJV by selling its stake, acquire AAR’s stake or continue the IJV.

This case analysis will explore BP and whether it was a good strategy to enter Russia and pursue an international joint venture with consortium AAR. Next the analysis will look at the evolution of the joint venture and examine the unique challenges faced by the international joint venture. Next the study will detail our recommendations regarding the AAR partnership, their implications and steps to implement this. Lastly the case will be updated to the present time.

1. Did BP pursue the right strategy to enter Russia?
There are arguments both for and against BP’s decision to enter Russia. Perhaps the biggest disadvantage to BP’s strategy was the cultural differences they would experience in Russia. In addition to obvious cultural differences between Western and Russian national cultures and between global and regional operations and experience, TNK-BP faced cultural differences between a public company and Russia’s owner-founder heritage, the business environment and organizational maturity, and the distinctive corporate cultures…...

Similar Documents

Msc14&15-Bp Study Guide.Pdf

...UNIVERSITY COLLEGE DUBLIN NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF IRELAND, DUBLIN MASTER OF SCIENCE (SINGAPORE) Business Policy BMGT 4025S STUDY GUIDE MSc14/15 FT / Singapore Copyright October 2012 1 Author: Dr Yousef Eiadat and Dr Richard Tan (2012) This manual was prepared for University College Dublin as a comprehensive support for students completing the above mentioned Degree programme. © This publication may not be reproduced, in whole or in part without permission in from University College Dublin. Module Co-ordinator: Dr Yousef Eiadat & Dr Richard Tan Contact details Mobile: TBA Office: TBA Email: 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE Welcome message 1. INTRODUCTION a. Background details b. Module aims 2. MODULE OUTLINE a. Module learning outcomes b. Themes and topics c. Learning supports 3. MODULE DELIVERY SCHEDULE a. Session arrangements b. Student engagement c. Office hours arrangements 4. ASSESSMENT DETAILS a. Assignments b. Module assessment components i. Pre module assignment ii. Group project iii. Examination 5. GRADING a. University grading policy b. Grade descriptors for assessment components 6. CONCLUDING COMMENTS APPENDICES 5 6 10 12 16 19 21 3 Welcome message Welcome to this unit on Business Policy. Dr Yousef Eiadat will be joining me in teaching this course. In this unit we aim to build skills in Strategic planning – the analysis behind strategic decisions, the crafting of strategies and the......

Words: 4379 - Pages: 18

Bp Case

...| 1. Based on the history of the company, why did BP get involved in so much questionable conduct? BP's history extends back to 1901 when William D'Arcy's Anglo-Persian Oil Company first drilled for oil in Persia and after seven years of drilling and darcy's nearly spent his net worth finally oil spewed out and became rich. Unfortunately later at 1914 BP was on the verge of bankruptcy due to the very low demand of oil in global market. Accordingly ,BP's Board strategy focused for decades on selling and making profits by expanding and increasing their market shares and they have neglected BP responsibilities with respect to human and environmental resources in their Mission statements and Corporate goals . Below is part of their new mission statement and underlined parts emphasize how BP have changed their way of thinking and realized how social responsibility and environment are important to their business especially after several disasters that occurred to them last decade. Mission statement: "BP wants to be recognized as a great company – competitively successful and a force for progress. We have a fundamental belief that we can make a difference in the world. We help the world meet its growing need for heat, light and mobility. We strive to do that by producing energy that is affordable, secure and doesn’t damage the environment. BP is progressive, responsible, innovative and performance driven." "Progressive - We believe in the......

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5


...when one of the world’s largest energy companies, BP, and the Russian state company, Rosneft, unsuccessfully attempted to form a strategic partnership on Arctic development. This failure was caused by the contractual and legal objections of the AAR consortium - BP’s partners in the Russian oil company TNK-BP. In 2003-5, BP and the AAR consortium led by three billionaires with Russian connections - Mikhail Fridman, Len Blavatnik, and Viktor Vekselberg - merged their Russian oil corporate assets - TNK, Sidanko, and Onako and their subsidiaries - under the umbrella of TNK-BP.2 This joint venture was established on a 50/50 basis, the operation of which required mutual joint decision making. The partners also signed a shareholding agreement on TNK- BP’s right of first refusal in relation to potential future oil and gas projects offered to BP or AAR in Russia and Ukraine. This agreement was subsequently used by AAR to stop the BP-Rosneft deal in international courts. Unfortunately, this was not the first time that BP had been unable to change the way it conducted its business in Russia. The first example occurred in 2007-8 when BP was reported to be keen on having Gazprom as a partner instead of AAR. This move would have transformed the TNK-BP joint venture into Gazprom-BP. This did not transpire. Second, in the spring-summer 2008, there was a turbulent ‘misunderstanding’ between BP and AAR, over the corporate governance and......

Words: 9031 - Pages: 37

Tnk-Bp Case Analysis 2011

...Strategic Management : Principles and Practice Case study « TNK-BP » 1) Explain based on i) the type of partners (competitors or not), ii) the contribution of resources (which resources?) and iii) the nature of the alliance (what is both partners’ purpose?) whether TNK-BP is a scale or scope alliance. The TNK-BP joint venture is an alliance between two competitors(i): the oil British giant BP and the consortium of four Russian billionaires behind AAR. On the hand, BP is the second largest private sector oil company in the world. On the other hand, AAR is a very diversified group; it has interests in banking, retail, telecommunications, and medias but also in oil, notably through TNK which owns oil reserves and facilities. Those two companies contribute differently (ii) to the joint-venture. BP brings its know-how and expertise to exploit oil reserves, as well as the required investment (6,8$ billions of equity). AAR provides oil production in Siberia, oil refining, gaz interest and 1400 filling stations in Russian and Ukraine. One could argue that BP needs natural resources and is ready to pay a premium for it, whereas AAR needs the technology and expertise of BP. This alliance (iii) is a joint venture between BP and AAR because TNK-BP is a new entity that is owned equally by BP and AAR without any mergers or acquisitions from BP to AAR or vice versa. This alliance is a scope alliance since it is driven by complementarities in competence and assets, and......

Words: 866 - Pages: 4

Bp Study Guide

...ACG 3401 Study Guide Exam 1 Accountants Roles * Management accountant * Internal auditor * Information systems auditor * External auitor * Tax accountant * Fraud examiner * Managerial Accountant * Provides info for mngmt decisions * Knowledge base: * * * * Business processes * Accounting information sustems * Internal controls * Managerial accouting techniques * Impact of accounting on behaviors Advocate for best info possible for making the best decision for the firm IMA Information criteria: 1. 2. 3. 4. Forward looking 5. Timely 6. Responsibility oriented Planning Systems (budgets) control systems (implement the course of action and evaluate) Management accounting answers questions related to : * * * * * Important customers ( profitability) * Substitute products * Critical capability * Funding ( growth) Value ( Adam Smith) * Value in use- derive value by using the product * Value in exchange- derive value from the exchange of that product for another good or service. Generic Value Chain Model: 1. 2. 3. 4. *Customer need identitified* 5. Identify the market and create the product/ service ( innovation cycle) 6. Build the product or service and deliver the product or service ( operations cycle) 7. Service the customer ( post sales service......

Words: 2656 - Pages: 11

Bp Case

...Case Analysis 1 - BP and the Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill Case Ying – Chen Lee Hawaii Pacific University 02.12.2013 Case Analysis 1 - BP and the Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill Case Event Review Before the event, the Deepwater Horizon oil spill (also referred to as the BP oil spill, the Gulf of Mexico oil spill, the BP oil disaster or the Macondo blowout), BP was facing a situation where the company was turbulent and needed the new locations and new technology to secure natural resources. The new CEO, Tony Hayward, proposed a variety of measures to boost productivity and profits which included safety improvement. The company tried to improve the financial deficit that was caused by the accident of oil spill and others. In this condition, BP made decisions that were risky and dangerous in the process. A few months before the accident, related workers, engineers and supervisors expressed their concern about the safety of the work environment because not enough cement was being used to stabilize the drilling platform. After that, methane leaked out in the evening on April 20th, and the drilling rig was soon engulfed in flames. Most of the workers were rescued; however, there were still 11 workers missing even though the Coast Guard searched for them for three days. After 36 hours of burning, the drilling rig sank in the morning on April 22nd. According to the investigation report by the U.S. Coast Guard and Ocean Energy Authority, the cement for reinforcing the oil well was the......

Words: 1165 - Pages: 5

Bp Texas Case Study

...BP TEXAS CITY Answer #1 As this case shows Human Rights violation BP, The company was lacking operational decisions, such as ensuring that safety standards are appropriate for employees; rather than pursuing additional profits and hiding behind a mask of public relations. Viewed from this perspective, ‘calculated casualties’ don’t provide the greatest amount of good; it simply highlights an unethical and ruthless pursuit of profits and hence environmental destruction and human deaths would widely be considered unethical. Answer#2 Yes, the OSHA policies and rules are aimed at addressing problems that existed in BP texas. The problems continued for so many years because of the culture of BP. They were not serious about the safety of employees and were focusing on making numbers. Answer#3 As it is mentioned in the case that BP global management was aware of problems with maintenance, spending and infrastructure well before March 2005 they were informed and had many OSHA violation , In 2005 they had an agreement with OSHA to fix the safety violations but BP had failed to do so stating that budget pressures were the reason behind it. Therefore such a big penalty was announced. Answer#4 * Use checklist and follow OSHA standards, Should properly train and motivate staff to use personal protective equipment. Form evacuation plans * Conduct safety and health audits. Introduce policies and give trainings to supervisor. * Proper selection and placement of employees......

Words: 597 - Pages: 3

Tnk-Bp a Case

...heretofore closed channels of distribution in key regions of the world. One very good reason why many joint ventures only involve two parties is the difficulty in integrating different corporate cultures. With two domestic companies from the same country, it would still be very difficult. However, with two companies from different cultures, it is almost impossible at times. This is probably why pure joint ventures have a fairly high failure rate only five years after inception. Joint ventures involving three or more parties are usually called syndicates and are most often formed for specific projects such as large construction or public works projects that might involve a wide variety of expertise and resources for successful completion. In some cases, syndicates are actually easier to manage because the project itself sets certain limits on each party and close cooperation is not always a prerequisite for ultimate success of the endeavor. bullet Portfolio investment. Yes, we know that you’re paying attention and no we’re not trying to trip you up here. Remember our definition of foreign direct investment as it pertains to controlling interest. For most of the latter part of the 20th century when FDI became an issue, a company’s portfolio investments were not considered a direct investment if the amount of stock and/or capital was not enough to garner a significant voting interest amongst shareholders or owners. However, two or three companies with "soft" investments in......

Words: 1543 - Pages: 7

Bps Marketing Case Study

...Although Barco Projection Systems (BPS) only captured 14% of the aggregate total for projectors, for the corporate and industrial environments, BPS offered an unequaled level of quality in high end projectors due to the continuous improvements in scan rates and general performance compared to its peers. BPS 35% video, 53% data, 12% graphics  total of 4,400 units (1,540 video units, 2,332 data units, 528 graphics units) 8% of entire market of video projectors (〖Total〗_video×.08=1,540→〖Total〗_video=19,250) 23% of entire market of data projectors (〖Total〗_data×.23=2,332→〖Total〗_data=10,139) 55% of entire market of graphics projectors (〖Total〗_graphics×.55=528→〖Total〗_graphics=960) Sony 66% video, 34% data  total of 15,000 units (9,900 video units, 5,100 data units) 50% of entire market of video projectors (〖Total〗_video×.5=9,900→〖Total〗_video=19,800) 49% of entire market of data projectors (〖Total〗_data×.49=5,100→〖Total〗_data=10,408) Electrohome 73% data, 27% graphics  total of 1,585 units (1157 data units, 428 graphics units) 11% of entire market of data projectors (〖Total〗_data×.11=1,157→〖Total〗_data=10,518) 44% of entire market of graphics projectors (〖Total〗_graphics×.44=428→〖Total〗_graphics=973) (Total) ̅_video=(19,250+19,800)/2=19,525 (Total) ̅_data=(10,139+10,408+10,518)/3=10,355 (Total) ̅_graphics=(960+973)/2=967 〖Total〗_projectors=19,525+10,355+967=30,847 Table 1. Market size calculations. BPS entered into the video projector......

Words: 943 - Pages: 4

Bp Ethics Case

...When asking someone about the top 3 oil companies in the world, it is almost always certain that BP will be named on that person’s list, accompanied by Exxon and Shell. The oil company is such a huge and necessary industry that our country depends on day in and day out. Governments and companies have all looked into different types of alternative energy but there are still none that are near as effective as oil. Oil is a highly flammable, high combustion, fuel that gives high effectiveness. The problem with oil is that it is messy, in many different ways, when burned it sends damaging emissions into our atmosphere, when leaked it kills basically anything in it’s path from animals to plants. The riskiness of oil has caused an uproar around the world recently with the recent “going green phase” and environmentally friendly movement. These largely point towards oil because oil when burned sends large amounts of CO2 into the atmosphere, which does damage to our atmosphere and lets in more Gama radiation from the sun, which heats up the Earth. This causes a large problem for oil companies and their initiative to make money. In this case we will be focusing on BP, a very well known company if not the most well known. The largest problem with BP is, most of us when hearing that name think straight to April, 2010 when a BP oil rig exploded in the Gulf of Mexico leaking out millions of gallons of petroleum. For a company and it’s stakeholders, this is one thing that you don’t want......

Words: 1541 - Pages: 7


...TNK-BP (RUSSIA) 2008 – (A07-09-0006) 1. Why did BP create TNK-BP? Are the partners equally committed and motivated to create a successful venture? 2. How has the JV performed? Has it met expectations? 3. Why has the JV experienced so many problems? 4. Does the Russian government have a specific agenda for the JV? 5. What options does BP have? What would you recommend? 1. In comparison with its competitors, the production growth of BP was constrained by its mature oil fields. As a result of the constrained production growth, BP’s financial performance was lagging behind compared to the financial performances of their competitors (e.g. ExxonMobil, Shell). Therefore, BP was aggressively looking for new oil reserves (p. 2). Russia was the world’s largest natural gas producer; the proven reserves were ranked 7th worldwide and there were huge opportunities for further exploitation. It seems like the Russian part of the joint venture is less motivated. They have done this deal to improve profits and to increase their benefits and potential growth. 2. For BP, the joint venture worked out quite well. As stated in the text: “TNK-BP accounted for nearly one-quarter of BP’s oil production.” If the joint venture comes to an end, this would have serious (financial) implications for BP. Also, in the period 2002-2006 the net profit grew from 1.5 million dollars to 6.4 million dollars. 3. One of the issues was that the partners were not in agreement as to the level......

Words: 688 - Pages: 3

Bp Case

...turtles and whales. The economic consequences were very bad as well. BP reported that the total cost of this bill will be around U$ 4bn and a share value decrease of 50%. We must also talk about the consequences on local industries. Indeed, tourism was employing 57 000 people before the spill and fishing represented a U$ 3bn in the region. These two sectors have been strongly affected by this incident. Ethics and discussion: In terms of ethics, there are a lot of lesson we can make from this spill. Firstly, we saw how powerful the oil companies were and we understood why the biggest market capitalization was an oil company, Exxon Mobil. This incident showed us that these companies don’t care about other people or other businesses because they just haven’t been riskless enough. And the fact that it is a cartel helps them. Indeed, there are few companies which own almost all the oil on Earth, and with the billions they make, nobody can control them, and we saw the results. Going beyond this, we can see that even governments see oil as a major issue for their acts. We just saw for example that France decided to attack Libya for the contracts they would get with the new Libyan government. Therefore, we can see that monopolies are not ethically good because that allows companies to use all the ways to make a lot of profits. And this might be done at the expense of thousands of people. We saw it with the BP spill. -------------------------------------------- [ 1 ].......

Words: 478 - Pages: 2

Case Study

...Case Studies on Cardiac Function This is the first case study that is required for the class. Please submit a paper (doesn’t have to be long; you could even give me bullet-point answers to the questions listed below) that answers all of the questions posed after Case Study 1. I have included an easy second case study which, if you complete it, will be worth extra credit. Answers to the first Case Study are worth 25 points and responding to Case Study 1 is required work for the course. The extra credit, which is not required, will be worth a total of 10 points. Please check the syllabus for the due date. Case 1 A.O. is an 89-year-old woman with a long history of systolic heart failure secondary to a large left ventricular infarct when she was in her 70s. She had poor activity tolerance and required assistance with activities of daily living. Even minimal activity was associated with moderately severe dyspnea and exertional chest pain, which was relieved by rest. A.O. also exhibited marked pedal edema bilaterally. She is being treated with digitalis, furosemide (Lasix), KCl, and sublingual nitroglycerin. Discussion Questions 1. Which type of heart failure (left or right sided) is usually associated with dyspnea? What other clinical findings are likely to be present with left-sided heart failure? Left side heart failure is usually associated with dyspnea. Pulmonary congestion, coughing, confusion and oliguria 2. What compensatory mechanisms are likely to...

Words: 753 - Pages: 4

Bp Oil Spill Case Analysis

...BP Oil Spill | Case Study Analysis | | Disclaimer: To start things off, I would like to mention that the BP Oil Spill is an extremely complicated case and its impact could be felt in every corner of the world. Therefore, my case study is only the tip of the iceberg and should not be used to judge the entire controversy. In addition, all statistics and information have been obtained from other sources. Enjoy! | | By: Haikang Zhu | For: Professor Bill WoofClass: Mgmt 1040 DDate: December 9th, 2010 | | BP (British Petroleum) is a global oil and gas company based in London, England. To date, it is the third largest energy company and the fourth largest company in the world in terms of revenues. Bp has operations in over 80 countries, produces around 3.8 million barrels of oil per day and has approximately 22,400 service stations worldwide. One major controversy that has been following every single oil and gas companies is the sustainability of offshore drillings and their impacts on the environment and the potential problems that might occur. Unfortunately for BP, On April 20th 2010, the dreaded problem occurred. The drilling rig known as the Deepwater Horizon Rig exploded, immediately killing 11 men and injuring 17 others. The incident took place in the Gulf of Mexico and is the worst environment disaster in the history after the Exxon Valdez accident in Alaska. The oil spill stemmed from a sea-floor sea gusher and was the result of the explosion of the......

Words: 2679 - Pages: 11

Case Study

...College of Nursing 415 Morga St. Tondo, Manila A Case Study on Acute Pancreatitis Secondary to Cholelithiasis Submitted by: Abad, Edryan Calara, Sharika Loradel Casul Mark Jury Corpuz, Trisha Dela Cruz, Marjori Gamboa, Jonalyn Lebico, Elmarie Lopez, Anica Tapawan, Ansherina Tuazon, Serleen March 09, 2012 Acknowledgement We would like to thank the following to the development of this case study. Mrs. Edna Oraye-Imperial, Dean, PCU – Mary Johnston College of Nursing, for her support and for allowing us to have our related learning experiences in the clinical area that hone our knowledge skills and attitude to be a competent, caring, Christian nurses. Ms. Ma. Lourdes Galima, Clinical Instructor, for continually guiding and supporting us throughout our duty at the Surgery ward, for helping us in enhancing and improving our skills in the area. For the patience that she showed us despite of our attitude and mistakes. Ms. Loreto Vicarme, School Librarian, for allowing us to utilize the library books and references for our case study. To the staff nurses on duty at the Surgery Intensive Care Unit and Ward of Mary Johnston Hospital for the support and providing us with enough information about the routines in the area which we were able to apply. To our fellow group members for their continuous support and sharing their knowledge and experiences for polishing this case study. To the patient, as well as her family members, for......

Words: 8460 - Pages: 34